Vinicius, List: VR: You can make only three moves on the podium. One for the S, one for the relation S-0, and one for the relation S-O-I
What would be the degenerate classes for the S-O (iconic/indexical/symbolic) and S-O-I (abducent/inducent/deducent) relations? Is it feasible instead to make the third move be for the S-I (rheme/dicisign/argument or seme/pheme/delome) relation, as suggested by Peirce's 1903 taxonomy? If so, how would the rules and/or results be different? VR: By following these rules, you will find 66 possible solutions, ten of which have only genuine shadows (these are the 10 genuine classes of signs). The other 56 are degenerate ones. Are these somehow the same 66 classes obtained from ten trichotomies arranged in a logical order of determination? Or is it a different scheme altogether? I assume the latter but would like to confirm. VR: In the second move, the relation of the sign to its object can be ampliative (moving inward). The last move is not ampliative and only extracts the possible consequences of the former. Please elaborate on why the rules are different for these two moves. Perhaps it will be clearer upon identifying the degenerate classes for the two relations. VR: For instance, Tom Short has always promoted the idea that all three interpretants (immediate, dynamic and final) can be of any category. I would say instead that all three interpretants can be in any of the three *universes *(possible/existent/necessitant). These obviously *correspond *to the three categories (1ns/2ns/3ns), but they are not *themselves *the three categories. VR: I agree with him. Most Peirce scholars do not, though (Jappy, for that matter). Really? I have not come across any Peirce scholar (including Jappy) *denying *that there are trichotomies for all three interpretants. In fact, Jappy *includes *those three trichotomies in his "hexad" that produces 28 classes. What am I missing? VR: But then what about the triadic relations? As I stated, the three *genuine *correlates (S, Od, If) are the ones in the *genuine *triadic relation of representing or mediating. In my view, and apparently in Peirce's, there is no distinct trichotomy for Od-S-Id. I see this as a *degenerate *triadic relation, reducible to its constituent *dyadic *relations, which have their own trichotomies (Od-S, S-Id). VR: Peirce seems to use "determine" with different meanings in different MS. Sometimes it seems to mean "determines at least", some others "determines at most". I agree that "determine" has different meanings in different contexts, even within Peirce's writings. Most notably, I believe that "determines" in EP 2:481 means "constrains the potential universe(s) of" for abstract sign classification and *does not* mean "logically and/or temporally precedes" within the concrete process of semiosis. Those who align "the Destinate Interpretant" with the immediate interpretant rather than the final interpretant tend to insist that "determines" must have *both *of these meanings in that particular passage. Again, just from a terminological standpoint, it seems to me that "destinate" and "explicit" are much more congruent with "final" and "immediate" than the other way around. VR: I gave up trying to reconstitute the exact thread of Peirce's proposals (if ever there was a unique and definite thread). His 1903 taxonomy is fairly straightforward and useful as far as it goes, which is probably why it remains popular despite his subsequent revisions. Those later taxonomies are indeed much more difficult to "reconstitute" since they mostly come from various Logic Notebook entries and draft letters. VR: I started a completely new rationale, and that's why I should say that I am a neo-Peircean. Fair enough. I try to maintain Peirce's rationale in certain respects, as well as his terminology, while going my own way where I have trouble making sense of it all otherwise. Regards, Jon Alan Schmidt - Olathe, Kansas, USA Structural Engineer, Synechist Philosopher, Lutheran Christian www.LinkedIn.com/in/JonAlanSchmidt - twitter.com/JonAlanSchmidt On Tue, Nov 9, 2021 at 10:26 AM Vinicius Romanini <[email protected]> wrote: > Jon, list > >> >> [image: image.png] >> >> >> JAS: There are genuine qualisigns (1), sinsigns (2), and legisigns (3); >> degenerate altersigns (1/2) and replicas (2/3); and doubly degenerate >> holisigns (1/2/3). >> >> Exact. I use a different notation: qualisigns (1), sinsigns (2) and > legisigns (3); degenerate altersigns (1') and replicas (2'); and doubly > degenerate holisigns (1"). > Each apostrophe indicates a degree of degeneration. > > I wasn't aware of Marty's Podium. I propose a game: > > 1) You can make only three moves on the podium. One for the S, one for the > relation S-0, and one for the relation S-O-I > 2) In the first move, you can place yourself in any shade at any level. > 3) For the second move, you can either stay in the shade you are in, jump > to any shade without leaving the level where you are, or jump to any level > and shade below. You cannot go up. > 4) For the third and last move, you can either stay in the shade where you > are, move outward to any shade at the level you are, or jump to any level > below provided you land either on the same or an outward relative position. > You cannot go up nor move inward (either staying at your level or jumping > to a lower level) > > By following these rules, you will find 66 possible solutions, ten of > which have only genuine shadows (these are the 10 genuine classes of > signs). The other 56 are degenerate ones. > The rules are different for each move. In the second move, the relation of > the sign to its object can be ampliative (moving inward). The last move is > not ampliative and only extracts the possible consequences of the former. > > JAS: what exactly does it mean to say that "a representamen has 1ns [or > 2ns or 3ns] for its final interpretant"? Perhaps an example of each would > be helpful. > > This is an old debate. It goes back to Gary Sanders's paper. For instance, > Tom Short has always promoted the idea that all three interpretants > (immediate, dynamic and final) can be of any category. I agree with him. > Most Peirce scholars do not, though (Jappy, for that matter). If you > revisit Tom's papers on the Transactions or the debate between Tom and Joe > Ransdell in this list, everything that could be said on this topic has > already been. > No consensus was ever established. > > My view is simple. The final interpretant is how the sign projects itself > in a would-be future. A qualisign can have only firstness for its final > interpretant. > A genuine symbol must have a general for its final interpretant for > otherwise it would not be a true general. > By assuming this view, the study of grammar becomes richer and more > complex but at the same time more logical. > > >> JAS: As I have already discussed in this thread, while >> qualisign/sinsign/legisign are three classes such that each sign is >> assigned to exactly one of them, I see tone/token/type as three >> "dimensions" of the same sign. The sign itself is a continuum, its types >> are its continuous portions of the same dimensionality as definitely >> significant forms, its tokens are its discrete embodiments of lower >> dimensionality that conform to those types, and its tones are indefinitely >> significant characters possessed by those tokens. >> >> I tend to agree. The taxonomy of signs aims at their natural classes. Its > mathematical structure renders them universal. The distinction > type/toke/tone seems more phenomenological. > > JAS: Where I see degeneracy in the later taxonomies is in the initial >> identification of two objects and three interpretants for each sign. >> Referencing Robert's podium diagram again, we have the genuine sign (1), >> dynamical object (2), and final interpretant (3); the degenerate immediate >> object (1/2) and dynamical interpretant (2/3); and the doubly degenerate >> immediate interpretant (1/2/3). Notice that the three genuine correlates >> are the ones in the genuine *triadic *relation of representing or >> mediating.] >> > > OK > >> >> Here the podium diagram reflects other important aspects, as well. The >> immediate object (1/2) and immediate interpretant (1/2/3) are *internal *to >> the sign (1), while the dynamical object (2), dynamical interpretant (2/3), >> and final interpretant (3) are *external *to the sign (1). That is why >> each of the latter three correlates has a *dyadic *relation with the >> sign, unlike the first two. >> > > Agree. But then what about the triadic relations? > > >> The dynamical object (2) determines the immediate object (1/2), and the >> final interpretant (3) determines the dynamical interpretant (2/3), which >> determines the immediate interpretant (1/2/3)--not as efficient causes, >> just in terms of the logical order of trichotomies where "a Possible can >> determine nothing but a Possible" and "a Necessitant can be determined by >> nothing but a Necessitant" (EP 2:481, 1908). This is another reason why I >> maintain that "the Destinate Interpretant" is the final interpretant, not >> the immediate interpretant. >> > > Here is where the confusion begins. Peirce seems to use "determine" with > different meanings in different MS. Sometimes it seems to mean "determines > at least", some others "determines at most". > I gave up trying to reconstitute the exact thread of Peirce's proposals > (if ever there was a unique and definite thread). > I started a completely new rationale, and that's why I should say that I > am a neo-Peircean. > > Regards, > Vinicius >
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ► PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . ► To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message NOT to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with UNSUBSCRIBE PEIRCE-L in the SUBJECT LINE of the message and nothing in the body. More at https://list.iupui.edu/sympa/help/user-signoff.html . ► PEIRCE-L is owned by THE PEIRCE GROUP; moderated by Gary Richmond; and co-managed by him and Ben Udell.
