Vinicius, List:

Thanks for spelling all this out, there is much to ponder here. I have read
your "Minute Semeiotic" material in the past, but it likely warrants
revisiting now that my own ideas about speculative grammar are more
developed.

VR: Most scholars that have dealt with the interpretants assume that
immediate interpretants can be only emotional, dynamic interpretants can be
emotional and energetic and final intepretants can be emotional, energetic
and logical. From what I can recall, at the time I was studying these
matters, only Short was of the opinion that all three of them could be
trichotomized.


My impression is that this debate is not so much about whether the
immediate/dynamical/final interpretants *have *trichotomies--Peirce clearly
thought so, since he included them in his later taxonomies--as whether they
are properly *labeled *within each division as emotional/energetic/logical
interpretants. Until fairly recently, I agreed strongly with Short that
they are, such that these two trichotomies are orthogonal to each other.
However, after carefully studying the only texts where Peirce discusses the
emotional/energetic/logical interpretants--over 500 pages of manuscripts
for an article entitled "Pragmatism" (R 317-322&324, 1907), intended to
introduce his version to a general audience--I now believe that they are
instead the familiar effects of signs that humans routinely experience as
"modifications of consciousness," while the immediate/dynamical/final
interpretants are the *corresponding *effects of signs in general.

I make my case for this in a paper that *Semiotica* recently accepted for
publication, "Peirce's Evolving Interpretants." I also present my position
(as recently discussed on-List) that in EP 2:478 (1906), the intentional
interpretant is a dynamical interpretant of a previous sign in the mind of
the utterer, the effectual interpretant is a dynamical interpretant of the
current (uttered) sign in the mind of the interpreter, and the
communicational interpretant is the immediate interpretant of the current
(uttered) sign in the commind. I originally went on to argue for the
destinate and explicit interpretants in EP 2:481 (1908) being the final and
immediate interpretants, respectively, but the blind reviewer was adamant
that they must be the other way around. I ultimately deleted that whole
section rather than continuing to debate it, since it had to do with
abstract sign classification rather than the concrete process of semiosis.

VR: Well, precisely when Peirce states his order of determination among the
correlates in the Syllabus of 1903, things get confusing. Hartshorne and
Weiss tried in several footnotes to amend Peirce and made things worse (at
least for me).


Indeed, both CP 2.235-242 (EP 2:290) and the accompanying editorial
footnotes are highly problematic. Peirce is right that from a phaneroscopic
standpoint, the first correlate (sign) is the simplest (genuine only), the
third correlate (interpretant) is the most complex (genuine = final,
degenerate = dynamical, doubly degenerate = immediate), and the second
correlate (object) is of middling complexity (genuine = dynamical,
degenerate = immediate). However, he is wrong about the first correlate
"being a mere possibility if any one of the three is of that nature, and
not being a law unless all three are of that nature," as well as the third
correlate "being a law if any one of the three is a law, and not being a
mere possibility unless all three are of that nature." Hartshorne and Weiss
then mix up the second and third correlates *themselves *with their *relations
*to the sign, which are the additional trichotomies that produce the
familiar ten classes in CP 2.243-272 (EP 2:291-299).

In my view, Peirce eventually gets the logical order of the correlates
right in his later taxonomies--the object determines the sign to determine
the interpretant, and the genuine object or interpretant determines the
degenerate object or interpretants. Hence, "the Dynamoid Object determines
the Immediate Object, which determines the Sign itself, which determines
the Destinate [final] Interpretant, which determines the Effective
[dynamical] Interpretant, which determines the Explicit [immediate]
Interpretant" (EP 2:481, 1908). Again, in this context, "determines" means
"constrains the potential universe(s) of," not "causes" or "temporally
precedes." To obtain the ten-trichotomy, 66-class taxonomy, I advocate
inserting the division according to the Od-S relation after the one for the
sign itself and placing the divisions according to the S-If, S-Id, and
Od-S-If relations in that sequence after the one for the immediate
interpretant.

All that said, as I mentioned a few days ago and hinted above, I now agree
with James Liszka (https://doi.org/10.1515/sem-2018-0089) that focusing
on classifying arbitrarily demarcated "individual" signs is misplaced, and
that concentrating instead on the real and continuous process of semiosis
is more fruitful.

Regards,

Jon Alan Schmidt - Olathe, Kansas, USA
Structural Engineer, Synechist Philosopher, Lutheran Christian
www.LinkedIn.com/in/JonAlanSchmidt - twitter.com/JonAlanSchmidt

On Wed, Nov 10, 2021 at 9:48 AM Vinicius Romanini <[email protected]>
wrote:

> Jon, list
>
> JAS: What would be the degenerate classes for the S-O
> (iconic/indexical/symbolic) and S-O-I (abducent/inducent/deducent)
> relations? Is it feasible instead to make the third move be for the S-I
> (rheme/dicisign/argument or seme/pheme/delome) relation, as suggested by
> Peirce's 1903 taxonomy? If so, how would the rules and/or results be
> different?
>
> I call the degenerate index an iedoseme (or ergoseme). Ex: the arrow of a
> rotten weathervane pointing in some direction. Since it is broken, it
> collapses into an icon. When you test the alarm of your car, the sound is
> an ergoseme (for it does not indicate properly).
> I call the symbol degenerated once a metonymy. It is usually a singular
> symbol. Ex: the crown of a king, the papal scepter, your signature on a
> document (the first two are metonymic sinsigns, the latter is a metonymic
> replica)
> I call the symbol degenerated twice a metaphor. No need for examples here.
>
> I call the degenerate dicent a syntax. Ex: the juxtaposition of an image
> and a name. It is a dicisign if you take the juxtaposition as being
> informative, but the mere juxtaposition is the syntax.
> I call the argument degenerated once an induction.
> I call the argument degenerated twice an abduction.
>
> I am not sure that all genuine arguments ard deductions. Peirce seems to
> believe that all genuine general arguments can be reduced to Barbara.
>
> JAS: Are these somehow the same 66 classes obtained from ten trichotomies
> arranged in a logical order of determination? Or is it a different scheme
> altogether? I assume the latter but would like to confirm.
> It is a different scheme. I found 11 trichotomies and their order of
> determination involves periods. The aspects are grouped into periods in a
> way similar to numbers in Mathematics.
> You have the hundreds, the thousands, the millions, and so on.  My periods
> are grounding, presentation, representation, and communication.
> Here is a link to the rationale :
> https://minutesemeiotic.org/XLjO5EL5EYsl6001EwBv
>
> JAS: Please elaborate on why the rules are different for these two moves.
> Perhaps it will be clearer upon identifying the degenerate classes for the
> two relations.
> The second move (S-Od) is where new information is embodied (from the
> dynamic object to the sign), usually through icons and hypoicons.
> The third move can only communicate the information. The interpretant is
> an effect of the relationship S-Od.
>
> JAS: I would say instead that all three interpretants can be in any of the
> three *universes *(possible/existent/necessitant). These obviously *correspond
> *to the three categories (1ns/2ns/3ns), but they are not *themselves *the
> three categories.
> I am happy with that.
>
> JAS: I have not come across any Peirce scholar (including Jappy) *denying
> *that there are trichotomies for all three interpretants. In fact, Jappy 
> *includes
> *those three trichotomies in his "hexad" that produces 28 classes. What
> am I missing?
> Most scholars that have dealt with the interpretants assume that immediate
> interpretants can be only emotional, dynamic interpretants can be emotional
> and energetic and final intepretants can be emotional, energetic and
> logical.
> From what I can recall, at the time I was studying these matters, only
> Short was of the opinion that all three of them could be trichotomized. I
> might be wrong, though.
>
> JAS: As I stated, the three *genuine *correlates (S, Od, If) are the ones
> in the *genuine *triadic relation of representing or mediating. In my
> view, and apparently in Peirce's, there is no distinct trichotomy for
> Od-S-Id. I see this as a *degenerate *triadic relation, reducible to its
> constituent *dyadic *relations, which have their own trichotomies (Od-S,
> S-Id).
> Here is the crucial point. I do think the trichotomy S-Od-Id is a
> necessary aspect for any communication to be effective. Hence my 11
> trichotomies instead of 10.
>
> JAS: I agree that "determine" has different meanings in different
> contexts, even within Peirce's writings. Most notably, I believe that
> "determines" in EP 2:481 means "constrains the potential universe(s) of"
> for abstract sign classification and *does not* mean "logically and/or
> temporally precedes" within the concrete process of semiosis. Those who
> align "the Destinate Interpretant" with the immediate interpretant rather
> than the final interpretant tend to insist that "determines" must have *both
> *of these meanings in that particular passage. Again, just from a
> terminological standpoint, it seems to me that "destinate" and "explicit"
> are much more congruent with "final" and "immediate" than the other way
> around.
> Yes, I agree.
>
> JAS: His 1903 taxonomy is fairly straightforward and useful as far as it
> goes, which is probably why it remains popular despite his subsequent
> revisions. Those later taxonomies are indeed much more difficult to
> "reconstitute" since they mostly come from various Logic Notebook entries
> and draft letters.
> Well, precisely when Peirce states his order of determination among the
> correlates in the Syllabus of 1903, things get confusing. Hartshorne and
> Weiss tried in several footnotes to amend Peirce and made things worse (at
> least for me).
>
> Regards,
> Vinicius
>
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
► PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON 
PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . 
► To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message NOT to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] 
with UNSUBSCRIBE PEIRCE-L in the SUBJECT LINE of the message and nothing in the 
body.  More at https://list.iupui.edu/sympa/help/user-signoff.html .
► PEIRCE-L is owned by THE PEIRCE GROUP;  moderated by Gary Richmond;  and 
co-managed by him and Ben Udell.

Reply via email to