Bernard, List:

Thanks very much for these comments. I am grateful to all the contributors
to this thread, whose posts have been consistently respectful, substantive,
and on-topic--Jack, Gary F., Jeff, Gary R., Mike, Helmut, Phyllis,
Vinicius, Robert, Mary, and now Bernard. Our views diverge when we get down
to many of the details, but we have been able to express those
disagreements without becoming disagreeable.

In this case, I have a different opinion on the logical order of the ten
trichotomies--I see it as Od, Oi, S, Od-S, If, Id, Ii, S-If, S-Id, Od-S-If;
using Peirce's Roman numerals (EP 2:483-490, 1908), III, II, I, IV, VIII,
VI, V, IX, VII, X. The underlying principles are (a) the object determines
the sign to determine the interpretant, (b) the correlates determine their
relations, and (c) each genuine correlate determines its degenerate
correlate(s). The resulting arrangement of the last six divisions produces
a taxonomy of sign classes that generally makes sense to me, more so than
any of the alternatives.

   - A temperative (purpose of If is to produce self-control) can be a
   usual (Id is a further sign), a percussive (Id is an action), or a
   sympathetic (Id is a feeling), while a gratific can only be a sympathetic.
   - A usual can be a relative (EG requires at least two lines of
   identity), a categorical (at least one line of identity), or a hypothetic
   (no lines of identity), while a sympathetic can only be a hypothetic.
   - A relative can be an argument/delome, a proposition/dicisign/pheme, or
   a term/rheme/seme, while a hypothetic can only be a term/rheme/seme.
   - An argument/delome can be an indicative (submitted), an imperative
   (urged), or a suggestive (presented), while a term/rheme/seme can only be a
   suggestive (cf. CP 8.338, 1904).
   - An indicative can be a deducent (assurance of form), an inducent
   (assurance of experience), or an abducent (assurance of instinct), while a
   suggestive can only be an abducent.

As for the normal interpretant, I have mentioned previously that I take
"normal" in this context to mean "normative" rather than "in accordance
with the usual course of things," such that it is equivalent to the final
interpretant in the sense of a *final cause*, as well as the destinate
interpretant in the sense of the sign's *destined *effect after infinite
inquiry by an infinite community. Peirce prepared the entries for both
"normal" and "normative" in the *Century Dictionary*, and his definitions
are consistent with viewing these terms as nearly synonymous (
http://triggs.djvu.org/century-dictionary.com/djvu2jpgframes.php?volno=05&page=461
).

*normal, **a. **1.* According to a rule, principle, or norm; conforming to
established law, order, habit, or usage: conforming with a certain type or
standard: not abnormal; regular; natural.

*2.* Serving to fix a standard; intended to set a standard

*normative, **a. *Establishing or setting up a norm, or standard which
ought to be conformed to.


Regards,

Jon Alan Schmidt - Olathe, Kansas, USA
Structural Engineer, Synechist Philosopher, Lutheran Christian
www.LinkedIn.com/in/JonAlanSchmidt - twitter.com/JonAlanSchmidt

On Thu, Nov 11, 2021 at 12:25 PM Bernard Morand <[email protected]>
wrote:

> JAS, Vinicius, List
>
> Le 10/11/2021 à 20:50, Jon Alan Schmidt a écrit :
> >
> > In my view, Peirce eventually gets the logical order of the
> correlates right in his later taxonomies--the object determines the sign
> to determine the interpretant, and the genuine object or
> interpretant determines the degenerate object or interpretants. Hence,
> "the Dynamoid Object determines the Immediate Object, which determines
> the Sign itself, which determines the Destinate [final] Interpretant, which
> determines the Effective [dynamical] Interpretant, which determines the
> Explicit [immediate] Interpretant" (EP 2:481, 1908). Again, in this
> context, "determines" means "constrains the potential universe(s) of," not
> "causes" or "temporally precedes." To obtain the ten-trichotomy, 66-class
> taxonomy, I advocate inserting the division according to the Od-S relation
> after the one for the sign itself and placing the divisions according to
> the S-If, S-Id, and Od-S-If relations in that sequence after the one for
> the immediate interpretant.
> >
> > All that said, as I mentioned a few days ago and hinted above, I
> now agree with James Liszka (https://doi.org/10.1515/sem-2018-0089)
> that focusing on classifying arbitrarily demarcated "individual"
> signs is misplaced, and that concentrating instead on the real and
> continuous process of semiosis is more fruitful.
> >
> Jon, it seems to me that you reach a similar conclusion as mine about the
> organisation of the second division of signs.
>
> As this conclusion may appear quite disturbing to many readers, the
> agreement is worth noticing.
>
> I published it in French in a book entitled "Logique de la Conception.
> Figures de sémiotique générale d'après C.S. Peirce." (L'Harmattan, Paris)
> in 2004.
>
> I join in attached file a schema (Fig. 14 p. 228 of the book) that shows
> how I think the classification of 1903 and the second one are articulated:
> the first (on the right of the figure) is embodied into the second on the
> left).
>
> The second classification adds the ordered divisions VIII, VII, VI, V
> which are an unfolding of the basic original division relative to the
> interpretant of the sign.
>
> At the other end, the additional divisions III, II relative to the Object
> of the sign remained hidden in the previous first division relative to the
> Sign itself.
>
> Finally another division, X, has been inserted into the table to mark the
> actual effect of the final interpretant.
>
> This latter consideration makes me doubt that the Final interpretant in
> its usual peircean sense may be there: its place is taken by the "Normal"
> Interpretant which I interpret as normal or usual course of things (Not
> what can be supposed to be reached in the long run and thus not yet
> actually known). This I think is the very sense of "Destinate". I came to
> the ordering shown in the Fig. 14 of divisions III -> II -> I -> IV -> X ->
> IX -> VIII -> VII -> VI -> V after recognizing the construction Peirce used
> in his own labelling of these divisions.
>
> I totally agree too with the remark from Liszka that you are quoting.
>
> Apologies for the french language in the added figure.
>
> Regards
>
> Bernard Morand
>
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
► PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON 
PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . 
► To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message NOT to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] 
with UNSUBSCRIBE PEIRCE-L in the SUBJECT LINE of the message and nothing in the 
body.  More at https://list.iupui.edu/sympa/help/user-signoff.html .
► PEIRCE-L is owned by THE PEIRCE GROUP;  moderated by Gary Richmond;  and 
co-managed by him and Ben Udell.

Reply via email to