----- Original Message ----- From: "Carrol Cox" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> > Yes I did: I said that it is not a legitimate question, and therefore > has no answer, simple or complicated. When it comes up as a legitimate > question, it would come up in the course of collective practice, and > would be answered in the contgext of that practice. ======================== Who the hell are you to unilaterally -- no, monopolistically -- decide what is and is not a legitimate question on this list? Is this list not a manifestation of a collective practice or are we, in your readings of post on this list, all solipsistic-monadic deceptive avatars engaged in a multilogue of the willfully misinterpretive? > > What would an "ennobling emotion" be? And would it exist in the > abstract? The same "emotion" (i.e. the same bodily state) would in > different circustances give rise to quite different complexes of thought > and feeling, and it would be the feelings/thoughts, not the emotion, > that could then, _in that context_, be discussed. > > Carrol > ==================== You used to be a teacher and you don't know what an ennobling emotion is? An ennobling thought -- thinking that ennobles, enables and empowers Others -- you don't know what those are? Gone, Ian
