--- Louis Proyect <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> Cuba abolished capitalism in the early 1960s, but
> this is not the
> case with the other countries you cite.

How does one abolish a global system?!  The Cuban
revolution might be a historical manifestation of
anti-capitalist struggle, but the statement "Cuba
abolished capitalism" is exactly the sort of problem
with is/is-not thinking.

> I am far more interested in providing a class
> analysis of Cuba

Class is a secondary, maybe even tertiary question.
Expropriating the "capitalists" is all good, but
supressing the law of value would seem to be more
central.  Cuba seems to be doing a good job of holding
out so far, but it's precisely the nature of
capitalism as a global system that makes resisting
that pressure so difficult.

> Of course, if you'd prefer to cite swaths of the
> Grundrisse, be my
> guest. I much prefer to look at concrete cases.

Nothing against empirical research.  But you don't
necessarily need Marx for that (I'm sorry if that
sounds condescending, I mean it as neutral as
possible).



__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com

Reply via email to