ok, no one bothered to point out my obvious mistake in the order lon/lat in the Polygon query...

Aside from that, I just double checked the SRIDs, dropped and reloaded the GIST indexes for both the POINT and MULTIPOLYGON tables, both in 4326, vacuumed and vacuumed again.

The basic question still stands - if I dont SetSRID(), I get a mixed SRID error msg with the SetSRID(), the Points in Polys takes 10 seconds to execute. That seems like a long time.

Is this expected performance?
Mac OS 10.10,  Powerbook 1ghz g4, decent 54gb internal drive

Why the mixed SRIDs error without the explicit calls?


SELECT gectable.name
FROM just_ca, gectable
WHERE
        just_ca.city = 'Berkeley'
AND
 st_within( SetSRID(gectable.geom_pts2,4326),
  SetSRID( just_ca.the_geom,4326))

this takes 10 seconds on 110,000 points (and 12 polys in city Berkeley).
(I added a GIST index on geom_pts2 and the_geom, and the query took
the same amount of time as without indexes. just_ca.city = 'Berkeley' alone
takes just 4ms)

The following query gets a mixed SRID error

SELECT gectable.name
FROM just_ca, gectable
WHERE
        just_ca.city = 'Berkeley'
AND
 st_within(  gectable.geom_pts2, just_ca.the_geom )

why??

_______________________________________________
postgis-users mailing list
[email protected]
http://postgis.refractions.net/mailman/listinfo/postgis-users

Reply via email to