On Sunday 15 October 2006 19:53, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
> HI, I (better my computer) am actually contributing to GIMPS prime research
> using prime25
> ver. 24.14 software.
> Intermediate algorithm statistic results are displayed as :[date  time]
> Factoring.........up to ..
> Should it not be Factorizing ?
> This does evidently not affect the quality and performance of the 
> algorithm nor the image of
> the GIMPS community,but just for the mathematical rigor!
> Please let me know about my concern, i.e. if I'm wright or wrong?

Actually both are wrong, in my opinion the text should be

Searching for factors of ... up to ...

or

Checking ... for factors up to ...

The point being that factoring (or factorizing, which sounds wrong to me and 
which my English (UK) spell checker has just objected to!) would apply to a 
number which is already known to be composite.

However I can see the point in keeping these status messages as short as 
possible, and there isn't really any ambiguity as a consequence of the 
existing text. Pedantry is a poor reason for fixing it.

Regards
Brian Beesley
_______________________________________________
Prime mailing list
[email protected]
http://hogranch.com/mailman/listinfo/prime

Reply via email to