Pak Syaf Jikok ambo yang di mandatkan untuak maundang, tolong kirimkan bara urang nan ka hadir dan tanggal bara perkiraannyo. Bia ambo siapkan.
Salam andiko Pada 6 Januari 2011 10.43, Dr Saafroedin Bahar < [email protected]> menulis: > Batua Riri, bung Andi Ko memang merencanakan mengundang urang Oxfam utk > manjalehkan hasil riset tu. Ambo harokkan Riri bisa hadir mengkritisi. Jadi > kito adokan tigo tahap: kito jo Oxfam; ditambah jo agt DPR dan DPD kaduonyo > di Jkt; dilanjuikkan di Padang. Nan di Jkt bisa dipalaweh jo komunitas > RantauNet dan Gebu Minang. Nan di Padang jo para stakeholders. Baa pandapek > Riri? > > Saafroedin Bahar. Taqdir di tangan Allah swt, nasib di tangan kita. > ------------------------------ > *From: * "Riri Mairizal Chaidir" <[email protected]> > *Sender: * [email protected] > *Date: *Thu, 6 Jan 2011 08:30:04 +0700 > *To: *<[email protected]> > *ReplyTo: * [email protected] > *Subject: *RE: [...@ntau-net] TEMUAN OXFAM TENTANG KONDISI KESIAPAN MITIGASI > KEBENCANAAN DI SUMBAR > > Pak Saaf dan Dunsanak Sadonyo. > > > > Maaf, kalau manuruik ambo, kalau memang akan diadakan suatu diskusi > mendalam dengan berbagai pihak, ada baiknya kita baca dulu pelan2 Laporan > Hasil Risetnya secara utuh, tidak cuma Summary dan Recommendationnya. > > > > Kalau yang saya pahami – dari Report itu – mereka melakukan studi atas > kebijakan Pemerintah. Kesimpulan mereka, Public Awareness itu sudah merupaka > prioritas. Hanya saja, dalam hal warning system nya lebih banyak ke masalah > teknologi dibandingkan sosio ekonomi. > > > > Tapi bisa saja saya pemahaman saya salah. > > > > Kalau saya (lagi2 kalau), dibandingkan terburu2 berdiskusi, apalagi dalam > format besar (dengan mengundang Anggota DPR, DPD), langkah pertama adalah, > bertemu dengan Researcher nya, minta beliau menjelaskan penelitiannya. > > > > Nah, dari situ – seandainya kita akan merefer ke Penelititan itu – baru > kita pertimbangkan apakah mau mengadakan diskusi dalam lingkup yang lebih > luas, atau cukup dengan “mengingatkan” Pemerintah bahwa ada hasil penelitian > begini lho … > > > > Maaf, itu Cuma pendapat saya > > > > > > Riri > > 48/L/BEkasi > > > > > > > > > > *From:* [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] *On > Behalf Of *Dr. Saafroedin BAHAR > *Sent:* Wednesday, January 05, 2011 8:46 PM > *To:* rantaunet rantaunet rantaunet > *Cc:* Asril H. Tanjung; Muhammad Jamil; Mochtar Naim; Farhan Muin DATUK > BAGINDO; Djohermansyah Djohan; Prof. Dr Azyumardi AZRA; Irman GUSMAN; > Dutamardin Umar; Khairul Jasmi; andi ko > *Subject:* [...@ntau-net] TEMUAN OXFAM TENTANG KONDISI KESIAPAN MITIGASI > KEBENCANAAN DI SUMBAR > > > > Assalamualaikum w.w. para sanak sapalanta, > > Di bawah ini saya kutipkan hasil riset Oxfam -- yang di-upload oleh bung > Andi Ko -- tentang tingkat kesiagaan dua daerah dalam mitigasi bencana, > yaitu Jawa Barat dan Sumatera Barat. Intinya sama, bahwa kedua daerah ini > sesungguhnya tidak siap, dan bahwa pelibatan masyarakat belum intensif. > > > > Sudah barang tentu hasil riset tersebut bukan sekedar untuk dibaca, tetapi > untuk ditindaklanjuti. Dalam SKM GM yang lalu masalah kebencanaan ini juga > termasuk mata acara,yang setelah dibahas, ya kesimpulannya sama. > > > > Saya telah mendorong bung Andi Ko untuk menindaklajutinya, antara lain > dengan membahasnya secara lebih mendalam. Bung Andi Ko menyarankan agar > pembahasan diadakan di Padang. Saya setuju. > > > > Sebelum di Padang, saya berpendapat agar diadakan dahulu di Jakarta, > khususnya oleh karena yang dibutuhkan adalah investasi untuk infrastruktur > mitigasi, yang tentu saja perlu dikaitkan dengan APBN. > > > > Saya menginginkan agar kita mengundang 19 orang anggota DPR RI dan empat > anggota DPD yang berasal dari Sumatera Barat untuk dimintakan komitmennya. > [Beliau-beliau kan pemegang amanah masyarakat Sumatera Barat]. > > > > Siapa yang akan mengundang ? Kalau tidak ada yang siap, saya akan > mengunsulkan agar Gebu Minang mengambil prakarsa. > > > > Bagaimana pendapat para sanak sapalanta ? > > > > > Wassalam, > Saafroedin Bahar Soetan Madjolelo > > (Laki-laki, Tanjung, masuk 74 th, Jakarta) > > Taqdir di tangan Allah, nasib di tangan kita. > > > > *The study’s findings and conclusions are as follows:* > > > > - The priority of DRR investments in West Java and West Sumatra is > mostly in public awareness, disaster education and training. The main > actors > who invest in DRR are government and NGOs (INGO and local NGO). > > > > - Gender mainstreaming is still found to be rare in both provinces > although NGOs are found to be more sensitive to gender. Therefore > cooperation between government and NGOs may make more gender sensitive > programs. > > > > - The Ministry of Women Empowerment (MOWE) does not have capacity to > mainstream gender in government programs. This is because the MOWE > authority > is limited. Similarly, the agency of women empowerment’s power is also > limited to districts and large cities. As a result risk reduction measures > are less effective for women as risk assessments are not gender sensitive. > > > > - *The number of victims in West Sumatera was still substantial, > largely due to the collapsing of buildings This shows that structural > mitigation is still not of high importance to the government* > > > > - Most investment tends to focus on specific types of hazards, with > earthquakes and tsunamis having the highest investment. This shows an > imbalance in investment between earthquakes and tsunamis and other types of > hazards. > > > > - *Disaster education while conducted at some formal education > institutions (public schools) is still limited. Disaster education, > however, > is not being taught at informal education institutions, such as courses. > * > > > > - EWS tend to emphasize the technological components of the warning > systems and are not people centred. Applied research on DRR is still > limited. *Most of the research is found on physical modelling of > hazards with only limited on socio-economic issues.* > > > > - The involvement of the private sector is very limited. > > > > - NGOs traditionally work in rural areas but not in urban areas. > > > > - *Government policies on disaster management are not based on strong > risk assessment.* > > > > - Participatory projects have been seen to be effective as a result of > the increased awareness of the communities. *However, the participation > of the communities is still limited. Therefore, more investment must be > done > to ensure community active role in disaster risk reduction activities.* > > > > *Several recommendations were suggested:* > > > > - *The scale of investment must consider the size of population and > area vulnerable to disaster. The current scale of investment is not yet > meeting the needs and must be expanded.* > > > > - *Investment should also cover sectors that traditionally not > addressed by NGOs, such as structural mitigation that requires skills and > bigger resources and stronger regulation. This can be addressed by > improving > the enabling environment, including laws and building codes and involving > more actors that have the competence , e.g. private sectors.* > > > > - Ministry of Women Empowerment and Children Protection should be > supported to enable them to advocate for the mainstreaming of gender into > DRR and emergency response. At the same time, NGOs, especially gender > focused NGOs, should also work more closely and advocate the newly > established BPBDs to mainstream gender into their organizations and > programmes. > > > > - *Good lessons from participatory DRR projects should be scaled up to > other vulnerable communities.* > > > > - *To speed up the disaster management institutions and legislation to > vulnerable districts, awareness and education should target decision makers > (legislative and executive). The established BPBDs should strengthen their > coordination function and leadership.* > > > > - Education should not only cover formal education but also informal > education. This is not only on knowledge but also on the structural > mitigation and safety. Disaster education should also include knowledge of > secondary hazards (e.g. landslides and fires can be induced by > earthquakes). > > > > - *Risk analysis should be used as a foundation for any disaster risk > reduction investments. The results from individual project risk analysis > (by > community based approach) should be used to fit with the government risk > analysis. On the other level, BPBDs should develop participatory risk > analysis mechanisms to enable more systematic and comprehensive risk > reduction systems. To ensure synchronization of various risk analysis > methodology, BPBD should conduct dialogue (such as DRR Forum) on risk > analysis and gender sensitive indicators.* > > > > - *Existing EWS should strengthen their community components and cover > the other prominent hazards (floods and landslides).* > > > > - More social research into disaster risk reductions. Funding for > social research in disaster risk reduction should be increased > > > > - *All investments will require additional financial and other > resources. Government and donors should increase their financial support > but > also it is important to identify alternative sources of funds, for example: > the potential use of climate change adaptation funds.* > > > > -- > > > > -- > . > * Posting yg berasal dari Palanta RantauNet, dipublikasikan di tempat lain > wajib mencantumkan sumber: ~dari Palanta r...@ntaunet > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/~<http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/%7E> > * Isi email, menjadi tanggung jawab pengirim email. > =========================================================== > UNTUK DIPERHATIKAN, melanggar akan dimoderasi: > - DILARANG: > 1. E-mail besar dari 200KB; > 2. E-mail attachment, tawarkan di sini & kirim melalui jalur pribadi; > 3. One Liner. > - Anggota WAJIB mematuhi peraturan serta mengirim biodata! Lihat di: > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/web/peraturan-rantaunet > - Tulis Nama, Umur & Lokasi disetiap posting > - Hapus footer & seluruh bagian tdk perlu dlm melakukan reply > - Untuk topik/subjek baru buat email baru, tdk mereply email lama & > mengganti subjeknya. > =========================================================== > Berhenti, bergabung kembali, mengubah konfigurasi/setting keanggotaan di: > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/subscribe. > > -- > . > * Posting yg berasal dari Palanta RantauNet, dipublikasikan di tempat lain > wajib mencantumkan sumber: ~dari Palanta r...@ntaunet > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/~<http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/%7E> > * Isi email, menjadi tanggung jawab pengirim email. > =========================================================== > UNTUK DIPERHATIKAN, melanggar akan dimoderasi: > - DILARANG: > 1. E-mail besar dari 200KB; > 2. E-mail attachment, tawarkan di sini & kirim melalui jalur pribadi; > 3. One Liner. > - Anggota WAJIB mematuhi peraturan serta mengirim biodata! Lihat di: > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/web/peraturan-rantaunet > - Tulis Nama, Umur & Lokasi disetiap posting > - Hapus footer & seluruh bagian tdk perlu dlm melakukan reply > - Untuk topik/subjek baru buat email baru, tdk mereply email lama & > mengganti subjeknya. > =========================================================== > Berhenti, bergabung kembali, mengubah konfigurasi/setting keanggotaan di: > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/subscribe. > > -- > . > * Posting yg berasal dari Palanta RantauNet, dipublikasikan di tempat lain > wajib mencantumkan sumber: ~dari Palanta r...@ntaunet > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/~<http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/%7E> > * Isi email, menjadi tanggung jawab pengirim email. > =========================================================== > UNTUK DIPERHATIKAN, melanggar akan dimoderasi: > - DILARANG: > 1. E-mail besar dari 200KB; > 2. E-mail attachment, tawarkan di sini & kirim melalui jalur pribadi; > 3. One Liner. > - Anggota WAJIB mematuhi peraturan serta mengirim biodata! Lihat di: > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/web/peraturan-rantaunet > - Tulis Nama, Umur & Lokasi disetiap posting > - Hapus footer & seluruh bagian tdk perlu dlm melakukan reply > - Untuk topik/subjek baru buat email baru, tdk mereply email lama & > mengganti subjeknya. > =========================================================== > Berhenti, bergabung kembali, mengubah konfigurasi/setting keanggotaan di: > http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/subscribe. > -- . * Posting yg berasal dari Palanta RantauNet, dipublikasikan di tempat lain wajib mencantumkan sumber: ~dari Palanta r...@ntaunet http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/~ * Isi email, menjadi tanggung jawab pengirim email. =========================================================== UNTUK DIPERHATIKAN, melanggar akan dimoderasi: - DILARANG: 1. E-mail besar dari 200KB; 2. E-mail attachment, tawarkan di sini & kirim melalui jalur pribadi; 3. One Liner. - Anggota WAJIB mematuhi peraturan serta mengirim biodata! Lihat di: http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/web/peraturan-rantaunet - Tulis Nama, Umur & Lokasi disetiap posting - Hapus footer & seluruh bagian tdk perlu dlm melakukan reply - Untuk topik/subjek baru buat email baru, tdk mereply email lama & mengganti subjeknya. =========================================================== Berhenti, bergabung kembali, mengubah konfigurasi/setting keanggotaan di: http://groups.google.com/group/RantauNet/subscribe.
