Philip Meyer;379730 Wrote: 
> >One thing that I've done in my library is to define an ALBUMARTIST for
> >_every_ non-compilation album, even when it's exactly the same as the
> >artist on every track.  With the way SqueezeCenter works to determine
> >the artist to display for each album, this makes the interface a
> little
> >quicker.  Without an album artist, SC looks at the artists from every
> >track in an album.  On a web page with, say, 50 albums, SqueezeCenter
> >does 100s of db queries.  With an album artist defined, it just needs
> >to do one query per album.  Still not ideal - it should be doable
> with
> >a single query that pulls all the albums on a page.
> >
> 
> Interesting.  It shouldn't be any different.  At scan time, a single
> contributor is stored in the album record.

I believe this contributor column is used for nothing other than
sorting albums by artist (and consequently, the alpha pagebar).  When
it comes to _displaying_ the artist for an album, every track is
examined, unless there's an ALBUMARTIST.

> It's also stored in the album to contributors link table, where there
> are more than one album artist contributor, but that can still be
> returned in a single query.

It's not used for displaying the artist name.

> Having an albumartist for regular albums changes the behaviour subtlely
> I think, as the songs will have track artist roles, not artist roles. 
> You also get the artist listed twice (on an album context "Artist:" and
> "Album Artist:", and in track context "Artist:" and "Track Artist:").

You're right, there are subtle consequences.  For instance, I have an
album by B.B. King and Eric Clapton, that I've tagged:

ALBUMARTIST=B.B. Kind & Eric Clapton
ARTIST=B.B. King
ARTIST=Eric Clapton

So I end up with another artist in my artist list, as though it where a
common ensemble name, like 'Simon & Garfunkel', which it isn't. 
Probably the biggest drawback that I've found is that there's no
ALBUMARTISTSORT tag recognized, so I have a little less control over
how albums are sorted by artist name.


-- 
JJZolx

Jim
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JJZolx's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=10
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=57594

_______________________________________________
ripping mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/ripping

Reply via email to