HI Authors,
Comment 1:
In below topology if [R] is the local root of the topology, Block id of R is 0
and Block ID of all other nodes in the topology as per psudo-code, I feel it
should be 0/1 for all.
When Assign_Block_ID is invoked, root gets the blockid 0, then since first DFS
child local root is GADAG root block id is incremented to 1 and assigned, for
all other DFS child block-id
Is assigned without incrementing it gets the value 1.
[E]----|
(5,0) |
| |
| |
[R] [D]---[C]
(0,0) (4,0) (3,0)
| |
| |
[A]---------[B]
(1,0) (2,0)
global_var: max_block_id
Assign_Block_ID(x, cur_block_id)
x.block_id = cur_block_id
foreach DFS child c of x
if (c.local_root is x)
max_block_id += 1
Assign_Block_ID(c, max_block_id)
else
Assign_Block_ID(c, cur_block_id)
max_block_id = 0
Assign_Block_ID(gadag_root, max_block_id)
Comment 2: "This is necessary for the DFS in
Lowpoint_Visit above, where the selection order of the interfaces to
explore results in different trees."
This sentence can be changed,
"This is necessary for the DFS in Lowpoint_Visit as per section 4.3. , where
the
selection order of the interfaces to explore results in different trees."
5.1. Interface Ordering
To ensure consistency in computation, all routers MUST order
interfaces identically down to the set of links with the same metric
to the same neighboring node. This is necessary for the DFS in
Lowpoint_Visit above, where the selection order of the interfaces to
explore results in different trees. Consistent interface ordering is
also necessary for computing the GADAG, where the selection order of
the interfaces to use to form ears can result in different GADAGs.
It is also necessary for the topological sort described in
Section 5.8, where different topological sort orderings can result in
undirected links being added to the GADAG in different directions.
Thanks & Regards
Anil S N
"Be liberal in what you accept, and conservative in what you send" - Jon Postel
_______________________________________________
rtgwg mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rtgwg
