I'm afraid I won't have a clear answer right now, but will try to help at least where I can.

On 09/16/2016 04:11 AM, Noah Kantrowitz wrote:
Okay, to get the disclaimer out of the way, I understand that SCLo/CentOS 
packages are not supported by RedHat. I'm trying to get my Chef SCL code to 
work on RHEL again (CentOS works great via centos-release-scl). The official 
(from what I can tell) solution is `subscription-manager repos --enable 
rhel-server-rhscl-{6,7}-rpms`. The problem is this fails on most cloud-y RHEL 
installs as the EC2/Rackspace/whatever images don't come with a subscription 
setup and thus even though they (I think, the cloud licenses are weird and 
bespoke) could use the SCL subscription, the system won't allow it.

So, are you're hitting the issue described in https://access.redhat.com/solutions/1120983?

EC2 has a (custom?) solution for this with a local RHUI server in each region 
that can be used to set up the SCL repository. This server is not reachable 
from outside EC2 though, so doesn't help on other cloud platforms.

It seems like the solution above does work for EC2 but not for other providers, right? In any case, I'd recommend to contact RH support, they already might have seen issues like this and might have a solution.

The next thing I thought to try is to use the SCLo/CentOS repositories directly 
for cloud users as they probably don't care too much about support or they 
would have set up a subscription. I can't figure out a stable way to do that 
though. From https://github.com/sclorg/centos-release-scl, I can do 
 but this only activates the sclo/ repo, not rh/ so I can't install the 
recompiles of the RHSCL packages (i.e. most of them).

The problem I have with this particular solution is that SCLo packages from CentOS were never meant to be run on RHEL, nobody tests them on RHEL and simply said for RHEL the solution is RHSCL channel. Although I understand you might be frustrated by not being able to do it simply the correct way..

I could set the http://mirror.centos.org/centos/6/sclo/x86_64/rh/ repository 
manually, but I would need a copy of the GPG to import. I've filed 
https://bugs.centos.org/view.php?id=11468 to request the GPG key be made 
available via centos.org but I would imagine any changes there will take some 

So with that wall of text, what's the best way to get SCL packages on RedHat 
for _all_ RHEL users?

That's exactly which way we should focus on, but I'm not able to help right now, since I don't have enough information about it. I'll try to fill gaps in my knowledge, but as mentioned above, I'd recommend to contact the RH support with this problem.


SCLorg mailing list

SCLorg mailing list

Reply via email to