Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
Of all the ones who voted +1 is there someone who's going to do something about it? Pier
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
On Thu, 17 May 2001, Pier P. Fumagalli wrote: Of all the ones who voted +1 is there someone who's going to do something about it? What do you mean by that ? To move the code in jakarata-tomcat-connectors? I guess most of the people who voted +1 are going to work on jakarta-tomcat-connectors or are alredy doing so. We already agreed that the webapp configuration stuff is going to be integrated into mod_jk, and I'm sure we'll take a look at the warp protocol - either as an additional protocol for mod_jk, or to merge it with ajp14. Costin
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
[EMAIL PROTECTED] at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Thu, 17 May 2001, Pier P. Fumagalli wrote: Of all the ones who voted +1 is there someone who's going to do something about it? What do you mean by that ? To move the code in jakarata-tomcat-connectors? I guess most of the people who voted +1 are going to work on jakarta-tomcat-connectors or are alredy doing so. We already agreed that the webapp configuration stuff is going to be integrated into mod_jk, and I'm sure we'll take a look at the warp protocol - either as an additional protocol for mod_jk, or to merge it with ajp14. I mean that someone (Henri) asked to vote on moving the code of webapp from the jakarta-tomcat-4.0 to the jakarta-tomcat-connectors CVS repository. A bunch of people (including you) voted +1 on that proposal (not me), so, if the guys who voted +1 want to do that, please do so (three days passed, vote is up, with a bunch of +1 - more than three - one 0 - mine - and no -1). Otherwise, you guys do whatever you want (as always)... Bah... Sometimes I just _love_ my f***in' limbo where I seclude myself and do whatever I want... Pier
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
[EMAIL PROTECTED] at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: [+1] Let's move mod_webapp and all its related stuff in jakarta-connectors. +1 The stuff is not ready ( neither the new mod_jk for 4.0 nor mod_webapp ), and when it is - tomcat-dev should decide which one will be used in 4.0. Isn't it how it works ? Yeah, however that doesn't force anyone to give up his work, or should we start debating on 3.x being a dead end??? :) :) :) This way it'll be fair - and you'll get your code used because and if it'll be better than mod_jk, not because it is the default for 4.0. Ok, I'm going to shut up now otherwise we'll end up in the same old flamewar. What-EVER. Pier
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
On Wed, 16 May 2001, Pier P. Fumagalli wrote: [EMAIL PROTECTED] at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: [+1] Let's move mod_webapp and all its related stuff in jakarta-connectors. +1 The stuff is not ready ( neither the new mod_jk for 4.0 nor mod_webapp ), and when it is - tomcat-dev should decide which one will be used in 4.0. Isn't it how it works ? Yeah, however that doesn't force anyone to give up his work, or should we start debating on 3.x being a dead end??? :) :) :) I don't think there is anything to debate about that. All we know is that we have a release plan for a 3.3 release, a plan for a 4.0 release using a different code base - and commiters will decide what code base will be used for 5.0 ( it may be a completely different one - who knows ? ). Anyone is free to try new ideas - and to ignore existing code and reinvent the weels. And anyone is free to choose the codebase he thing has the best chances for long-term and work on it. But tomcat-dev must decide what is used in a certain release - and making mod_webapp the default for 4.0 is not fair. When you feel it's ready we can of course vote on it - and if indeed it's better I would be happy to use it in 3.x also. I believe mod_jk has more chances - so that's where I'll put my free development time ( if I find any :-). Costin This way it'll be fair - and you'll get your code used because and if it'll be better than mod_jk, not because it is the default for 4.0. Ok, I'm going to shut up now otherwise we'll end up in the same old flamewar. What-EVER.
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
[EMAIL PROTECTED] at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Wed, 16 May 2001, Pier P. Fumagalli wrote: [EMAIL PROTECTED] at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: [+1] Let's move mod_webapp and all its related stuff in jakarta-connectors. +1 The stuff is not ready ( neither the new mod_jk for 4.0 nor mod_webapp ), and when it is - tomcat-dev should decide which one will be used in 4.0. Isn't it how it works ? Yeah, however that doesn't force anyone to give up his work, or should we start debating on 3.x being a dead end??? :) :) :) I don't think there is anything to debate about that. All we know is that we have a release plan for a 3.3 release, a plan for a 4.0 release using a different code base - and commiters will decide what code base will be used for 5.0 ( it may be a completely different one - who knows ? ). Anyone is free to try new ideas - and to ignore existing code and reinvent the weels. And anyone is free to choose the codebase he thing has the best chances for long-term and work on it. But tomcat-dev must decide what is used in a certain release - and making mod_webapp the default for 4.0 is not fair. When you feel it's ready we can of course vote on it - and if indeed it's better I would be happy to use it in 3.x also. I believe mod_jk has more chances - so that's where I'll put my free development time ( if I find any :-). One cannot even write a little joke that someone will start nitpicking him... Bah... Apparently smileys got lost in my message... Pier
web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
What about importing the mod_webapp code in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ? There is allready jk stuff (native, java), we could also have here a 'wa' subdir jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/apache-1.3/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/apache-2.0/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/include/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/java/ The idea is to provide to new users a common area when he's looking for web-server to servlet-engine connectors. - Henri Gomez ___[_] EMAIL : [EMAIL PROTECTED](. .) PGP KEY : 697ECEDD...oOOo..(_)..oOOo... PGP Fingerprint : 9DF8 1EA8 ED53 2F39 DC9B 904A 364F 80E6
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
GOMEZ Henri at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What about importing the mod_webapp code in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ? There is allready jk stuff (native, java), we could also have here a 'wa' subdir jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/apache-1.3/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/apache-2.0/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/include/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/java/ The idea is to provide to new users a common area when he's looking for web-server to servlet-engine connectors. Bah... I don't see any advantage for that, but you're more than welcome to do it. Actually, let's ask to the list: [+1] Let's move mod_webapp and all its related stuff in jakarta-connectors. [ 0] I don't give a damn. [-1] Keep it where it is because (please explain) Pier: 0
RE: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/apache-1.3/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/apache-2.0/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/include/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/java/ The idea is to provide to new users a common area when he's looking for web-server to servlet-engine connectors. Bah... I don't see any advantage for that, but you're more than welcome to do it. Actually, let's ask to the list: [+1] Let's move mod_webapp and all its related stuff in jakarta-connectors. [ 0] I don't give a damn. [-1] Keep it where it is because (please explain) Pier: 0 Didn't the jakarta-tomcat-connectors goal is to remove the connectors stuff from the servlet-engine code ? +1 in that case.
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
[+1] Let's move mod_webapp and all its related stuff in jakarta-connectors. [ 0] I don't give a damn. [-1] Keep it where it is because (please explain) +1 i'm of the opinion that the core parts of connectors should be servlet container agnostic and separate from any container. also, i think if webapp and warp (or the core parts of it) were moved outside of tomcat 4, a lot of people would be happier when tomcat 5 hits the streets and a connector is needed :)
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
On Tue, 15 May 2001, Pier P. Fumagalli wrote: GOMEZ Henri at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What about importing the mod_webapp code in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ? There is allready jk stuff (native, java), we could also have here a 'wa' subdir jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/apache-1.3/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/apache-2.0/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/native/include/ jakarta-tomcat-connectors/wa/src/java/ The idea is to provide to new users a common area when he's looking for web-server to servlet-engine connectors. Bah... I don't see any advantage for that, but you're more than welcome to do it. Actually, let's ask to the list: [+1] Let's move mod_webapp and all its related stuff in jakarta-connectors. +1 The stuff is not ready ( neither the new mod_jk for 4.0 nor mod_webapp ), and when it is - tomcat-dev should decide which one will be used in 4.0. Isn't it how it works ? This way it'll be fair - and you'll get your code used because and if it'll be better than mod_jk, not because it is the default for 4.0. Costin [ 0] I don't give a damn. [-1] Keep it where it is because (please explain) Pier: 0
Re: web_app in jakarta-tomcat-connectors ?
on 5/15/01 4:15 AM, GOMEZ Henri [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Didn't the jakarta-tomcat-connectors goal is to remove the connectors stuff from the servlet-engine code ? +1 in that case. Remember, +1 means that you are willing to help out. :-) -jon -- If you come from a Perl or PHP background, JSP is a way to take your pain to new levels. --Anonymous http://jakarta.apache.org/velocity/ymtd/ymtd.html
