Re: [twitter-dev] Possibility to link to the user page not by the name but by the id.

2010-01-20 Thread Abraham Williams
I remember this topic coming up before and it seems like someone built an
application that handled this but I can't find any references to it. Maybe
somebody else can?

Abraham

On Wed, Jan 20, 2010 at 06:29, Ivan  wrote:

> Hi.
>
> I tried to find the similar question here (in google groups), in the
> FAQ and in the API, but couldn't find anything.
>
> The problem:
> Cross-posting the links to the user page and to some his statuses in
> the web become more and more popular. But, as i understood, you can't
> guarantee that this links not long after would not change the logical
> destination. For example I create some post about some twitter-user
> "aaa" and give the link "twitter.com/aaa"
> After that user “aaa” changed name to "bbb" and user "ddd" changed
> name to "aaa". So my old link now points to the different person.
>
> This problem becomes more serious for the aggregators that don't know
> what content they might approve after a while.
>
> The simplest decision would be providing the possibility to link to
> the user not by name but also by id. That pages might be just
> redirections to the original user pages, it doesn't matter.
>
> For example
> if the user “aaa” have id 11, the following two links should point
> to the same page:
> twitter.com/aaa and twitter.com/id/11
>
> This mechanism should also be applied for the statuses:
> twitter.com/id/11/statuses/22
>
> Ivan.
>



-- 
Abraham Williams | Moved to Seattle | May cause email delays
Project | Intersect | http://intersect.labs.poseurtech.com
Hacker | http://abrah.am | http://twitter.com/abraham
This email is: [ ] shareable [x] ask first [ ] private.
Sent from Seattle, WA, United States


[twitter-dev] Possibility to link to the user page not by the name but by the id.

2010-01-20 Thread Ivan
Hi.

I tried to find the similar question here (in google groups), in the
FAQ and in the API, but couldn't find anything.

The problem:
Cross-posting the links to the user page and to some his statuses in
the web become more and more popular. But, as i understood, you can't
guarantee that this links not long after would not change the logical
destination. For example I create some post about some twitter-user
"aaa" and give the link "twitter.com/aaa"
After that user “aaa” changed name to "bbb" and user "ddd" changed
name to "aaa". So my old link now points to the different person.

This problem becomes more serious for the aggregators that don't know
what content they might approve after a while.

The simplest decision would be providing the possibility to link to
the user not by name but also by id. That pages might be just
redirections to the original user pages, it doesn't matter.

For example
if the user “aaa” have id 11, the following two links should point
to the same page:
twitter.com/aaa and twitter.com/id/11

This mechanism should also be applied for the statuses:
twitter.com/id/11/statuses/22

Ivan.