Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-10 Thread rouncer81
Bill Hibbard,  your talking about impossible questions. Questions that cannot be answered logically. -- Artificial General Intelligence List: AGI Permalink: https://agi.topicbox.com/groups/agi/T6cada473e1abac06-Mcdfea4cf3408f95dbd39d7fc Delivery options: htt

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-09 Thread John Rose
Perhaps we need definitions of stupidity. With all artificial intelligence there is artificial stupidity? Take the diff and correlate to bliss (ignorance). Blue pill me baby. Consumes less watts. More efficient? But survival is negentropy. So knowledge is potential energy. Causal entropic force?

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-09 Thread Bill Hibbard via AGI
> Philosophy is arguing about the meanings of words. For me, the great lesson of philosophy is that any language that is general enough to express all the ideas we need to express is able to express questions that do not have answers. For example, "Is there a god?" This may be related to the fact

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-09 Thread TimTyler
On 2019-11-08 15:58:PM, Matt Mahoney wrote: You can choose to model I/O peripherals as either part of the agent or part of the environment. Likewise for an input delay line. In one case it lowers intelligence and in the other case it doesn't. Thinking about it in computer science terms blurs t

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-09 Thread TimTyler
On 2019-11-08 17:53:PM, Matt Mahoney wrote: > we can approximate reward as dollars per hour over a set of > real environments of practical value. In that case, it does > matter how well you can see, hear, walk, and lift heavy objects. > Whether you think that's fair or not, it matters for AGI too

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-09 Thread Nanograte Knowledge Technologies
something else? From: WriterOfMinds Sent: Saturday, 09 November 2019 08:46 To: AGI Subject: Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence Nanograte, you seem to use "rational" oddly. Almost as if it's a synonym for "

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread WriterOfMinds
Nanograte, you seem to use "rational" oddly.  Almost as if it's a synonym for "pragmatic." That's not what I was trying to say at all. In the sense I had in mind, the word means "possessing higher reasoning powers," as in the phrase, "man is a rational animal."  I paired it with "sapient" becau

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread rouncer81
Its like the world goes to madness.   I think AGI wont give us anything remarkably new than ourselves, but it will be ASI - because you could make its brain never forget, have instant reflexes, have constant never ending motivation, its like making the "DAEMON OF EFFICIENCY" are we mad and headi

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread Nanograte Knowledge Technologies
ubject: Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence Requirements for AGI. 1. To automate human labor so we don't have to work. 2. To provide a platform for uploading our minds so we don't have to die. 3. To create Kardashev level I, II, and III civilizations, controlling th

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread rouncer81
hang on, was I just being a skeptic myself,  sorry,   maybe you can reduce conversation to rules?    But u need them computer detectable... -- Artificial General Intelligence List: AGI Permalink: https://agi.topicbox.com/groups/agi/T6cada473e1abac06-Mf03997

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread rouncer81
WriterofMinds you are going for the hardest possible a.i. to make,  if you just want to play soccer or tennis against a robot I wouldnt call it easy, but its at least possible. The best chat bots are all irrational,  you have to be acceptant to some form of irrationality or its impossible to do

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread WriterOfMinds
> Requirements for AGI. > > 1. To automate human labor so we don't have to work. > 2. To provide a platform for uploading our minds so we don't have to die. > 3. To create Kardashev level I, II, and III civilizations, controlling the > Earth, Sun, and galaxy respectively. Okay; now we know what

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread rouncer81
When I say quantum I just mean exponential power, I dont mean quantum mechanics sorry. -- Artificial General Intelligence List: AGI Permalink: https://agi.topicbox.com/groups/agi/T6cada473e1abac06-Md5d1fca136ee73c386640a76 Delivery options: https://agi.topi

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread Matt Mahoney
Actually no, a quantum computer doesn't solve AGI. Neural networks are not unitary. A quantum computer can only perform time reversible operations. It can't copy bits or write into memory. In my paper on the cost of AI I specified the requirements for step 1 (automating labor) in more detail and a

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread immortal . discoveries
Matt's got good point. It's all about what it does, what we need. Survival. 'advances/progress' are just survival steps. Sure, the brainz/AGI will be needed to do the big stunts; the right data, attention, etc, but you can look at it more sane like matt said.

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread rouncer81
Funny you said that,  because 2 of those happenings it actually dont require human level intelligence to be automated, a quantum computer alone would suffice.   but the platform for the "artificial heaven" may actually not even be possible even with AGI,  theres huge security risks there only go

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread Matt Mahoney
Defining intelligence is proving to be as big a distraction as defining consciousness. Remember when I said that the biggest mistake my students make is to start designing a program after skipping the requirements? We're doing it again. Requirements for AGI. 1. To automate human labor so we don't

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread rouncer81
I like how Writer of Minds said the environment includes the agents body,  which I always considered it true to, and fixes the definition somewhat. I was also going to say, What Colin Hayes said,  that it refers to a computer intelligence, not real intelligence, and its the leading method today

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread immortal . discoveries
Survival requires general adaptive plans. Thinking allows you flexibility to generate plans. Real arms allow you to refine your plans plus carry them out. -- Artificial General Intelligence List: AGI Permalink: https://agi.topicbox.com/groups/agi/T6cada473e

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread Matt Mahoney
Legg's formal definition of intelligence models an agent exchanging symbols with an environment, both Turing machines. Like all models, it isn't going to exactly coincide with what you think intelligence ought to mean, whether that's school grades or a score on a particular IQ test. You can choose

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-08 Thread TimTyler
On 2019-11-08 00:15:AM, TimTyler wrote: Another thread recently discussed Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence - i.e. "Intelligence measures an agent’s ability to achieve goals in a wide range of environments". I have never been able to swallow this proposed definition because I think it lea

Re: [agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-07 Thread Colin Hales
> > "Intelligence measures an agent’s ability to achieve goals in a wide > range of environments" > > No. This is a definition of automation. Zero intelligence. Intelligence is a measure of an ability to achieve goals in environments never before encountered. Until the discourse gets this, th

[agi] Against Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence

2019-11-07 Thread TimTyler
Another thread recently discussed Legg's 2007 definition of intelligence - i.e. "Intelligence measures an agent’s ability to achieve goals in a wide range of environments". I have never been able to swallow this proposed definition because I think it leaves out something important, namely: the