Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-02-02 Thread Richard Larsson
Hi Stefan, If we do something like this we have to start by removing abs_xsec_agenda. There's no good way to mold the Zeeman effect into fitting with it. I will inline the rest. Den mån 1 feb. 2021 kl 17:29 skrev Stefan Buehler < stefan.bueh...@uni-hamburg.de>: > Hej Richard, > > to me the

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-02-01 Thread Stefan Buehler
Hej Richard, to me the interesting point is that the specific inputs could be handled where the “Add..Habit” happens. In the case of absorption, a lot of difficulty comes from the dichotomy between the species tags and the methods that have to be added to the absorption agenda to actually do

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-02-01 Thread Richard Larsson
Simon, Stefan, It seems to me that this is a proposal of using a modern "void *" list/vector with some strict interface. Have I misunderstood something here? I mean you might implement it with virtual classes, std::variant, or some other reinterpreting interface but that seems about it. I am

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-02-01 Thread Stefan Buehler
Dear Simon, The handling of the constant data is completely up to the implementation of the specific scatterers. For the ScatteringParticle class, for example, this is provided when the object is constructed. So when the ARTS user calls: scattering_speciesAddScatteringHabit(...) an object

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-02-01 Thread Simon Pfreundschuh
ass. From: Stefan Buehler Sent: Monday, February 1, 2021 12:07:56 PM To: Simon Pfreundschuh Cc: ARTS Developers List Subject: Re: Simon plans for scattering properties Dear Simon, how will you manage communication? I’m asking because there is a related issue in computing absorpt

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-02-01 Thread Stefan Buehler
of Stefan Buehler Sent: Friday, January 29, 2021 8:42:21 AM To: Simon Pfreundschuh Cc: ARTS Developers List Subject: Re: Simon plans for scattering properties Hej Simon, can you help me understand it then, please? I do want to find the best solution, not necessarily the quickest. (But simplicity

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-01-31 Thread Simon Pfreundschuh
on behalf of Stefan Buehler Sent: Friday, January 29, 2021 8:42:21 AM To: Simon Pfreundschuh Cc: ARTS Developers List Subject: Re: Simon plans for scattering properties Hej Simon, can you help me understand it then, please? I do want to find the best solution, not necessarily the quickest

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-01-28 Thread Stefan Buehler
-boun...@mailman.rrz.uni-hamburg.de on behalf of Stefan Buehler Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 9:36:33 AM To: ARTS Developers List Subject: Simon plans for scattering properties Dear all, one thing I took home from the developer meeting on Friday is that I would like to better understand Simon’s

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-01-28 Thread Stefan Buehler
From: Stefan Buehler Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2021 5:02:28 PM To: Simon Pfreundschuh Cc: ARTS Developers List Subject: Re: Simon plans for scattering properties Dear Simon, thanks for the summary! I think I understand more or less how this works now. A bit unfortunate that so much

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-01-28 Thread Simon Pfreundschuh
cut this short. /s From: Stefan Buehler Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2021 5:02:28 PM To: Simon Pfreundschuh Cc: ARTS Developers List Subject: Re: Simon plans for scattering properties Dear Simon, thanks for the summary! I think I understand more or less how

Re: Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-01-28 Thread Stefan Buehler
...@mailman.rrz.uni-hamburg.de on behalf of Stefan Buehler Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 9:36:33 AM To: ARTS Developers List Subject: Simon plans for scattering properties Dear all, one thing I took home from the developer meeting on Friday is that I would like to better understand Simon’s plans

Simon plans for scattering properties

2021-01-25 Thread Stefan Buehler
Dear all, one thing I took home from the developer meeting on Friday is that I would like to better understand Simon’s plans for the scattering properties. We need this to make a good decision on how to proceed with the Rayleigh scattering (incorporate it into the existing scattering data