Re: [Beowulf] RoCE vs. InfiniBand

2021-09-29 Thread Stu Midgley
Morning I strongly suggest you get Mellanox to come in help with the initial config. Their technical teams are great and they know what they are doing. We run OpenMPI with UCX on top of Mellanox Multi-Host ethernet network. The setup required a few parameters on each switch and away we went.

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Ellis Wilson
On 9/29/21 5:51 PM, Jörg Saßmannshausen wrote: interesting concept. I did not know about the Lustre fsencrypt but then, I am less the in-detail expert in PFS. Just to make sure I get the concept of that correct: Basically Lustre is providing projects which itself are encrypted, similar to the

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Jörg Saßmannshausen
Hi Ellis, interesting concept. I did not know about the Lustre fsencrypt but then, I am less the in-detail expert in PFS. Just to make sure I get the concept of that correct: Basically Lustre is providing projects which itself are encrypted, similar to the encrypted containers I mentioned

Re: [Beowulf] [EXTERNAL] Re: Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Jörg Saßmannshausen
Dear all, back at a previous work place the shredder did come to our place and like Jim said: loud, not much to look at other than a heap of shredded metal and plastic the other end. There is an active volcano around right now:

Re: [Beowulf] RoCE vs. InfiniBand

2021-09-29 Thread Lohit Valleru via Beowulf
Hello Everyone.. I am now at a similar confusion between what to choose for a new cluster - ROCE vs Infiniband. My experience with ROCE when I tried it recently was that it was not easy to set it up. It required me to set up qos for lossless fabric, and pfc for flow control. On top of that - it

Re: [Beowulf] [EXTERNAL] Re: Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Lux, Jim (US 7140) via Beowulf
There are special purpose drive shredders - they'll even come out to your facility with such a device mounted on a truck. It's not as exciting as you might think. Throw stuff in, makes horrible noise, done. For entertainment, the truck sized wood chipper used when clearing old orchards is

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Ellis Wilson
On 9/29/21 11:41 AM, Jörg Saßmannshausen wrote: If you still need more, don't store the data at all but print it out on paper and destroy it by means of incineration. :D I have heard stories from past colleagues of one large US Lab putting their HDDs through wood chippers with magnets on the

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Ellis Wilson
Apologies in advance for the top-post -- too many interleaved streams here to sanely bottom-post appropriately. SED drives, which are a reasonably small mark-up for both HDDs and SSDs, provide full drive or per-band solutions to "wipe" the drive by revving the key associated with the band or

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Jörg Saßmannshausen
Dear all, interesting discussion and very timely for me as well as we are currently setting up a new HPC facility, using OpenStack throughout so we can build a Data Safe Haven with it as well. The question about data security came up too in various conversations, both internal and with

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Skylar Thompson
In this case, we've successfully pushed back with the granting agency (US NIH, generally, for us) that it's just not feasible to guarantee that the data are truly gone on a production parallel filesystem. The data are encrypted at rest (including offsite backups), which has been sufficient for our

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Paul Edmon via Beowulf
I guess the question is for a parallel filesystem how do you make sure you have 0'd out the file with out borking the whole filesystem since you are spread over a RAID set and could be spread over multiple hosts. -Paul Edmon- On 9/29/2021 10:32 AM, Scott Atchley wrote: For our users that have

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Paul Edmon via Beowulf
Yeah, that's what we were surmising.  But paranoia and compliance being what it is we were curious what others were doing. -Paul Edmon- On 9/29/2021 10:32 AM, Renfro, Michael wrote: I have to wonder if the intent of the DUA is to keep physical media from winding up in the wrong hands. If

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Skylar Thompson
We have one storage system (DDN/GPFS) that is required to be NIST-compliant, and we bought self-encrypting drives for it. The up-charge for SED drives has diminished significantly over the past few years so that might be easier than doing it in software and then having to verify/certify that the

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Renfro, Michael
I have to wonder if the intent of the DUA is to keep physical media from winding up in the wrong hands. If so, if the servers hosting the parallel filesystem (or a normal single file server) is physically secured in a data center, and the drives are destroyed on decommissioning, that might

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Scott Atchley
For our users that have sensitive data, we keep it encrypted at rest and in movement. For HDD-based systems, you can perform a secure erase per NIST standards. For SSD-based systems, the extra writes from the secure erase will contribute to the wear on the drives and possibly their eventually

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Paul Edmon via Beowulf
The former.  We are curious how to selectively delete data from a parallel filesystem.  For example we commonly use Lustre, ceph, and Isilon in our environment.  That said if other types allow for easier destruction of selective data we would be interested in hearing about it. -Paul Edmon-

Re: [Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Scott Atchley
Are you asking about selectively deleting data from a parallel file system (PFS) or destroying drives after removal from the system either due to failure or system decommissioning? For the latter, DOE does not allow us to send any non-volatile media offsite once it has had user data on it. When

[Beowulf] Data Destruction

2021-09-29 Thread Paul Edmon via Beowulf
Occassionally we get DUA (Data Use Agreement) requests for sensitive data that require data destruction (e.g. NIST 800-88). We've been struggling with how to handle this in an era of distributed filesystems and disks.  We were curious how other people handle requests like this?  What types of