RE: Ease the pain but don't stop offshoring

2004-03-30 Thread Mike Lee
Bethlehem steel is the biggest one I know; they didn't fund their retirement plans properly, they declared bankruptcy and the gov is left holding the bag. I agree that business that work the system this way are despicable. One more reason for workers not to trust a corporation to take care

RE: Ease the pain but don't stop offshoring

2004-03-28 Thread Mike Lee
Kevin pointed out that big business gets job retraining too when it screws up: problem with the above statement, the government does spend my tax dollars propping up companies that are failing in the market place like airlines and farming. In PA they are paying parts of a doctor's

RE: Ease the pain but don't stop offshoring

2004-03-28 Thread Kevin Tarr
Mostly agreeing with all Mike wrote, but there are other sides of the story too, where the gov should have been doing something and didn't. Bethlehem steel is the biggest one I know; they didn't fund their retirement plans properly, they declared bankruptcy and the gov is left holding the bag.

RE: Ease the pain but don't stop offshoring

2004-03-27 Thread Mike Lee
Tom wants reparations, from whom, I'm not quite sure: Economists talk about this all the time - easing the pain for people displaced by macroeconomic currents - but IT NEVER ACTUALLY HAPPENS. We never, as a society, seriously think about compensating the victims of necessary economic

RE: Ease the pain but don't stop offshoring

2004-03-27 Thread Kevin Tarr
Hardly anybody thinks that businesses that go under should be compensated and cuddled by the government for having their livelihood disappear. If a business can't cut it in the marketplace, tough. Worse than that, when a business is going under, and the owner must liquidate inventory at a loss,

Re: Ease the pain but don't stop offshoring

2004-03-26 Thread Tom Beck
Trying to slow the process of outsourcing is no solution. Instead, the US must make the adjustment process less painful and ensure that it has full access to foreign markets. First, the government should assist displaced workers. The benefits of free trade can only be realised if those people find

Re: Ease the pain but don't stop offshoring

2004-03-26 Thread Erik Reuter
On Fri, Mar 26, 2004 at 05:22:31PM -0500, Tom Beck wrote: Economists talk about this all the time - easing the pain for people displaced by macroeconomic currents - but IT NEVER ACTUALLY HAPPENS. We never, as a society, seriously think about compensating the victims of necessary economic