Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-24 Thread Fabio Dall'Antonia
Dear all, I don't know how closely this relates to what James pointed at, but regarding the aspect of NCS information usage in the heavy-atom finding/refinement stage, I would like to mention two programs of my knowledgethat are able to detect NCS in a set of putative heavy atom sites froma

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-22 Thread Pietro Roversi
] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU The problem of many monomers in the ASU is not restricted to macromolecules. An interesting recent small molecule example is the structure of L-tryptophan (http://dx.doi.org/10.1107/S0108768112033484) which, amazingly, was not published until 2012. This is perhaps

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-21 Thread James Holton
The problem of many monomers in the ASU is not restricted to macromolecules. An interesting recent small molecule example is the structure of L-tryptophan (http://dx.doi.org/10.1107/S0108768112033484) which, amazingly, was not published until 2012. This is perhaps in part due to difficulty in

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-21 Thread Steiner, Roberto
In my experience translational NCS also can a part when one has many molecules in the a.u. If MR is an option, modern packages are rather good in dealing with TNCS. We used Molrep + Refmac at 3.x A (still unpublished) for a case with 18 complexes (36 monomers) in the a.u. and things weren't as

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-20 Thread David Schuller
Is the monomer the biggest unit you have to search with? If there is a dimer, tetramer, etc. that is conserved, you could try searching with that. On 01/19/14 14:30, Chris Fage wrote: Thank you all for your responses. I already have a few ideas about how to approach the problem. One of my

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-20 Thread Roger Rowlett
I agree. Searching with a larger unit is likely to be successful if you have a good idea of the structure of that larger unit. We had an example of a low homology (29% identity) MR situation with 8 subunits per ASU with twinned data. Not solvable with monomers. Solvable with a dimer search

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-20 Thread Eugene Valkov
What is the sequence identity of your best search model? Finding that many copies in P1 with 3A data is a challenge but certainly not impossible if there is a reasonably close (20-25% identity) search model available. I would suggest spending some time on preparing a very good search model with

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-20 Thread G. Sridhar Prasad
To: CCP4BB@JISCMAIL.AC.UK Subject: Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU What is the sequence identity of your best search model? Finding that many copies in P1 with 3A data is a challenge but certainly not impossible if there is a reasonably close (20-25% identity) search model available. I would

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-20 Thread Carlos Frazao
] On Behalf Of Eugene Valkov Sent: Monday, January 20, 2014 6:37 AM To: CCP4BB@JISCMAIL.AC.UK Subject: Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU What is the sequence identity of your best search model? Finding that many copies in P1 with 3A data is a challenge but certainly not impossible

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-20 Thread Chris Fage
I am grateful for all of the suggestions. I think I have enough tricks to try at this point, but I may check back with this group if things don't work out. Many thanks once again, Chris On Sat, Jan 18, 2014 at 11:14 AM, Chris Fage cdf...@gmail.com wrote: Hello Everyone, I am currently

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-19 Thread Frank von Delft
Wasn't there this huge thread just 3 days ago on heavy atom soaking On 19/01/2014 07:18, Felix Frolow wrote: Francis, It can happened We have (not yet published) P1 with 24 molecules. When we cut His-tag we get P1 with 32 molecules. In our case we believe it is dictated by very strong

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-19 Thread Chris Fage
Thank you all for your responses. I already have a few ideas about how to approach the problem. One of my concerns with so monomers per asymmetric unit at lower resolution was the failure of MR software. Neither PHENIX nor Phaser MR have made progress. I am fairly new to anomalous methods, having

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-19 Thread Francis Reyes
Chris, On Jan 19, 2014, at 11:30 AM, Chris Fage cdf...@gmail.com wrote: Thank you all for your responses. I already have a few ideas about how to approach the problem. One of my concerns with so monomers per asymmetric unit at lower resolution was the failure of MR software. Neither

[ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-18 Thread Chris Fage
Hello Everyone, I am currently trying to phase a structure with an asymmetric unit predicted to contain 20-24 monomers (space group P1). The native crystals, while beautiful in appearance (see attached), only diffract to ~3.4-3.0 angstroms at best, and SeMet-derived crystals grow with poor

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-18 Thread Scott Thomas Walsh
Hi Chris, It would be nice to have a wee bit more information. Is 3.4-3.0 angstroms from a home source or synchrotron? What are the crystallization conditions for both the native and SeMet crystals? Did you see the SeMet crystals with the native crystals. Have you tried MMS with the native

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-18 Thread Francis Reyes
You sure about this space group? 24 monomers in P1 is unusual (at least to me) F On Jan 18, 2014, at 9:14 AM, Chris Fage cdf...@gmail.com wrote: Hello Everyone, I am currently trying to phase a structure with an asymmetric unit predicted to contain 20-24 monomers (space group P1). The

Re: [ccp4bb] Phasing with Many Monomers/AU

2014-01-18 Thread Felix Frolow
Francis, It can happened We have (not yet published) P1 with 24 molecules. When we cut His-tag we get P1 with 32 molecules. In our case we believe it is dictated by very strong interaction between two monomers, and strong interaction between dimers with build a flattish tetramer. Probably