Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD journals crashes

2016-05-20 Thread Anthony D'Atri
Atri > Sent: Friday, May 20, 2016 1:32 PM > To: ceph-users@lists.ceph.com > Subject: Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD > journals crashes > > >> Ceph will not acknowledge a client write before all journals (replica >> size, 3

Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD journals crashes

2016-05-20 Thread EP Komarla
Of Anthony D'Atri Sent: Friday, May 20, 2016 1:32 PM To: ceph-users@lists.ceph.com Subject: Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD journals crashes > Ceph will not acknowledge a client write before all journals (replica > size, 3 by default) have received the da

Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD journals crashes

2016-05-20 Thread Anthony D'Atri
> Ceph will not acknowledge a client write before all journals (replica > size, 3 by default) have received the data, so loosing one journal SSD > will NEVER result in an actual data loss. Some say that all replicas must be written; others say that only min_size, 2 by default, must be written

Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD journals crashes

2016-05-19 Thread Christian Balzer
<ep.koma...@flextronics.com> > Subject: Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting > several OSD journals crashes > > > Hello, > > first of all, wall of text. Don't do that. > Use returns and paragraphs liberally to make reading easy. > I'm betting

Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD journals crashes

2016-05-19 Thread Dyweni - Ceph-Users
Hi, Yes and no, for the actual data loss. This depends on your crush map. If you're using the original map (which came with the installation), then your smallest failure domain will be the host. If you have replica size and 3 hosts and 5 OSDs per host (15 OSDs total), then loosing the

Re: [ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD journals crashes

2016-05-19 Thread Christian Balzer
Hello, first of all, wall of text. Don't do that. Use returns and paragraphs liberally to make reading easy. I'm betting at least half of the people who could have answered you question took a look at this blob of text and ignored it. Secondly, search engines are your friend. The first hit

[ceph-users] Do you see a data loss if a SSD hosting several OSD journals crashes

2016-05-19 Thread EP Komarla
* We are trying to assess if we are going to see a data loss if an SSD that is hosting journals for few OSDs crashes. In our configuration, each SSD is partitioned into 5 chunks and each chunk is mapped as a journal drive for one OSD. What I understand from the Ceph documentation: