Re: MokoMakefile make update forces Bitbake cache rebuild

2007-04-02 Thread Rod Whitby
Henryk Plötz wrote: > Am Mon, 02 Apr 2007 12:26:20 +0930 schrieb Rod Whitby: >> The silence-retrieved-revisions patch is the other culprit. This >> seemed to be debugging information that was output during the bbfile >> parsing. Perhaps mickeyl could add that patch permanently to the >> openmoko s

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Andrew Turner
There are a couple of Google Summer of Code applications that involve building a mapping application on OpenMoko. Hopefully one of these get's funded. At the very least that will demonstrate the viability of OpenMoko and the Neo1973 as a mobile mapping platform that commercial vendors can then con

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Paul McMillan
I agree that while this is unlikely, it's the best option for all involved. You would need a software company to write that binary library though... which would probably not be a particularly profitable enterprise. ___ OpenMoko community mailing list com

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Hans L
I just thought of another (yes, probably unlikely) possibility, but maybe worth considering. A map provider could keep their data in a closed format and provide a closed source binary library API for interfacing with the data. This way open source developers could have their own front-end interfa

Re: VoIP call transfer?

2007-04-02 Thread adrian cockcroft
On 4/2/07, Paul McMillan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: It's nice to have rational conversation and argument about this, rather than the great amounts of handwringing which sometimes constitute the bulk of these discussions... Agreed :-) I agree... there's very little reason for us to cache the

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Hans L
On 4/2/07, Andrew Turner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: ... Right, but the bigger question is if Google wanted to develop & support their GmapsMobile for OpenMoko. This will be difficult. I think this is a common misconception. Google Maps Mobile runs on Java(J2ME), so as long as the phone can sup

Re: VoIP call transfer?

2007-04-02 Thread Paul McMillan
It's nice to have rational conversation and argument about this, rather than the great amounts of handwringing which sometimes constitute the bulk of these discussions... The "burden" of a skype client is not primarily in the UI, most people would be happy to just have a way to run Skype on thei

Re: VoIP call transfer?

2007-04-02 Thread adrian cockcroft
On 4/2/07, Paul McMillan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Adrian, thanks for an insider's viewpoint. Likewise, thanks for this detailed response. What you describe (a Linux/ARM gateway binary) would be an acceptable solution for many people, since it wouldn't overly burden the device with a full-b

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Ian Stirling
wim delvaux wrote: Seems to confirm parent's interpretation. The code is closed, and 'free' only in so far as Nokia are allowing a no-cost download of the beta version. Navigation is a paid-for upgrade. The license agreement prevents redistribution of the data files, and prevents reverse-engineer

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Paul McMillan
What if somebody writes a free application that works but with charts that cost money ? You can't buy the charts. They are protected by various technical and licensing methods in each of the products you use. The companies can't take the risk of an open source software product revealing and d

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread wim delvaux
> > Seems to confirm parent's interpretation. The code is closed, and 'free' > only in so far as Nokia are allowing a no-cost download of the beta > version. Navigation is a paid-for upgrade. The license agreement prevents > redistribution of the data files, and prevents reverse-engineering of the

Re: An Update

2007-04-02 Thread Dr. H. Nikolaus Schaller
Am 02.04.2007 um 22:07 schrieb Matthew S. Hamrick: Apple is well know for good design... i.e. - understanding the interplay between psychology, manufacturing technology and materials. In terms of hardware quality, they've never been consistently good. For instance, my 450MHz G4 tower is st

Re: An Update

2007-04-02 Thread Matthew S. Hamrick
Apple is well know for good design... i.e. - understanding the interplay between psychology, manufacturing technology and materials. In terms of hardware quality, they've never been consistently good. For instance, my 450MHz G4 tower is still crankin' away after 8 years. My G5 and photo iPo

Re: An Update

2007-04-02 Thread Matthew S. Hamrick
D'oh! I forgot to credit Dick Gabriel (of Lucid fame (or infamy, depending on your opinion of Lisp and C++)) for the concept of how important evolution is in software development. He's penned a number of very interesting papers, available at his site: http://www.dreamsongs.com/Essays.htm

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Paul McMillan
Something else worth mentioning, regarding road usage, is that on a much larger scale, we could get fairly accurate road data automatically if every phone recorded where it went (unless the functionality was turned off) and just uploaded that data automatically to a server when it was near an acce

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Paul McMillan
Regarding the repeated requests for google maps on the device: YES IT IS POSSIBLE. YOU DO NOT WANT IT. According to the terms, you aren't allowed to cache the data for further use later. This means that you have to download the images over GPRS every time you pass through an area. These images a

Re: An Update

2007-04-02 Thread Matthew S. Hamrick
Depends on the development model. Peter Naur has an interesting take on software development, which I paraphrase... The software that's released is an artifact of the true value of the organization; the ability to efficiently communicate models in the problem space amongst the people that a

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Steven **
According to OSM's wiki (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/index.php/Getting_Involved#Recording_tracks_using_a_GPS_receiver Step 5), it would be a copyright violation to use Google Maps in any way to fill data into OSM. OSM insists in their guides that you note street names while you're traveling, si

Re: VoIP call transfer?

2007-04-02 Thread Paul McMillan
Adrian, thanks for an insider's viewpoint. What you describe (a Linux/ARM gateway binary) would be an acceptable solution for many people, since it wouldn't overly burden the device with a full-blown Skype client, and would provide the connectivity to integrate Skype contacts alongside sip and ot

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Steven **
On 4/2/07, Steven ** <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: According to OSM's wiki (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/index.php/Getting_Involved#Recording_tracks_using_a_GPS_receiver Step 5), it would be a copyright violation to use Google Maps in any way to fill data into OSM. OSM insists in their guides that

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Ian Stirling
Jonathon Suggs wrote: Andrew Turner wrote: Caching googlemaps tiles, and not through their client, is a violation of their Terms of Service. Same for all the other providers. Here's an interesting question. What if you constantly logged your position (while driving). Then when you got ba

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Jonathon Suggs
Andrew Turner wrote: Caching googlemaps tiles, and not through their client, is a violation of their Terms of Service. Same for all the other providers. Here's an interesting question. What if you constantly logged your position (while driving). Then when you got back home, you could uplo

Re: An Update

2007-04-02 Thread Jonas Berlin
Quoting Dr. H. Nikolaus Schaller on 04/02/2007 07:29 AM UTC: > I think that the Neo is also seen as some competition to the iPhone - > and Apple > is known for high hardware quality standards. Now please, this is some illusion.. I've had & heard of many problems with apple hardware.. :) - xkr47

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Ian Stirling
Andrew Turner wrote: On 4/2/07, adrian cockcroft <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'm happy with the capabilities of Google maps, except that it doesn't know where I am http://www.opengeodata.org/?p=189 The UK Ordnance Survey - national mapping agency - is incorporating their data into OSM, an

Re: Fwd: UI long term development perspective: physics engine

2007-04-02 Thread Al Johnson
On Monday 02 April 2007 00:38, Florent THIERY wrote: > > > i'm pretty curious to know what exactly the touchscreen sees when you > > > touch the screen with 2 fingers at the same time, when you move them, > > > when you move only one of the 2, etc, ...). > > > > The output is the center of the

wifi chipsets

2007-04-02 Thread Christopher Friedt
I was looking on the wiki just to see if any decision has been made on the Wifi chipsets to go into the next version of the openmoko. Although I suggested the SyChip devices (admittedly only to have the chance to win a Neo), I should say a couple of things. I do a lot of arm development, and

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Andrew Turner
On 4/2/07, adrian cockcroft <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'm happy with the capabilities of Google maps, except that it doesn't know where I am Caching googlemaps tiles, and not through their client, is a violation of their Terms of Service. Same for all the other providers. So you're restri

RE: An Update

2007-04-02 Thread David Schlesinger
>..."Given enough eyeballs, all bugs are shallow." >I wish there were a way to apply this to hardware, >without the costs being astronomical. Unfortunately, this turns out not to be completely true, even for software. Given enough eyeballs, most localized programming errors are fairly shallow, b

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread adrian cockcroft
I'm happy with the capabilities of Google maps, except that it doesn't know where I am So given java support on OpenMoko, I think there is already a fairly generic mobile Java version of Google Maps that should just work... However to interface to the GPS we will need a modified version. I th

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Al Johnson
On Monday 02 April 2007 12:36, wim delvaux wrote: > On Monday 02 April 2007 11:42:51 Attila Csipa wrote: > > On Monday 02 April 2007 08:13, Hans L wrote: > > > I guess it is a question of whether the map providers are willing to > > > cooperate and divulge the details of their file format to an ope

Re: VoIP call transfer?

2007-04-02 Thread adrian cockcroft
First: I work for eBay, I'm a Skype beta tester and have helped develop/test the Skype Java API. I'm not speaking here in any official capacity. Keeping to the technology issues, Skype for mobile is targeted at Symbian and Windows mobile, Skype desktop for Linux runs on x86, its being worked on b

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread karsten . at . openmoko
If I remember correctly the company of smart2go was bought by Nokia last year. So I don't think they will support other phones but Nokias in near future. Regards Karsten On Monday 02 April 2007 11:42:51 Attila Csipa wrote: > On Monday 02 April 2007 08:13, Hans L wrote: > > I guess it is a questio

Re: UI long term development perspective: physics engine

2007-04-02 Thread adrian cockcroft
If the touchscreen reports the last touch and two fingers cause the position to hop between two points then the driver just needs an algorithm that reports the last two places and has some smoothing and clustering built in. Given low level access to the hardware this shouldn't be too difficult to

Re: An Update

2007-04-02 Thread Mike Sandman
Sean Moss-Pultz wrote: > All along we've taking the stance that openness goes deeper than > just source code. And we don't plan on stopping today because of pesky > hardware delays. So, I'm letting you know there will be some delays. > > Engineers worked through the weekend trying to verify the l

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Sander van Grieken
Their GO products are also ARM based if I recall correctly, so in theory it should be possible to provide the expected ABI and run the proprietary parts. And IMHO the EULA doesn't prohibit running TomTom on another device, as long as you remove the program from the original device.. >From the Tom

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread wim delvaux
On Monday 02 April 2007 11:42:51 Attila Csipa wrote: > On Monday 02 April 2007 08:13, Hans L wrote: > > I guess it is a question of whether the map providers are willing to > > cooperate and divulge the details of their file format to an open source > > project, or alternatively converting their da

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Attila Csipa
On Monday 02 April 2007 08:13, Hans L wrote: > I guess it is a question of whether the map providers are willing to > cooperate and divulge the details of their file format to an open source > project, or alternatively converting their data into some open format for > use with such a project. In m

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Georg Michelitsch
Just wanted to add that I'm interested in such a solution too, I'm willing to pay for the maps, but I don't like the idea of having some proprietary software on my phone, I would appreciate the solution of an opensource GPS Navigation Application in connection with the maps from Teleatlas, etc.

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Jeff Andros
there's been a long running discussion on getting java up and running... what would be the possibility of tying into the gmaps mobile interface? does anyone who reads licences better than I know if this violates the EULA? maybe we could talk google into doing a custom version? they do it for quite

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Mike Hodson
(I honestly hate gmails lack of replying to the proper address) On 4/2/07, Tehn Yit Chin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I don't mean this to be a flippant remark, but how about google map as > a OpenStreetMap replacement? Google Maps is not a collection of mapping data, it licenses and pays for fr

Re: An Update

2007-04-02 Thread Dr. H. Nikolaus Schaller
Sean, thank you *very* much for your openness in this aspect as well! The latest hardware spin -- GTA01B_V4 was supposed to fix the few remaining issues keeping us from setting phones free; but, we uncovered some other issues. From my own experience in the Mobile Phone business, I know that

Re: tomtom on the Neo1973

2007-04-02 Thread Tehn Yit Chin
I don't mean this to be a flippant remark, but how about google map as a OpenStreetMap replacement? On 4/2/07, Hans L <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Just wanted to say that I am another user that would be interested in a commercial mapping application running on an OpenMoko device. I realize that m