Re: Indo European Origins

2003-01-14 Thread Harmon Seaver
On Tue, Jan 14, 2003 at 10:36:46AM -0800, Michael Motyka wrote: Very true. Communicating with a 14th century Englishman would be difficult. I took a similar major's course with Robert Kaske in the 80's without the benefit of the side-by-side. It was as close to learning a new language as I

Re: Indo European Origins (language mutability, efficiency)

2003-01-14 Thread Major Variola (ret)
On Ken's All contemporary natural languages, like all biological species, are the same age. At first this parsed because I was thinking in the sense of all organisms have ancestries going back the same amount of time. (And humans aren't the 'goal' of evolution.) Not sure if non-bioheads

Re: Indo European Origins

2003-01-14 Thread Bill Stewart
At 04:25 PM 01/14/2003 +, Ken Brown wrote: All contemporary natural languages, like all biological species, are the same age. This statement is so silly it leaves me speechless... [] Nonsense. Icelandic is little changed from the Old Norse of 1000 A.D. Icelanders can easily read the

Re: Indo European Origins

2003-01-13 Thread Tim May
On Monday, January 13, 2003, at 07:42 AM, Ken Brown wrote: R. A. Hettinga wrote: At 4:25 PM -0500 on 1/9/03, Trei, Peter wrote: Basque is unique, as you say I remember someone saying somewhere, probably on PBS, that Basque is *very* old, paleolithic, and lots of popular mythology has

Re: Indo European Origins

2003-01-13 Thread Ken Brown
R. A. Hettinga wrote: At 4:25 PM -0500 on 1/9/03, Trei, Peter wrote: Basque is unique, as you say I remember someone saying somewhere, probably on PBS, that Basque is *very* old, paleolithic, and lots of popular mythology has cropped up that it's the closest living relative to some

Re: Indo European Origins and other stuff

2003-01-10 Thread Tyler Durden
Major Variola wrote... Reference). Of course, the Bhagavad Gita is a subsection of the Maybe your highschool has firewalled off anything that will lead you to Hoffman, Ott, Huxley, etc. Yeah, read all a lot of that shit 25 years ago. Seems easier to ask in an email while making some

Re: Indo European Origins and other stuff

2003-01-10 Thread Mike Rosing
On Thu, 9 Jan 2003, Tyler Durden wrote: I'd also point out the need to be deliberately oblique. I'm not sure we aren't actually headed towards a time where any of us can be carted away for expressing how we really think. I also don't kid myself about whether someone could be listening. And

Re: Indo European Origins

2003-01-09 Thread Meyer Wolfsheim
On Thu, 9 Jan 2003, Tyler Durden wrote: Soma? Despite the fact that I've read large chunks of the Rig Vedas, I don't remember anything called Soma (unless this is a Brave New World Reference). Of course, the Bhagavad Gita is a subsection of the Mahabaratabut I don't imagine this is what

Re: Indo European Origins

2003-01-09 Thread Major Variola (ret)
At 03:32 PM 1/9/03 -0500, Tyler Durden wrote: Soma? Despite the fact that I've read large chunks of the Rig Vedas, I don't remember anything called Soma (unless this is a Brave New World Reference). Of course, the Bhagavad Gita is a subsection of the Mahabaratabut I don't imagine this is what

RE: Indo European Origins

2003-01-09 Thread Trei, Peter
Tyler Durden[SMTP:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] wrote: Most of the people from the British Isles over to Northern India speak a variant of the original Indo-European language, with Sanskrit and Lithuanian likely being the closest languages surviving. Some interesting exceptions (I believe) are