Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-28 Thread Franco Martelli
Hi Marc, On 20/05/24 at 14:35, Marc SCHAEFER wrote: 3. grub BOOT FAILS IF ANY LV HAS dm-integrity, EVEN IF NOT LINKED TO / if I reboot now, grub2 complains about rimage issues, clear the screen and then I am at the grub2 prompt. Booting is only possible with Debian rescue, disabling the

Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-23 Thread Marc SCHAEFER
the exact address where the kernel & initrd was, regardless of abstractions layers :->) Recently, I have been playing with RAID-on-LVM (I was mostly using LVM on md before, which worked with grub), and it works too. Where grub fails, is if you have /boot on the same LVM volume group where

Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-22 Thread Stefan Monnier
> I found this [1], quoting: "I'd also like to share an issue I've > discovered: if /boot's partition is a LV, then there must not be a > raidintegrity LV anywhere before that LV inside the same VG. Otherwise, > update-grub will show an error (disk `lvmid/.../...' not found) and GRUB > cannot

Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-22 Thread Marc SCHAEFER
Hello, On Wed, May 22, 2024 at 10:13:06AM +, Andy Smith wrote: > metadata tags to some PVs prevented grub from assembling them, grub is indeed very fragile if you use dm-integrity anywhere on any of your LVs on the same VG where /boot is (or at least if in the list of LVs, the dm-integrity

Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-22 Thread Andy Smith
Hello, On Wed, May 22, 2024 at 08:57:38AM +0200, Marc SCHAEFER wrote: > I will try this work-around and report back here. As I said, I can > live with /boot on RAID without dm-integrity, as long as the rest can be > dm-integrity+raid protected. I'm interested in how you get on. I d

Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-22 Thread Marc SCHAEFER
Hello, On Wed, May 22, 2024 at 08:57:38AM +0200, Marc SCHAEFER wrote: > I will try this work-around and report back here. As I said, I can > live with /boot on RAID without dm-integrity, as long as the rest can be > dm-integrity+raid protected. So, enable dm-integrity on all LVs,

Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-22 Thread Marc SCHAEFER
work-around and report back here. As I said, I can live with /boot on RAID without dm-integrity, as long as the rest can be dm-integrity+raid protected. [1] https://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/717763/lvm2-integrity-feature-breaks-lv-activation

Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-22 Thread Marc SCHAEFER
ysetup (from LUKS), but LVM RAID PVs -- I don't use LUKS encryption anyway on that system 2) the issue is not the kernel not supporting it, because when the system is up, it works (I have done tests to destroy part of the underlying devices, they get detected and fixed correctly) 3) the

Re: Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-21 Thread Franco Martelli
On 20/05/24 at 14:35, Marc SCHAEFER wrote: Any idea what could be the problem? Any way to just make grub2 ignore the rimage (sub)volumes at setup and boot time? (I could live with / aka vg1/root not using dm-integrity, as long as the data/docker/etc volumes are integrity-protected) ? Or how

Debian bookwork / grub2 / LVM / RAID / dm-integrity fails to boot

2024-05-20 Thread Marc SCHAEFER
Hello, 1. INITIAL SITUATION: WORKS (no dm-integrity at all) I have a Debian bookwork uptodate system that boots correctly with kernel 6.1.0-21-amd64. It is setup like this: - /dev/nvme1n1p1 is /boot/efi - /dev/nvme0n1p2 and /dev/nvme1n1p2 are the two LVM physical volumes - a volume

RE: Perte de configuration RAID

2023-12-20 Thread David BERCOT
Bonjour Thierry, En effet, mon erreur (la deuxième en fait ;-)) a été de re-créer "directement" les 2 groupes... J'aurais pu les ré-importer en mode "foreign". Ca me servira pour la prochaine fois... Je vais faire des tests complémentaires avec l'utilitaire de la car

Re: Perte de configuration RAID

2023-12-18 Thread Th.A.C
Bonjour, je fais des bricoles sur des serveurs Dell, mais rien d'extraordinaire. De mémoire, on ne recrée pas un raid, mais on l'importe (un truc dans le genre "... foreign ..."). En général, quand on démarre le serveur avec des disques inconnus, s'il voit un raid compatible, il

Re: Perte de configuration RAID

2023-12-18 Thread didier gaumet
Le 18/12/2023 à 10:47, David BERCOT a écrit : Bonjour Didier, Je te remercie pour ton mail mais tu cibles ici l'utilisation d'une solution RAID logicielle avec Mdadm. Me concernant, il s'agit de RAID matériel avec une carte spécifique. Mais je vais quand même regarder au cas où il y aurait

RE: Perte de configuration RAID

2023-12-18 Thread David BERCOT
Bonjour Didier, Je te remercie pour ton mail mais tu cibles ici l'utilisation d'une solution RAID logicielle avec Mdadm. Me concernant, il s'agit de RAID matériel avec une carte spécifique. Mais je vais quand même regarder au cas où il y aurait quelque chose à prendre... Bien cordialement

Re: Perte de configuration RAID

2023-12-18 Thread didier gaumet
Le 18/12/2023 à 10:08, David BERCOT a écrit : [...] J'ai voulu créer un 3ème groupe RAID et, au moment d'appliquer la configuration, le système a supprimé mes 2 premiers groupes !!! Je les ai re-créés mais, malheureusement, il ne retrouve pas ses petits (et ne boote même pas sur Debian

Perte de configuration RAID

2023-12-18 Thread David BERCOT
, sur un serveur (Dell PowerEdge R540 avec carte PERC H330), j'avais la configuration suivante : - groupe RAID0 : Debian - groupe RAID5 : données J'ai voulu créer un 3ème groupe RAID et, au moment d'appliquer la configuration, le système a supprimé mes 2 premiers groupes !!! Je les ai re-créés mais

Re: Data disaster preparedness and recovery without RAID

2023-12-14 Thread Pocket
files that glow blue. ;-) My files glow Greene so I am safe > > >>> On 12/13/23 10:42, Pocket wrote: >>>> After removing raid, I completely redesigned my network to be more inline >>>> with the howtos and other information. >>> >>> Plea

Re: Data disaster preparedness and recovery without RAID

2023-12-14 Thread David Christensen
), restoring from the snapshot should produce a set of files that work correctly. Radioactive I see Do not eat files that glow blue. ;-) On 12/13/23 10:42, Pocket wrote: After removing raid, I completely redesigned my network to be more inline with the howtos and other information. Please

Re: Data disaster preparedness and recovery without RAID

2023-12-14 Thread Pocket
Sent from my iPad > On Dec 14, 2023, at 4:09 AM, David Christensen > wrote: > > On 12/13/23 08:51, Pocket wrote: >> I gave up using raid many years ago and I used the extra drives as backups. >> Wrote a script to rsync /home to the backup drives. > > >

Data disaster preparedness and recovery without RAID

2023-12-14 Thread David Christensen
On 12/13/23 08:51, Pocket wrote: I gave up using raid many years ago and I used the extra drives as backups. Wrote a script to rsync /home to the backup drives. While external HDD enclosures can work, my favorite is mobile racks: https://www.startech.com/en-us/hdd/drw150satbk https

Re: (deb-cat) Mida de blocs per a RAID de programari

2023-07-24 Thread Narcis Garcia
El 23/7/23 a les 10:19, Alex Muntada ha escrit: A on vull anar a parar amb tot això és a, si resulta que un capçal llegeix i escriu, per exemple, 4 MiB a cada demanda, és molt ineficient establir trossos/chunks de RAID de 512 KiB, ja que el sistema operatiu demanarà 8 vegades la mateixa operació

Re: (deb-cat) Mida de blocs per a RAID de programari

2023-07-23 Thread Alex Muntada
tal·lació amb un programet (script) > prescindint de DebianInstaller, però el què ara estic explorant > és 1 sola personalització per a seguir amb DebianInstaller quan > no vull complicar res més. A les configuracions de preseed del d-i per al raid no he vist que s'hi pugui posar la mida,

Re: (deb-cat) Mida de blocs per a RAID de programari

2023-07-22 Thread Narcis Garcia
sistema operatiu, sinó l'òptima per al dispositiu físic. És a dir, que si el capçal d'un disc dur escriu com a mínim 2048 KiB, aleshores seria molt ineficient establir blocs/chunks de 512 KiB a la capra RAID, perquè el sistema operatiu podria demanar escriure 4 vegades el mateix segment de disc per

Re: (deb-cat) Mida de blocs per a RAID de programari

2023-07-22 Thread Alex Muntada
apçal d'un disc > dur escriu com a mínim 2048 KiB, aleshores seria molt ineficient > establir blocs/chunks de 512 KiB a la capra RAID, perquè el > sistema operatiu podria demanar escriure 4 vegades el mateix > segment de disc per a emplenar-lo de dades independents de > 512 KiB cada t

Re: (deb-cat) Mida de blocs per a RAID de programari

2023-07-21 Thread Narcis Garcia
operacions físiques. No busco la mida òptima per al sistema operatiu, sinó l'òptima per al dispositiu físic. És a dir, que si el capçal d'un disc dur escriu com a mínim 2048 KiB, aleshores seria molt ineficient establir blocs/chunks de 512 KiB a la capra RAID, perquè el sistema operatiu podria demanar

Re: (deb-cat) Mida de blocs per a RAID de programari

2023-07-21 Thread Alex Muntada
de bloc del RAID amb el > DebianInstaller. A la documentació no trobo enlloc que es pugui canviar la mida de bloc (o chunk, com li diu mdadm). He seguit aquest camí: https://wiki.debian.org/DebianInstaller/Preseed https://www.debian.org/releases/stable/amd64/apbs04.en.html https://salsa.debian.org

(deb-cat) Mida de blocs per a RAID de programari

2023-07-13 Thread Narcis Garcia
Bona tarda, De vegades faig una instal·lació de Debian en un ordinador amb varis discs durs de mida similar i, apart d'una partició per a /boot al disc d'arrencada, amb la resta dels espais estableixo un conjunt RAID de programari. Sovint estableixo RAID0 per accelerar equips antics o

Re: Raid Array and Changing Motherboard

2023-07-02 Thread David Christensen
On 7/2/23 13:11, Mick Ab wrote: On 19:58, Sun, 2 Jul 2023 David Christensen On 7/2/23 10:23, Mick Ab wrote: I have a software RAID 1 array of two hard drives. Each of the two disks contains the Debian operating system and user data. I am thinking of changing the motherboard because

Re: Raid Array and Changing Motherboard

2023-07-02 Thread Alexander V. Makartsev
On 02.07.2023 22:23, Mick Ab wrote: I have a software RAID 1 array of two hard drives. Each of the two disks contains the Debian operating system and user data. I am thinking of changing the motherboard because of problems that might be connected to the current motherboard. The new

Re: Raid Array and Changing Motherboard

2023-07-02 Thread Mick Ab
On 19:58, Sun, 2 Jul 2023 David Christensen > On 7/2/23 10:23, Mick Ab wrote: > > I have a software RAID 1 array of two hard drives. Each of the two disks > > contains the Debian operating system and user data. > > > > I am thinking of changing the motherboard bec

Re: Raid Array and Changing Motherboard

2023-07-02 Thread David Christensen
On 7/2/23 10:23, Mick Ab wrote: I have a software RAID 1 array of two hard drives. Each of the two disks contains the Debian operating system and user data. I am thinking of changing the motherboard because of problems that might be connected to the current motherboard. The new motherboard

Re: Raid Array and Changing Motherboard

2023-07-02 Thread Charles Curley
On Sun, 2 Jul 2023 18:23:31 +0100 Mick Ab wrote: > I am thinking of changing the motherboard because of problems that > might be connected to the current motherboard. The new motherboard > would be the same make and model as the current motherboard. > > Would I need to recreate t

Raid Array and Changing Motherboard

2023-07-02 Thread Mick Ab
I have a software RAID 1 array of two hard drives. Each of the two disks contains the Debian operating system and user data. I am thinking of changing the motherboard because of problems that might be connected to the current motherboard. The new motherboard would be the same make and model

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-20 Thread Nicolas George
Tim Woodall (12023-03-17): > Yes. It's possible. Took me about 5 minutes to work out the steps. All > of which are already mentioned upthread. All of them, except one. > mdadm --build ${md} --level=raid1 --raid-devices=2 ${d1} missing Until now, all suggestions with mdadm started wit

Re: RAID1 + iSCSI as backup (was Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network)

2023-03-18 Thread Dan Ritter
nually fail a disk then store it in a safe deposit box or > > > > something as > > > > a backup, but I have not gotten around to it. > > > > > > > > It sounds to me like adding an iSCSI volume (e.g. from AWS) to the RAID > > > > as >

Re: RAID1 + iSCSI as backup (was Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network)

2023-03-18 Thread David Christensen
(plus a hot spare). On top of that is LUKS, and on top of that is LVM. I keep meaning to manually fail a disk then store it in a safe deposit box or something as a backup, but I have not gotten around to it. It sounds to me like adding an iSCSI volume (e.g. from AWS) to the RAID as an additional

Re: RAID1 + iSCSI as backup (was Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network)

2023-03-17 Thread Gregory Seidman
; > spare). On top of that is LUKS, and on top of that is LVM. I keep meaning > > to manually fail a disk then store it in a safe deposit box or something as > > a backup, but I have not gotten around to it. > > > > It sounds to me like adding an iSCSI volume (e.g. from AWS)

Re: RAID1 + iSCSI as backup (was Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network)

2023-03-17 Thread David Christensen
On 3/17/23 12:36, Gregory Seidman wrote: On Fri, Mar 17, 2023 at 06:00:46PM +0300, Reco wrote: [...] PS There's that old saying, "RAID is not a substitute for a backup". What you're trying to do sounds suspiciously similar to an old "RAID split-mirror" backup te

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Tim Woodall
red mdadm --build ${md} --level=raid1 --raid-devices=2 ${d1} missing echo "Mounting single disk raid" mount ${md} /mnt/fred ls -al /mnt/fred mdadm ${md} --add ${d2} sleep 10 echo "Done sleeping - sync had better be done!" mdadm ${md} --fail ${d2} mdadm ${md} --remove ${d2

Re: RAID1 + iSCSI as backup (was Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network)

2023-03-17 Thread Dan Ritter
Gregory Seidman wrote: > On Fri, Mar 17, 2023 at 06:00:46PM +0300, Reco wrote: > [...] > > PS There's that old saying, "RAID is not a substitute for a backup". > > What you're trying to do sounds suspiciously similar to an old "RAID > > spli

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Nicolas George
Nicolas George (12023-03-17): > It is not vagueness, it is genericness: /dev/something is anything and > contains anything, and I want a solution that works for anything. Just to be clear: I KNOW that what I am asking, the ability to synchronize an existing block device onto another over the

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Nicolas George
Greg Wooledge (12023-03-17): > > I have a block device on the local host /dev/something with data on it. ^^^ There. I have data, therefore, any solution that assumes the data is not there can only be proposed by somebody who

RAID1 + iSCSI as backup (was Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network)

2023-03-17 Thread Gregory Seidman
On Fri, Mar 17, 2023 at 06:00:46PM +0300, Reco wrote: [...] > PS There's that old saying, "RAID is not a substitute for a backup". > What you're trying to do sounds suspiciously similar to an old "RAID > split-mirror" backup technique. Just saying. This thread has

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Greg Wooledge
On Fri, Mar 17, 2023 at 05:01:57PM +0100, Nicolas George wrote: > Dan Ritter (12023-03-17): > > If Reco didn't understand your question, it's because you are > > very light on details. > > No. Reco's answers contradict the very first sentence of my first > e-mail. The first sentence of your

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Tim Woodall
On Fri, 17 Mar 2023, Nicolas George wrote: Dan Ritter (12023-03-17): If Reco didn't understand your question, it's because you are very light on details. No. Reco's answers contradict the very first sentence of my first e-mail. Is this possible? How can Reco's answers contradict that.

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Nicolas George
Dan Ritter (12023-03-17): > If Reco didn't understand your question, it's because you are > very light on details. No. Reco's answers contradict the very first sentence of my first e-mail. -- Nicolas George

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Dan Ritter
Nicolas George wrote: > Reco (12023-03-17): > > Well, theoretically you can use Btrfs instead. > > No, I cannot. Obviously. > > > What you're trying to do sounds suspiciously similar to an old "RAID > > split-mirror" backup technique. > >

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Nicolas George
Reco (12023-03-17): > Well, theoretically you can use Btrfs instead. No, I cannot. Obviously. > What you're trying to do sounds suspiciously similar to an old "RAID > split-mirror" backup technique. Absolutely not. If you do not understand the question, it is okay to not ans

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Reco
implementing mdadm + iSCSI + ext4 would be probably the best way to achieve whatever you want to do. PS There's that old saying, "RAID is not a substitute for a backup". What you're trying to do sounds suspiciously similar to an old "RAID split-mirror" backup technique. Just saying. Reco

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Nicolas George
Reco (12023-03-17): > Yes, it will destroy the contents of the device, so backup No. If I accepted to have to rely on an extra copy of the data, I would not be trying to do something complicated like that. -- Nicolas George

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Reco
ering" (syncronization between mirror sides) concerns only actual data residing in a zpool. I.e. if you have 1Tb mirrored zpool which is filled to 200Gb you will resync 200Gb. In comparison, mdadm RAID resync will happily read 1Tb from one drive and write 1Tb to another *unless* you're using

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Nicolas George
/md0 --level=mirror --force --raid-devices=1 \ > --metadata=1.0 /dev/local_dev missing > > --metadata=1.0 is highly important here, as it's one of the few mdadm > metadata formats that keeps said metadata at the end of the device. Well, I am sorry to report that you did not read my

Re: More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Reco
sor architecture restrictions, and somewhat unusual design decisions for the filesystem storage. So let's keep it on MDADM + iSCSI for now. > What I want to do: > > 1. Stop programs and umount /dev/something > > 2. mdadm --create /dev/md0 --level=mirror --force --raid-devices=1 \ >

More RAID weirdness: external RAID over network

2023-03-17 Thread Nicolas George
). What I want to do: 1. Stop programs and umount /dev/something 2. mdadm --create /dev/md0 --level=mirror --force --raid-devices=1 \ --metadata-file /data/raid_something /dev/something → Now I have /dev/md0 that is an exact image of /dev/something, with changes on it synced instantaneously. 3

Re: Whole-disk RAID and GPT/UEFI

2023-02-24 Thread David Christensen
On 2/23/23 11:05, Tim Woodall wrote: On Wed, 22 Feb 2023, Nicolas George wrote: Is there a solution to have a whole-disk RAID (software, mdadm) that is also partitioned in GPT and bootable in UEFI? I've wanted this ... I think only hardware raid where the bios thinks it's a single disk

Re: Whole-disk RAID and GPT/UEFI

2023-02-23 Thread Tim Woodall
On Wed, 22 Feb 2023, Nicolas George wrote: Hi. Is there a solution to have a whole-disk RAID (software, mdadm) that is also partitioned in GPT and bootable in UEFI? I've wanted this but settled for using dd to copy the start of the disk, fdisk to rewrite the GPT properly then mdadm

Re: Whole-disk RAID and GPT/UEFI

2023-02-22 Thread Juri Grabowski
Hello, I have seen some installations with following setup: GPT sda1 sdb1 bios_grub md1 0.9 sda2 sdb2 efi md2 0.9 sda3 sdb3 /boot md3 0.9 sda4 sdb4 / md? 1.1 on such installations it's important, that grub installation is made with "grub-install --removable" I mean it was some grub bugs about

Re: Whole-disk RAID and GPT/UEFI

2023-02-22 Thread DdB
Am 22.02.2023 um 17:07 schrieb Nicolas George: > Unfortunately, that puts the partition table > and EFI partition outside the RAID: if you have to add/replace a disk, > you need to partition and reinstall GRUB, that makes a few more > manipulations on top of syncing the RAID. Yes, i g

Re: Whole-disk RAID and GPT/UEFI

2023-02-22 Thread Dan Ritter
Nicolas George wrote: > Hi. > > Is there a solution to have a whole-disk RAID (software, mdadm) that is > also partitioned in GPT and bootable in UEFI? Not that I know of. An EFI partition needs to be FAT32 or VFAT. What I think you could do: Partition the disks with GPT: 2 par

Re: Whole-disk RAID and GPT/UEFI

2023-02-22 Thread Nicolas George
e to make an USB stick that was bootable in legacy mode, bootable in UEFI mode and usable as a regular USB stick (spoiler: it worked, until I tried it with Windows.) But it will not help for this issue. > The only issue, i have had a look at, was the problem to have a raid, > that is bootable

Re: Whole-disk RAID and GPT/UEFI

2023-02-22 Thread DdB
up (not use them at all) and unfortunately that applies to standard GPT tools as well, but the dual bootability can solve some problems. The only issue, i have had a look at, was the problem to have a raid, that is bootable no matter which one of the drives initially fails, a problem, that

Whole-disk RAID and GPT/UEFI

2023-02-22 Thread Nicolas George
Hi. Is there a solution to have a whole-disk RAID (software, mdadm) that is also partitioned in GPT and bootable in UEFI? What I imagine: - RAID1, mirroring: if you ignore the RAID, the data is there. - The GPT metadata is somewhere not too close to the beginning of the drive nor too close

Re: Peut ton faire du raid 10 logiciel?

2023-01-25 Thread ptilou
Le mercredi 4 janvier 2023 à 05:40:06 UTC+1, Olivier backup my spare a écrit : > Bonjour > > J'ai récupéré le PC de ma mère. > J'ai mis une carte RAID chinoise (raid O, 1, 5, 10) > Problème. 2 disk 2 To et 2 disque 4 To > J'ai fait une grappe 2 to et une grappe 4 To en raid

Re: Peut ton faire du raid 10 logiciel?

2023-01-25 Thread Michel Verdier
Le 25 janvier 2023 Daniel Caillibaud a écrit : > L'intérêt du raid0 c'est de multiplier par 2 (quasiment) les perfs disques > (avec deux volumes > dans le raid0), et j'avais compris qu'il fallait des volumes de tailles > voisines pour conserver > ça. Oui c'est vrai, pour éviter de remplir une

Re: Peut ton faire du raid 10 logiciel?

2023-01-25 Thread Daniel Caillibaud
Le 24/01/23 à 13:26, Michel Verdier a écrit : > En fait il faut 2 *partitions* de même taille pour chaque paire > raid1. Mais on peut avoir des tailles différentes pour le raid0. On peut, mais ça dégrade les perfs non ? L'intérêt du raid0 c'est de multiplier par 2 (quasiment) les perfs disques

Re: Peut ton faire du raid 10 logiciel?

2023-01-24 Thread Michel Verdier
Le 24 janvier 2023 Daniel Caillibaud a écrit : > Pour du raid10, il me semble qu'il faut 4 disques de même taille. > > Il vaut mieux faire d'abord les paires de raid1 puis le raid0 entre deux > paires (sinon avec la > perte d'un seul disque tu perds tout). En fait il faut 2 *partitions* de même

Re: Peut ton faire du raid 10 logiciel?

2023-01-24 Thread Daniel Caillibaud
Le 04/01/23 à 05:37, Olivier backup my spare a écrit : > Bonjour > > J'ai récupéré le PC de ma mère. > J'ai mis une carte RAID chinoise (raid O, 1, 5, 10) > Problème. 2 disk 2 To et 2 disque 4 To > J'ai fait une grappe 2 to et une grappe 4 To en raid 0 > Là, la carte refus

Re: Peut ton faire du raid 10 logiciel?

2023-01-04 Thread Michel Verdier
Le 4 janvier 2023 Olivier backup my spare a écrit : > Là, la carte refuse de faire du raid 10 > > Puis je le faire avec la debian. Je n'ai jamais fait de raid logiciel sous > linux, alors je demande. Oui ça marche très bien avec mdadm.

Peut ton faire du raid 10 logiciel?

2023-01-03 Thread Olivier backup my spare
Bonjour J'ai récupéré le PC de ma mère. J'ai mis une carte RAID chinoise (raid O, 1, 5, 10) Problème. 2 disk 2 To et 2 disque 4 To J'ai fait une grappe 2 to et une grappe 4 To en raid 0 Là, la carte refuse de faire du raid 10 Puis je le faire avec la debian. Je n'ai jamais fait de raid logiciel

Re: Dell CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation -> RAID On vs AHCI

2022-12-24 Thread David Christensen
computers. When I boot the flash drive in a Dell Precision 3630 Tower that has Windows 11 Pro installed on the internal NVMe drive, the internal PCIe NVMe drive is not visible to Linux: The work-around is to change CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation from "RAID On: to "

Re: Dell CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation -> RAID On vs AHCI

2022-12-24 Thread David Christensen
acity storage costs to a minimum." I believe that is marketing speak for "the computer supports Optane Memory", not "every machine comes with Optane Memory". I believe that's the pseudo-RAID you are seeing in the UEFI setup screen. Maybe you can see the physical driv

Re: Dell CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation -> RAID On vs AHCI

2022-12-24 Thread Andrew M.A. Cater
1 11.2G 0 part > `-sda4_crypt 254:00 11.2G 0 crypt / > sr0 11:01 1024M 0 rom > > 2022-12-23 18:46:19 root@laalaa ~/laalaa.tracy.holgerdanske.com > # l /dev/n* > /dev/null /dev/nvram > > /dev/net: > ./ ../ tun > > > The work-around

Re: Dell CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation -> RAID On vs AHCI

2022-12-24 Thread Jeffrey Walton
s/dfb/p/precision-3630-workstation/pd, the machine has Optane. I believe that's the pseudo-RAID you are seeing in the UEFI setup screen. Maybe you can see the physical drives using raid utilities. Jeff

Re: Dell CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation -> RAID On vs AHCI

2022-12-24 Thread David Christensen
boot the flash drive in a Dell Precision 3630 Tower that has Windows 11 Pro installed on the internal NVMe drive, the internal PCIe NVMe drive is not visible to Linux: The work-around is to change CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation from "RAID On: to "AHC

Re: Dell CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation -> RAID On vs AHCI

2022-12-23 Thread Jeffrey Walton
t >`-sda4_crypt 254:00 11.2G 0 crypt / > sr0 11:01 1024M 0 rom > > 2022-12-23 18:46:19 root@laalaa ~/laalaa.tracy.holgerdanske.com > # l /dev/n* > /dev/null /dev/nvram > > /dev/net: > ./ ../ tun > > > The work-around is to change CMOS

Dell CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation -> RAID On vs AHCI

2022-12-23 Thread David Christensen
11.2G 0 crypt / sr0 11:01 1024M 0 rom 2022-12-23 18:46:19 root@laalaa ~/laalaa.tracy.holgerdanske.com # l /dev/n* /dev/null /dev/nvram /dev/net: ./ ../ tun The work-around is to change CMOS Setup -> System Configuration -> SATA Operation from "RAID On: to "AHC

network raid (Re: deduplicating file systems: VDO with Debian?)

2022-11-11 Thread hede
Am 10.11.2022 14:40, schrieb Curt: (or maybe a RAID array is conceivable over a network and a distance?). Not only conceivable, but indeed practicable: Linbit DRBD

Re: how to change device number in RAID array

2022-08-23 Thread Andy Smith
Hi Gary, On Mon, Aug 22, 2022 at 10:00:34AM -0400, Gary Dale wrote: > I'm running Debian/Bookworm on an AMD64 system. I recently added a second > drive to it for use in a RAID1 array. What was the configuration of the array before you added the new drive? Was it a RAID-1 with one missing

Re: how to change device number in RAID array

2022-08-22 Thread Charles Curley
2 blocks super 1.2 level 5, 64k chunk, algorithm 2 [3/3] [UUU] bitmap: 0/30 pages [0KB], 65536KB chunk unused devices: root@hawk:~# You may notice from my output that I have raid on 0, 1, 3, and 4. 4 is the spare. 3 and 4 are not in numeric order. And there is no 2. So I'm not sure that the fa

Re: how to change device number in RAID array

2022-08-22 Thread Cindy Sue Causey
On 8/22/22, Gary Dale wrote: > I'm running Debian/Bookworm on an AMD64 system. I recently added a > second drive to it for use in a RAID1 array. However I'm now getting > regular messages about "SparesMissing event on...". > > cat /proc/mdstat shows the problem: active raid1 sda1[0] sdb1[2] - the

how to change device number in RAID array

2022-08-22 Thread Gary Dale
I'm running Debian/Bookworm on an AMD64 system. I recently added a second drive to it for use in a RAID1 array. However I'm now getting regular messages about "SparesMissing event on...". cat /proc/mdstat shows the problem: active raid1 sda1[0] sdb1[2] - the newly added drive is showing up as

RE: OT: RAID-5 sobre SSD

2022-07-25 Thread Marcelo Olcese (Gmail)
Hola! Tengo 3 servidores DEBIAN 11 con RAID 5 y su Spare, 1 con RAID 1 y su Spare, todos con SSD, que salen más baratos que los SAS. Por ahora ningún problema. SLdos, Marcelo.- -Mensaje original- De: Debian [mailto:javier.debian.bb...@gmail.com] Enviado el: martes, 19 de julio de 2022

Re: OT: RAID-5 sobre SSD

2022-07-19 Thread Debian
fallan todos a la vez te hacen una avería. Un saludo. ESO NO ME GUSTA. ¿No te acordás la marca/modelo? Justamente en un RAID uno siempre trata de usar misma marca, modelo y en lo posible, serie, para que la velocidad de todos sea exactamente la misma. JAP Lo encontré: https

Re: OT: RAID-5 sobre SSD

2022-07-19 Thread Debian
saludo. ESO NO ME GUSTA. ¿No te acordás la marca/modelo? Justamente en un RAID uno siempre trata de usar misma marca, modelo y en lo posible, serie, para que la velocidad de todos sea exactamente la misma. JAP

Re: OT: RAID-5 sobre SSD

2022-07-19 Thread Pedro Gras
wrote: > El 18/7/22 a las 15:05, Camaleón escribió: > > El 2022-07-18 a las 10:21 -0300, Debian escribió: > > > >> Buenos días. > >> > >> Esta pregunta va para Camaleón, pues creo que es la única persona que > tiene > >> experiencia en el te

Re: OT: RAID-5 sobre SSD

2022-07-19 Thread Debian
El 18/7/22 a las 15:05, Camaleón escribió: El 2022-07-18 a las 10:21 -0300, Debian escribió: Buenos días. Esta pregunta va para Camaleón, pues creo que es la única persona que tiene experiencia en el tema de los que suelen leer por acá. Con RAID mi experiencia es escasa (sólo he trabajado

Re: OT: RAID-5 sobre SSD

2022-07-18 Thread Camaleón
El 2022-07-18 a las 10:21 -0300, Debian escribió: > Buenos días. > > Esta pregunta va para Camaleón, pues creo que es la única persona que tiene > experiencia en el tema de los que suelen leer por acá. Con RAID mi experiencia es escasa (sólo he trabajado con hardware raid, nive

OT: RAID-5 sobre SSD

2022-07-18 Thread Debian
Buenos días. Esta pregunta va para Camaleón, pues creo que es la única persona que tiene experiencia en el tema de los que suelen leer por acá. Tengo que reemplazar un pequeño servidor con RAID-5 por software sobre un Debian con 4 discos HDD de 1Tb cada uno que está tirando desde hace ya 4

Re: grub2 uefi et raid

2021-11-05 Thread Kohler Gerard
Le 20/10/2021 à 06:43, Jean-Michel OLTRA a écrit : Bonjour, Le mardi 19 octobre 2021, Kohler Gerard a écrit... Le problème : je ne me rappelle plus quel est le Debian qui gère le Grub, ni sur quel disque et quelle partition il est installé. comment faire pour avoir ces réponses ?

Re : Re: grub2 uefi et raid

2021-10-21 Thread k6dedijon
@lists.debian.org Envoyé: Wed, 20 Oct 2021 12:38:55 +0200 (CEST) Objet: Re: grub2 uefi et raid Tu t'es aventuré dans une installation compliquée. Pour ma part j'ai arrêté de faire du multiboot géré par un OS ça finit toujours mal lors d'une réinstallation d'un OS. Sur mon ordi fixe qui a plusieurs OS

Re: grub2 uefi et raid

2021-10-20 Thread Wallace
Tu t'es aventuré dans une installation compliquée. Pour ma part j'ai arrêté de faire du multiboot géré par un OS ça finit toujours mal lors d'une réinstallation d'un OS. Sur mon ordi fixe qui a plusieurs OS, lorsque je fais une installation je débranche tous les disques non concernés, puis

Re: grub2 uefi et raid

2021-10-19 Thread Jean-Michel OLTRA
Bonjour, Le mardi 19 octobre 2021, Kohler Gerard a écrit... > Le problème : je ne me rappelle plus quel est le Debian qui gère le Grub, ni > sur quel disque et quelle partition il est installé. > > comment faire pour avoir ces réponses ? Avec `fdisk -l` ou au menu de grub lors du

grub2 uefi et raid

2021-10-19 Thread Kohler Gerard
bonjour, voulant installer la version testing je me heurte à un problème bête : Ma machine est dotée d'UEFI. j'ai 3 DD dont les deux premiers sont montés en RAID1 (/dev/sda et /dev/sdb) et ils contiennent mes données, le troisième (/dev/sdc) est mon disque système. sur mon disque système

Re: debian-installer RAID question

2021-09-18 Thread Felix Natter
Many Thanks for the very helpful reply, Reco! -- Felix Natter debian/rules!

Re: debian-installer RAID question

2021-09-18 Thread Felix Natter
Thanks Sven! -- Felix Natter debian/rules!

Re: debian-installer RAID question

2021-09-18 Thread Felix Natter
Many Thanks for the very helpful reply Andy! -- Felix Natter debian/rules!

Re: debian-installer RAID question

2021-09-18 Thread Felix Natter
Darac Marjal writes: > On 11/09/2021 17:55, Felix Natter wrote: >> hello fellow Debian users, >> >> I have an SSD for the root filesystem, and two HDDs using RAID1 for >> /storage running Debian10. Now I need a plan B in case the upgrade >> fails. > > Just want to check that you've not missed

Re: debian-installer RAID question

2021-09-18 Thread Felix Natter
hi Andrei, Andrei POPESCU writes: thank you for your answer. > On Sb, 11 sep 21, 18:55:56, Felix Natter wrote: >> hello fellow Debian users, >> >> I have an SSD for the root filesystem, and two HDDs using RAID1 for >> /storage running Debian10. Now I need a plan B in case the upgrade >>

Re: mdadm RAID and the Bullseye installer

2021-09-14 Thread Gene Heskett
On Tuesday 14 September 2021 12:55:41 Dan Ritter wrote: > Gene Heskett wrote: > > This is interesting and I will likely do it when I install the > > debian-11.1-net-install I just burnt. > > > > But, I have installed 4, 1 terabyte samsung SSD's on a separate > >

mdadm RAID and the Bullseye installer

2021-09-14 Thread Dan Ritter
Gene Heskett wrote: > This is interesting and I will likely do it when I install the > debian-11.1-net-install I just burnt. > > But, I have installed 4, 1 terabyte samsung SSD's on a separate non-raid > controller card which I intend to use as a software raid-6 or 10

  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   >