[Design-team] Re: [badges] Re: Re: Fedora Badges: Switching from bad...@lists.fp.o list to Discourse?

2018-11-06 Thread Máirín Duffy
Hi,Just 2 points, one I think is important for commops and the only reason I bring it up is to be helpful there, the other is re: ML subs.Right so the first thing is, you measured commops activity on discourse for oct, but what about the ML activity? You got 9 participants and iirc 22 threads

[Design-team] Planning first-ever Badges FAD

2018-11-06 Thread Justin W. Flory
Hi all, Yesterday, Marie and I worked on a draft to map out goals and planning for a Fedora Badges FAD in 2019; constructive feedback is welcome before we put together a proposal to the Fedora Council:

[Design-team] Re: [badges] Fedora Badges: Switching from bad...@lists.fp.o list to Discourse?

2018-11-06 Thread Justin W. Flory
Hi Máirín, thanks for sharing this feedback. I appreciate the perspective you bring and I agree that for the bigger-picture problems of engagement and participation, it is a people-scale issue, not technology-scale. I am still in favor of switching to a Discourse forum for three reasons: 1.

[Design-team] Re: [badges] Fedora Badges: Switching from bad...@lists.fp.o list to Discourse?

2018-11-06 Thread Máirín Duffy
Hi,None of the 3 reasons you cited preclude using hyperkitty. It addresses the same usage patterns. I continue to see no compelling discourse specific reason to move from hyperkitty based on the reasoning you put ogether. I also fail to see a statistically significant improvement in your single