Re: OpenJDK8 / OpenJDK11 container deprecation

2023-02-16 Thread Luke Cwik via dev
I upgraded the docker version on Jenkins workers and the tests passed. (also installed Python 3.11 so we are ready for that) On Tue, Feb 14, 2023 at 3:21 PM Kenneth Knowles wrote: > SGTM. I asked on the PR if this could impact users, but having read the > docker release calendar I am not

Re: OpenJDK8 / OpenJDK11 container deprecation

2023-02-14 Thread Kenneth Knowles
SGTM. I asked on the PR if this could impact users, but having read the docker release calendar I am not concerned. The last update to the old version was in 2019, and the introduction of compatible versions was 2020. On Tue, Feb 14, 2023 at 3:01 PM Byron Ellis via user wrote: > FWIW I am Team

Re: OpenJDK8 / OpenJDK11 container deprecation

2023-02-14 Thread Byron Ellis via dev
FWIW I am Team Upgrade Docker :-) On Tue, Feb 14, 2023 at 2:53 PM Luke Cwik via user wrote: > I made some progress in testing the container and did hit an issue where > Ubuntu 22.04 "Jammy" is dependent on the version of Docker installed. It > turns out that our boot.go crashes with

Re: OpenJDK8 / OpenJDK11 container deprecation

2023-02-14 Thread Luke Cwik via dev
I made some progress in testing the container and did hit an issue where Ubuntu 22.04 "Jammy" is dependent on the version of Docker installed. It turns out that our boot.go crashes with "runtime/cgo: pthread_create failed: Operation not permitted" because the Ubuntu 22.04 is using new syscalls

Re: OpenJDK8 / OpenJDK11 container deprecation

2023-02-09 Thread Luke Cwik via dev
Our current container java 8 container is 262 MiBs and layers on top of openjdk:8-bullseye which is 226 MiBs compressed while eclipse-temurin:8 is 92 MiBs compressed and eclipse-temurin:8-alpine is 65 MiBs compressed. I would rather not get into issues with C library differences caused by the

Re: OpenJDK8 / OpenJDK11 container deprecation

2023-02-07 Thread Andrew Pilloud via dev
This sounds reasonable to me as well. I've made swaps like this in the past, the base image of each is probably a bigger factor than the JDK. The openjdk images were based on Debian 11. The default eclipse-temurin images are based on Ubuntu 22.04 with an alpine option. Ubuntu is a Debian

Re: OpenJDK8 / OpenJDK11 container deprecation

2023-02-07 Thread Robert Bradshaw via dev
Seams reasonable to me. On Tue, Feb 7, 2023 at 4:19 PM Luke Cwik via user wrote: > > As per [1], the JDK8 and JDK11 containers that Apache Beam uses have stopped > being built and supported since July 2022. I have filed [2] to track the > resolution of this issue. > > Based upon [1], almost

OpenJDK8 / OpenJDK11 container deprecation

2023-02-07 Thread Luke Cwik via dev
As per [1], the JDK8 and JDK11 containers that Apache Beam uses have stopped being built and supported since July 2022. I have filed [2] to track the resolution of this issue. Based upon [1], almost everyone is swapping to the eclipse-temurin container[3] as their base based upon the linked