Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-25 Thread Carlos Sanchez
Result 3 +1 (including mine) will proceed with the release On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 8:53 AM, John Casey [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 Carlos Sanchez wrote: Release was rolledback and performed again, site and staging repo updated, please restart the voting process

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Arnaud HERITIER
Couldn't we setup a custom profile for QA checks (pmd, checkstyle, clirr ...) that we activate in a separate project in the CI server ? It's what I begin to do at work. The advantage is to keep the integration build fast and we can have a look at the QA builds to improve them. Arnaud On Mon, Jul

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Olivier Lamy
Hi, I agree too. IMHO we don't have to block a release because they are checkstyle errors : releasing something must not be nightmare (we are here to help users and fix issues). Ok except for missing license headers in source files. We will find some exceptions which will prevent automatisation of

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Brett Porter
On 21/07/2008, at 4:56 PM, Arnaud HERITIER wrote: Couldn't we setup a custom profile for QA checks (pmd, checkstyle, clirr ...) that we activate in a separate project in the CI server ? It's what I begin to do at work. The advantage is to keep the integration build fast and we can have a

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Stephane Nicoll
It is maybe a stupid question, but I think it's still using ant 1.6.5. I know that switching to 1.7 (I did locally) issue a weird path with space problem on Windows. Ant 1.7.1 is out but I don't know if the problem is fixed and I am lazy to search in BugSuperZilla. To me, the biggest limitation

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Dennis Lundberg
http://jira.codehaus.org/browse/MANTRUN-68 is scheduled for version 1.3. I think Carlos wanted to get a version of the plugin out with all the fixes, before upgrading Ant. Yes, the spaces in a Windows path was fixed in 1.7.1. Stephane Nicoll wrote: It is maybe a stupid question, but I think

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Dennis Lundberg
Olivier Lamy wrote: Hi, I agree too. IMHO we don't have to block a release because they are checkstyle errors : releasing something must not be nightmare (we are here to help users and fix issues). Right, I totally agree with that. I just wrote down things that are worth looking at during

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Jason van Zyl
points that we need to reduce Checkstyle errors, checking Clirr report and licenses. Any others ideas? Cheers, Vincent -- Forwarded message -- From: Dennis Lundberg [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: 16 juil. 2008 15:48 Subject: Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2 To: Maven

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Stephane Nicoll
Makes sense. Thanks for the info. S. On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 11:54 AM, Dennis Lundberg [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: http://jira.codehaus.org/browse/MANTRUN-68 is scheduled for version 1.3. I think Carlos wanted to get a version of the plugin out with all the fixes, before upgrading Ant. Yes,

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Jesse McConnell
+1 On Sun, Jul 20, 2008 at 4:16 PM, Carlos Sanchez [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Release was rolledback and performed again, site and staging repo updated, please restart the voting process http://jira.codehaus.org/secure/ReleaseNote.jspa?projectId=11125styleName=Htmlversion=12210 Staging repo:

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread Dennis Lundberg
+1 Carlos Sanchez wrote: Release was rolledback and performed again, site and staging repo updated, please restart the voting process http://jira.codehaus.org/secure/ReleaseNote.jspa?projectId=11125styleName=Htmlversion=12210 Staging repo: http://people.apache.org/~carlos/staging-repo

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-21 Thread John Casey
+1 Carlos Sanchez wrote: Release was rolledback and performed again, site and staging repo updated, please restart the voting process http://jira.codehaus.org/secure/ReleaseNote.jspa?projectId=11125styleName=Htmlversion=12210 Staging repo: http://people.apache.org/~carlos/staging-repo

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-20 Thread Vincent Siveton
: Dennis Lundberg [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: 16 juil. 2008 15:48 Subject: Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2 To: Maven Developers List dev@maven.apache.org Thanks for pushing for this release Carlos! Unfortunately there are a couple of things that needs to be fixed before we

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-20 Thread Carlos Sanchez
Release was rolledback and performed again, site and staging repo updated, please restart the voting process http://jira.codehaus.org/secure/ReleaseNote.jspa?projectId=11125styleName=Htmlversion=12210 Staging repo: http://people.apache.org/~carlos/staging-repo Staging site:

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-20 Thread Brett Porter
On 19/07/2008, at 11:26 PM, Dennis Lundberg wrote: I went and harvested the mojo-dev list for release vote comments, most of the from Benjamin. Some are specific to plugins, but many are general. Here's the list: Thanks Dennis! (and Benjamin :) Inherit from the latest released parent

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-19 Thread Dennis Lundberg
Lundberg [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: 16 juil. 2008 15:48 Subject: Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2 To: Maven Developers List dev@maven.apache.org Thanks for pushing for this release Carlos! Unfortunately there are a couple of things that needs to be fixed before we can release 1.2

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-19 Thread Jason van Zyl
] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2 To: Maven Developers List dev@maven.apache.org Thanks for pushing for this release Carlos! Unfortunately there are a couple of things that needs to be fixed before we can release 1.2, for which I have to vote -1 to the current release candidate. - The POM is missing

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-18 Thread Vincent Siveton
Hi, Following the recent Dennis's comments on MPIR and Antrun, I asked myself how to improve our QA review and specially how to handle Maven reports in the release process. Does release manager need to justify failing reports for a given release? If so, how. How to improve the Maven report conf

[VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-16 Thread Carlos Sanchez
Hi, 9 issues fixed. Last release was 2.5 years ago http://jira.codehaus.org/secure/ReleaseNote.jspa?projectId=11125styleName=Htmlversion=12210 Staging repo: http://people.apache.org/~carlos/staging-repo Staging site: http://maven.apache.org/plugins/maven-antrun-plugin-1.2/ Guide to testing

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-16 Thread Dennis Lundberg
Thanks for pushing for this release Carlos! Unfortunately there are a couple of things that needs to be fixed before we can release 1.2, for which I have to vote -1 to the current release candidate. - The POM is missing the license header (I fixed this in svn) - The Source files have the old

Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-16 Thread Vincent Siveton
Thanks Dennis to fix them. BTW Carlos, could you also include a release notes link on the jira report? We discussed about it recently. Cheers, Vincent 2008/7/16, Dennis Lundberg [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Thanks for pushing for this release Carlos! Unfortunately there are a couple of things that

How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-16 Thread Vincent Siveton
] Date: 16 juil. 2008 15:48 Subject: Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2 To: Maven Developers List dev@maven.apache.org Thanks for pushing for this release Carlos! Unfortunately there are a couple of things that needs to be fixed before we can release 1.2, for which I have to vote

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-16 Thread Carlos Sanchez
Checkstyle errors, checking Clirr report and licenses. Any others ideas? Cheers, Vincent -- Forwarded message -- From: Dennis Lundberg [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: 16 juil. 2008 15:48 Subject: Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2 To: Maven Developers List dev

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-16 Thread Vincent Siveton
PROTECTED] Date: 16 juil. 2008 15:48 Subject: Re: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2 To: Maven Developers List dev@maven.apache.org Thanks for pushing for this release Carlos! Unfortunately there are a couple of things that needs to be fixed before we can release

Re: How to validate a Maven release? Fwd: [VOTE] Release Maven antrun plugin version 1.2

2008-07-16 Thread Benjamin Bentmann
Vincent Siveton wrote: What are the minimalist things that we need to check for a good Maven release? [...] Any others ideas? Cross-compiling against the intended minimum JDK to catch accidental usage of newer types/methods. Checking for properly declared dependencies with the help of