Re: [OSM-dev] Standardized feature/tag database idea & proposal

2020-11-16 Thread Mateusz Konieczny via dev
Nov 16, 2020, 10:21 by si...@poole.ch: > > the iD presets are the law of the land and anything else is simply > irrelevant. > > That is so overstating things that it ceases to be an useful statement. iD presets and "press button here to `upgrade tags`  without explanation what and why and

Re: [OSM-dev] Standardized feature/tag database idea & proposal

2020-11-16 Thread Christoph Hormann
> Simon Poole hat am 16.11.2020 10:21 geschrieben: > > [...] On the other hand, not just because of the demographics, but also > because of the OSMFs involvement, like it or not, the iD presets are the law > of the land and anything else is simply irrelevant. From my experience with

Re: [OSM-dev] Standardized feature/tag database idea & proposal

2020-11-16 Thread Simon Poole
Frederik has already pointed out some of the relevant historic points. On top of that there is https://github.com/osmlab/editor-presets and I proposed  something similar a couple of years back as a GSOC project. I would consider the concept moot. On the one hand, while theoretically still

Re: [OSM-dev] Standardized feature/tag database idea & proposal

2020-11-16 Thread Frederik Ramm
Seth, On 11/15/20 19:14, Seth Deegan wrote: > Has anyone ever thought of creating an official database that stores all > of the approved and in-use tags/features in OSM? Yes, of course, this idea has been around in a variety of flavours. I remember a conference talk by David Earl in 2010

Re: [OSM-dev] Standardized feature/tag database idea & proposal

2020-11-15 Thread Mateusz Konieczny via dev
Nov 15, 2020, 19:14 by jayands...@gmail.com: > Idea > Has anyone ever thought of creating an official database that stores all of > the approved and in-use tags/features in OSM?  > Yes. Depending on what one means by "database" OSM Wiki can be considered as one. Wikidata copy ( 

[OSM-dev] Standardized feature/tag database idea & proposal

2020-11-15 Thread Seth Deegan
*Idea* Has anyone ever thought of creating an official database that stores all of the approved and in-use tags/features in OSM? *Reasoning* This could allow the editors (iD and JOSM, StreetComplete, GoMap!) and data consumers (osm-carto,. Mapbox etc.), to easily stay up-to-date with new