Re: [DISCUSS] Minimize use of MINOR, BUILD, and HOTFIX w/ no JIRA

2016-07-07 Thread Tom Graves
I think the problems comes in with your definition as well as peoples interpretation of that.  I don't agree with your statement of "where the "how" is different from the "what"".   This could apply to a lot of things.  I could easily file a jira that says remove synchronization on routine x,

Re: [DISCUSS] Minimize use of MINOR, BUILD, and HOTFIX w/ no JIRA

2016-07-07 Thread Sean Owen
I don't agree that every change needs a JIRA, myself. Really, we didn't choose to have this system split across JIRA and Github PRs. It's necessitated by how the ASF works (and with some good reasons). But while we have this dual system, I figure, let's try to make some sense of it. I think it

Re: [DISCUSS] Minimize use of MINOR, BUILD, and HOTFIX w/ no JIRA

2016-07-07 Thread Tom Graves
Popping this back up to the dev list again.  I see a bunch of checkins with minor or hotfix.   It seems to me we shouldn't be doing this, but I would like to hear thoughts from others.  I see no reason we can't have a jira for each of those issues, it only takes a few seconds to file one and it

Re: [DISCUSS] Minimize use of MINOR, BUILD, and HOTFIX w/ no JIRA

2015-06-11 Thread shane knapp
+1, and i know i've been guilty of this in the past. :) On Wed, Jun 10, 2015 at 10:20 PM, Joseph Bradley jos...@databricks.com wrote: +1 On Sat, Jun 6, 2015 at 9:01 AM, Patrick Wendell pwend...@gmail.com wrote: Hey All, Just a request here - it would be great if people could create

Re: [DISCUSS] Minimize use of MINOR, BUILD, and HOTFIX w/ no JIRA

2015-06-10 Thread Joseph Bradley
+1 On Sat, Jun 6, 2015 at 9:01 AM, Patrick Wendell pwend...@gmail.com wrote: Hey All, Just a request here - it would be great if people could create JIRA's for any and all merged pull requests. The reason is that when patches get reverted due to build breaks or other issues, it is very

[DISCUSS] Minimize use of MINOR, BUILD, and HOTFIX w/ no JIRA

2015-06-06 Thread Patrick Wendell
Hey All, Just a request here - it would be great if people could create JIRA's for any and all merged pull requests. The reason is that when patches get reverted due to build breaks or other issues, it is very difficult to keep track of what is going on if there is no JIRA. Here is a list of 5