Re: [DISCUSS] Switch to GitHub issues after trial

2018-03-07 Thread Keith Turner
On Mon, Mar 5, 2018 at 6:07 PM, Keith Turner wrote: > On Thu, Feb 15, 2018 at 12:52 PM, Josh Elser wrote: >> -0 as an initial reaction because I'm still not convinced that GH issues >> provides any additional features or better experience than JIRA does, and >> this change would only serve to fra

Re: [DISCUSS] Switch to GitHub issues after trial

2018-03-07 Thread Mike Walch
> > 4. What is the migration plan for existing issues? Will we have split > issue >tracker for years? > > The proposal documents migrating existing JIRA issues as they are worked. > This means that existing JIRA issues that are never worked will never > migrate. After all branches are re

Re: [DISCUSS] Switch to GitHub issues after trial

2018-03-07 Thread Keith Turner
On Wed, Mar 7, 2018 at 11:17 AM, Mike Walch wrote: >> >> 4. What is the migration plan for existing issues? Will we have split >> issue >>tracker for years? >> >> The proposal documents migrating existing JIRA issues as they are worked. >> This means that existing JIRA issues that are nev

Re: [DISCUSS] Switch to GitHub issues after trial

2018-03-07 Thread Josh Elser
Sorry for the top-post. I really appreciate the numbered list below, Keith. Specifically the answers to #1 and #4 make me very happy. I think #5 needs some a little more concrete (IMO, you should just decide what it should be). #6 +1 to a message to private, this is how Apache general reque

Re: [DISCUSS] Switch to GitHub issues after trial

2018-03-07 Thread Keith Turner
On Wed, Mar 7, 2018 at 11:50 AM, Josh Elser wrote: > Sorry for the top-post. > > I really appreciate the numbered list below, Keith. Specifically the answers > to #1 and #4 make me very happy. > > I think #5 needs some a little more concrete (IMO, you should just decide > what it should be). My w

Re: [DISCUSS] Switch to GitHub issues after trial

2018-03-07 Thread Christopher
On Wed, Mar 7, 2018 at 11:50 AM Josh Elser wrote: > Sorry for the top-post. > > I really appreciate the numbered list below, Keith. Specifically the > answers to #1 and #4 make me very happy. > > I think #5 needs some a little more concrete (IMO, you should just > decide what it should be). > > #