Re: [dns-privacy] User Perspective

2018-09-24 Thread Brian Haberman
All, I would like the focus for this week (9/24-9/30) to be on clarifying the requirements from the user's perspective. So far, I have seen: * DNS transaction privacy, if possible * User willingness to send PII if transaction is encrypted Do others have additional requirements? If you

[dns-privacy] Moving discussions along

2018-09-24 Thread Brian Haberman
All, The threads for discussing the various perspectives on the recursive-to-authoritative problem space have fizzled out. Rather than having a series of parallel discussions going on, I am going to try and get a focus on one area per week. Hopefully, this will get more people involved in the

Re: [dns-privacy] User Perspective

2018-09-24 Thread Melinda Shore
On 9/24/18 11:58 AM, Amelia Andersdotter wrote: > I have difficulties seeing how a user (within the meaning of individual > internet consumer) has any practical choice to other than to share PII > with a DNS provider? It's not so much about "willingness" as it is about > "feeling comfortable

Re: [dns-privacy] User Perspective

2018-09-24 Thread Amelia Andersdotter
On 2018-09-24 16:08, Brian Haberman wrote: > All, > I would like the focus for this week (9/24-9/30) to be on > clarifying the requirements from the user's perspective. So far, I have > seen: > > * DNS transaction privacy, if possible > * User willingness to send PII if transaction is