Re: [ECOLOG-L] Bias for positive results in science was Sarewitz on Systematic Error

2012-05-17 Thread Martin Meiss
But Pedro, how do you go about understanding a system without, either formally or informally, generating and testing hypotheses? If I observe that caterpillars are eating daisies and catbirds are eating caterpillars, my mind automatically thinks, Hmm, maybe the catbird population density affects

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Lovelock retracts

2012-05-17 Thread Steve Brewer
Although I am inclined to agree that most of the recent warming has a strong anthropogenic signature, I looked at the abstract of the Journal of Climate article (I don't have access to the full article) and don't see how you can definitely conclude that the post 1950s warming is significantly

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Bias for positive results in science was Sarewitz on Systematic Error

2012-05-17 Thread Pedro Barbosa
No argument, Martin. The caterpillars are eating daisies and catbirds are eating caterpillars was the beginning of understanding the nature of the interactions in the field. But, I simply suggest that the field observations are likely to be the preferred basis upon which to

[ECOLOG-L] Postdoctoral opportunity in vegetation remote sensing

2012-05-17 Thread José Gómez-Dans
Dear all, A postdoc opportunity on remote sensing of chlorophyll fluorescence @FU Berlin has come up. The title of the post is Analysis of global maps of terrestrial chlorophyll fluorescence derived from space measurments Please find more information on this URL http://goo.gl/MPufB. Regards,

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Used a tablet for field work?

2012-05-17 Thread Lindsay Reynolds
Based on several field seasons of success by my colleagues with this set up, I'm going to implement field data collection on iPod Touches this summer. iPod Touches are relatively cheap and the functionality for what I need is good. I think glare might be an issue we will have to deal with. The

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Bias for positive results in science was Sarewitz on Systematic Error

2012-05-17 Thread Lee Dyer
Martin,Good point - of course all good science is hypothesis driven ... but I am sure that nobody wants the literature flooded with the thousands of hypotheses that go through my mind when I'm in the field or laboratory. Most of these informal hypotheses are unreasonable, silly, confused, and

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Lovelock retracts

2012-05-17 Thread Christopher PT Peters
So I ask, should scientists start communicating more to the general public; and would communicating more to the general public be more of a benefit to our society than increasing our publication record? Journalists grab their soundbite, run with it, and completely misrepresent the science paper,

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Bias for positive results in science was Sarewitz on Systematic Error

2012-05-17 Thread David Inouye
Posting this for Karen: Martin, Questions are great. From my perspective, asking first about which other species are present and what they are doing would lead to a broader view of the community at large and lead to more meaningful specific hypotheses about the interaction you initially

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Lovelock retracts

2012-05-17 Thread Laura Jodice
I think that scientists should make use of people who are well versed in both science and communications. I also think that scientists should be very careful about stretching the truth if they get involved in advocacy. I think that there is a habit among some NGOs and environmental advocates

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Used a tablet for field work?

2012-05-17 Thread Zak Gezon
I have an iphone that I use in the field all the time. I haven't used it for data entry, although that is something I would be interested in exploring. I have heard that LogMeIn can be used to access data files on a PC so that data entry can be done in the field directly into an excel file,

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Lovelock retracts

2012-05-17 Thread Chris Merkord
On Thu, May 17, 2012 at 8:19 AM, Basil Iannone bian...@uic.edu wrote: So I ask, should scientists start communicating more to the general public; A recent study (Brulle et al. in press, below) shows that U.S. public opinion on climate change is little influenced by access to scientific

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Lovelock retracts

2012-05-17 Thread Don McKenzie
Just so people know -- this article is not free for download. You will be asked to pay $35 USD. On May 17, 2012, at 8:52 AM, Chris Merkord wrote: On Thu, May 17, 2012 at 8:19 AM, Basil Iannone bian...@uic.edu wrote: So I ask, should scientists start communicating more to the general

[ECOLOG-L] Graduate Study in Plant Biology

2012-05-17 Thread Glenn Matlack
Graduate Study in Plant Biology The Department of Environmental and Plant Biology, Ohio University, offers graduate programs at the Masters and PhD levels. Areas of study include cell molecular biology, plant structure/development, phylogeny amp; evolution, and plant ecology, with particular

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Lovelock retracts

2012-05-17 Thread Basil Iannone
Chris, Good point. The media is looking for a story that will sell, which in the case of science is not often the case (sorry folks, not everyone finds our research as interesting as we do). I wasn't suggesting that we talk to the media more, but perhaps communicate more directly to the general

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Ride the Train to ESA 2012 in Portland, OR!

2012-05-17 Thread Jane Shevtsov
I also plan to take the train from Los Angeles, largely because it's a beautiful route and train trips are fun. Jane On Wed, May 16, 2012 at 5:38 PM, Jorge Ramos jramo...@asu.edu wrote: Hello ESA 2012 participants,  The ESA Student Section is happy to announce that one of its members, Andrew

[ECOLOG-L] Calling All Biologists: Showcase Science to Policymakers

2012-05-17 Thread Julie Palakovich Carr
This August, the American Institute of Biological Sciences (AIBS) will coordinate the 4th Annual Biological Sciences Congressional District Visits event. This national initiative encourages members of the science community to meet with their elected officials. Unlike other efforts to educate

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Ride the Train to ESA 2012 in Portland, OR!

2012-05-17 Thread Amartya Saha
Hello Jorge, riding a train cross-country is extremely enjoyable, affords time for oneself and is also a great gesture. But at the same time, unfortunately it is time consuming (5 days from Miami to Portland one way, difficult to take that much time off for, especially for those with

[ECOLOG-L] Fwd: Government of Canada announces closure of the Experimental Lakes Area

2012-05-17 Thread Michael Rennie
Fisheries and Oceans Canada staff are today being informed of the decision of the Government of Canada to close operations at the Experimental Lakes Area in Kenora, Ontario. In its decision, the Government has said that whole lake manipulative experiments are better carried out by universities