"Fran Burstall (Gmail)" writes:
> I get a lot of mismatches emms-info-native vs emms-info-taglib around two
> tags:
>
> 1. albumartistsort:
>
> 2. genre: emms-native-info yields things like "(16)" while
> emms-print-meta-data gives things like "Reggae".
>
> I think all this happened at commit
"Fran Burstall (Gmail)" writes:
>> We could do the same by decoding TXXXs in emms-info-native. It could be
>> a defcustom in case some users prefer strictly "standard" tags.
> That is probably the way to go though my reading of the spec is that TSO2
> is not strictly standard either!
That's
>
> We could do the same by decoding TXXXs in emms-info-native. It could be
> a defcustom in case some users prefer strictly "standard" tags.
That is probably the way to go though my reading of the spec is that TSO2
is not strictly standard either!
---Fran
On Wed, 24 Feb 2021 at 15:50,
"Fran Burstall (Gmail)" writes:
>> same info. Can you please send a sample of some offending file so I can
>> investigate?
> Here!
Thanks.
The file has a TSO2 frame with the "wrong" value, as expected, but it
also has a user-defined text frame TXXX with ALBUMARTISTSORT key and
"Various
Here!
---Fran
On Tue, 23 Feb 2021 at 23:15, Petteri Hintsanen wrote:
> "Fran Burstall (Gmail)" writes:
>
> >> I think taglib is going wrong here.
> >
> > Maybe so, but in all the cases in my tests, it gives the "right" answer.
> > In the example I gave , it was part of a compilation with
"Fran Burstall (Gmail)" writes:
>> I think taglib is going wrong here.
>
> Maybe so, but in all the cases in my tests, it gives the "right" answer.
> In the example I gave , it was part of a compilation with albumartist
> "Various Artists" and I would expect albumartistsort to at least
>
> "Album artist sort" is taken from "TSO2" frame, which is not standard,
> but not necessarily controversial. At least those two references
> mentioned in code (Foobar2000 and Picard) agree on it, as does
> https://id3.org/Developer%20Information
>
> I think taglib is going wrong here.
>
Maybe
"Fran Burstall (Gmail)" writes:
> I get a lot of mismatches emms-info-native vs emms-info-taglib around two
> tags:
[...]
> It is interesting that exiftool gives the same answer as emms-info-native
> here so maybe this is a controversial tag?
"Album artist sort" is taken from "TSO2" frame,
Hi,
I get a lot of mismatches emms-info-native vs emms-info-taglib around two
tags:
1. albumartistsort:
emms-print-metadata gives
info-album=The Black Box of Jazz
info-albumartist=Various Artists
info-albumartistsort=Various Artists
info-artist=Phil Woods
info-artistsort=Woods, Phil
Petteri Hintsanen writes:
> Hello all,
>
> emms-info-native seems to work well enough so I merged it into the
> master branch. Thanks to everyone who helped in testing and debugging.
> Of course, if you still run into bugs, please report them.
>
> I'll update the manual soon-ish.
Thank you for
10 matches
Mail list logo
