RE: Quantum accident survivor

2003-11-10 Thread David Barrett-Lennard
I'm trying to define identity... Let's write x~y if SAS's x and y (possibly in different universes) have the same identity. I propose that this relation must be reflexive, symmetric and transitive. This neatly partitions all SAS's into equivalence classes, and we have no ambiguity working out

Re: Quantum accident survivor

2003-11-10 Thread Eric Cavalcanti
Hi, I disagreed with some points in your argumentation... - Original Message - From: David Barrett-Lennard [EMAIL PROTECTED] I'm trying to define identity... Let's write x~y if SAS's x and y (possibly in different universes) have the same identity. You did not yet 'define'

Re: Quantum accident survivor

2003-11-10 Thread Dag-Ove Reistad
Hi, I just have one question to clarify your position. - Original Message - From: Eric Cavalcanti [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, November 05, 2003 6:06 AM Subject: Re: Quantum accident survivor But suppose you just stepped outside the Paris duplicator.

Re: Quantum accident survivor

2003-11-10 Thread Saibal Mitra
There are some problems with this as Eric has pointed out. The best way to define identity, i.m.o., would be to say that a program is a SAS having an identity. If that SAS experience the outcome of an experiment, it's program will be changed by the mere fact it has acquired the memory of the

Re: Quantum accident survivor

2003-11-10 Thread Dag-Ove Reistad
Hi, I believe one main issue here is the state of one's surviving consciousness. There is no reason to believe that having consciousness is an on/off thing. So if you do accept quantum immortality thinking, in a typical death-scenario (a severe heart attack, say) we could imagine a survivalrate

Re: Quantum accident survivor

2003-11-10 Thread Hal Finney
Eric Cavalcanti, [EMAIL PROTECTED], writes: In the case of non-destructive-copy experiment, the copy is made in a distinct place/time from the original. They could as well be done 100,000 years in the future and in the Andromeda galaxy, and you should as well expect to have the subjective