Re: [Fis] POSTS ON TERRY' S BOOK - PRESENTED BY DEACON

2012-05-04 Thread Bruno Marchal
On 04 May 2012, at 11:35, Pedro C. Marijuan wrote: Dear Gordana, Hector and colleagues, I keep thinking that the theme of "absences" is really fundamental for advancing the foundations of information science, but I am disappointed by the way Terry has oriented the book. Both style and c

Re: [Fis] POSTS ON TERRY' S BOOK - PRESENTED BY DEACON

2012-05-04 Thread Krassimir Markov
Dear Gordana, Pedro ans FIS colleagues, Now I am too busy with the summer conferences and have no time to explain in deep what I think about Terry’s book. Shortly I can say that many already clear phenomena in the book are presented as “just invented or to be invented”. At the first place the

Re: [Fis] POSTS ON TERRY' S BOOK - PRESENTED BY DEACON

2012-05-04 Thread Loet Leydesdorff
Dear colleagues, Differently from “The Symbolic Species,” “Incomplete Nature” is “too naturalistic” for my taste. It seems to me that the incompleteness and absences are consequential to selection mechanisms operating. Selections can operate recursively and lead to hyper-selection, trajectory

Re: [Fis] POSTS ON TERRY' S BOOK - PRESENTED BY DEACON

2012-05-04 Thread Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic
Dear Pedro, I am sure that Terry Deacon would agree with you - the book is incomplete, and it leaves host of open questions. But that is what makes it attractive. It is a book that moves and provokes thoughts. So the idea to organize a conference about Incomplete Nature is a very good idea. Al

Re: [Fis] POSTS ON TERRY' S BOOK - PRESENTED BY DEACON

2012-05-04 Thread Pedro C. Marijuan
Dear Gordana, Hector and colleagues, I keep thinking that the theme of "absences" is really fundamental for advancing the foundations of information science, but I am disappointed by the way Terry has oriented the book. Both style and contents are inadequate for my taste. He continues to do w