Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-22 Thread Martin Spott
Curtis L. Olson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I do look out for drivers _before_ I buy a card for my or my customers' PeeCee (currently I don't even own a PC ;-) Is it sgi machines that you run on? It became sort of a hobby to collect used Unix workstations. I have an Octane with MXI graphics

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-22 Thread Martin Spott
Curtis L. Olson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Martin Spott writes: Not many, but on the other hand you won't have much trouble with the BIOS when you think about a standalone FlightGear CD. Dealing with a bunch of different kernel modules for autodetecting different vendors' cards might prove to

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-22 Thread Curtis L. Olson
Hi Martin, Martin Spott writes: Especially the mess with NVidia's drivers is the manufacturer's fault. ATI at least _tries_ to conform with the standards proposed by the DRI. With ATI you can copy the DRI driver module and the kernel module (after tweaking the build script) to the appropriate

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-22 Thread Curtis L. Olson
Martin writes: It became sort of a hobby to collect used Unix workstations. I have an Octane with MXI graphics and TRAM as workplace at home, but this machine (only 195 MHz) turned out not being able to keep up with recent development. Its CPU is simply too slow and can't cope with all the

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-22 Thread Andy Ross
Martin Spott wrote: a) Unload the kernel's GART module during the autodetection and load NVidia's special kernel module, b) replace the OpenGL libraries, c) run a special X Server. Martin, just stop this flaming; b is true. a and c are not, and have never been. NVidia's drivers install

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-22 Thread Martin Spott
Curtis L. Olson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: a) Unload the kernel's GART module during the autodetection and load NVidia's special kernel module, Nvidia's kernel module does have an AGP driver, but it is smart enough to not activate this portion of the driver if the linux GART module is

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-22 Thread Jon Stockill
On Mon, 22 Dec 2003, Martin Spott wrote: a) Unload the kernel's GART module during the autodetection and load NVidia's special kernel module, Nope - it'll use kernel GART, or its own internal one. b) replace the OpenGL libraries, The installer does this automatically c) run a special X

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Martin Spott
Melchior FRANZ [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: [...] But I don't feel like making a fgfs CD. The problems with licenses of different proprietary graphic cards aren't such a great motivation. I tend to include OpenSource drivers only, no proprietary stuff. There are enough cards with OpenSource

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Jon Stockill
On Sun, 21 Dec 2003, Melchior FRANZ wrote: * Martin Spott -- Sunday 21 December 2003 00:07: I tend to include OpenSource drivers only, no proprietary stuff. I understand, but then the whole effort is pretty useless. There are too many nVidia card users, and no open source 3D drivers for

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Martin Spott
Melchior FRANZ [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: * Martin Spott -- Sunday 21 December 2003 00:07: I tend to include OpenSource drivers only, no proprietary stuff. I understand, but then the whole effort is pretty useless. There are too many nVidia card users, and no open source 3D drivers for them.

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Erik Hofman
Martin Spott wrote: As you already said: [...] The problems with licenses of different proprietary graphic cards aren't such a great motivation. I second that. Why shouldn't people use cards with OpenSource drivers for a presentation of an OpenSource flight simulator ? FlightGear developers are

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Curtis L. Olson
Martin Spott writes: Melchior FRANZ [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: * Martin Spott -- Sunday 21 December 2003 00:07: I tend to include OpenSource drivers only, no proprietary stuff. I understand, but then the whole effort is pretty useless. There are too many nVidia card users, and no open

RE: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Norman Vine
Curtis L. Olson writes: But personally, I don't mind if FlightGear runs on top of proprietary operating systems or drivers such as Mac OS, sgi, windows, solaris, or a binary nvidia driver on linux. There needs to be a balance between idealism and pragmatism. Taking the paragmatic route a

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Martin Spott
Jon Stockill [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: And the open source drivers don't support some of the newer ATI cards. Sorry, why do you buy cards that are not supported by OpenSource drivers ? You are developing OpenSource software, why don't you take care of that. I can't accept this as a valid

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Curtis L. Olson
Martin Spott writes: Jon Stockill [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: And the open source drivers don't support some of the newer ATI cards. Sorry, why do you buy cards that are not supported by OpenSource drivers ? You are developing OpenSource software, why don't you take care of that. I can't

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Martin Spott
Norman Vine [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Taking the paragmatic route a little further -- I wonder how many machines running FGFS are running with an Open Source BIOS ? Not many, but on the other hand you won't have much trouble with the BIOS when you think about a standalone FlightGear CD.

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Curtis L. Olson
Martin Spott writes: Not many, but on the other hand you won't have much trouble with the BIOS when you think about a standalone FlightGear CD. Dealing with a bunch of different kernel modules for autodetecting different vendors' cards might prove to end in a huge mess. This _is_ very

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Alex Perry
From: Martin Spott [EMAIL PROTECTED] Jon Stockill [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: And the open source drivers don't support some of the newer ATI cards. Sorry, why do you buy cards that are not supported by OpenSource drivers ? You are developing OpenSource software, why don't you take care of

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Re: LiveCD for FGFS - suggestion

2003-12-21 Thread Curtis L. Olson
Alex Perry writes: From: Martin Spott [EMAIL PROTECTED] Jon Stockill [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: And the open source drivers don't support some of the newer ATI cards. Sorry, why do you buy cards that are not supported by OpenSource drivers ? You are developing OpenSource software, why