Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Alan Kay
Hi Thiago To me, there is not nearly enough context to publish this outside this list. I like arguments and complaints that are well supported. I don't like the all too general practice on the web of mere opinions about any and all things. One of the most interesting aspects to me about the

Re: [fonc] HotDraw's Tool State Machine Editor

2011-07-25 Thread Alan Kay
Hi Benoît I don't know of an another attempt to build a whole system with wide properties in DSLs. But it wouldn't surprise me if there were some others around. It requires more design effort, and the tools to make languages need to be effective and as easy as possible, but the payoffs are

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Igor Stasenko
On 25 July 2011 09:47, Alan Kay alan.n...@yahoo.com wrote: Hi Thiago To me, there is not nearly enough context to publish this outside this list. I like arguments and complaints that are well supported. I don't like the all too general practice on the web of mere opinions about any and all

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Julian Leviston
On 26/07/2011, at 12:03 AM, Igor Stasenko wrote: In contrast, as you mentioned, TCP/IP protocol which is backbone of today's internet having much better design. But i think this is a general problem of software evolution. No matter how hard you try, you cannot foresee all kinds of

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Dethe Elza
On 2011-07-25, at 12:47 AM, Alan Kay wrote: For example, some of our next version of Etoys for children could be done in JS, but not all -- e.g. the Kedama massively parallel programmable particle system made by Yoshiki cannot be implemented to run fast enough in JS. It needs something

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Igor Stasenko
On 25 July 2011 16:16, Julian Leviston jul...@leviston.net wrote: On 26/07/2011, at 12:03 AM, Igor Stasenko wrote: Interestingly that many today's trendy and popular things (which we know today as web) were invented as a temporary solution without any systematic approach. I think that i

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Igor Stasenko
On 25 July 2011 17:40, Yoshiki Ohshima yosh...@vpri.org wrote:  Well said, Igor! At Mon, 25 Jul 2011 16:03:57 +0200, Igor Stasenko wrote: It is really a pity, that we have a systems which has no trust from users side.  Following the logic, maybe making provably secure system is not

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Wesley Smith
Why all those emerging technologies is just reproducing the same which were available for desktop apps for years? Doesn't it rings a bell that it is something fundamentally wrong with this technology? Which technology? The technical software one or the human organization social one?

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Igor Stasenko
On 25 July 2011 18:29, Wesley Smith wesley.h...@gmail.com wrote: Why all those emerging technologies is just reproducing the same which were available for desktop apps for years? Doesn't it rings a bell that it is something fundamentally wrong with this technology? Which technology?  The

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Jakob Praher
Dear Alan, Dear List, the following very recent announcement might be of interest to this discussion: http://groups.google.com/group/mozilla.dev.platform/browse_thread/thread/7668a9d46a43e482 To quote Andreas et al.: Mozilla believes that the web can displace proprietary,

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Jakob Praher
Dear Alan, Dear List, the following very recent announcement might be of interest to this discussion: http://groups.google.com/group/mozilla.dev.platform/browse_thread/thread/7668a9d46a43e482 To quote Andreas et al.: Mozilla believes that the web can displace proprietary,

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Dethe Elza
On 2011-07-25, at 9:25 AM, Igor Stasenko wrote: But don't you see a problem: it evolving from simple 'kiddie' scripting language into a full fledged system. First off, JS was done in a hurry, but by Brendan Eich who was hired by Netscape because he had implemented languages before and knew

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Marcel Weiher
Hi Alan, thanks for elaborating. I guess I had seen some of those criticisms before but not connected them with actual design flaws. While there is certainly room for criticism, it seems hard to dispute that the WWW is a remarkably successful artifact, a vast and unprecedented global

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Igor Stasenko
On 25 July 2011 19:01, Dethe Elza de...@livingcode.org wrote: On 2011-07-25, at 9:25 AM, Igor Stasenko wrote: But don't you see a problem: it evolving from simple 'kiddie' scripting language into a full fledged system. First off, JS was done in a hurry, but by Brendan Eich who was hired by

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Benoît Fleury
So, i think it is more a lack of vision, than technical/security issues. There might not have been a technical vision in the www but there is I think a political statement which is that the information must be open. Papers like The Rule of Least Power [1] make it very clear. This is, in my

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread David Barbour
On Sun, Jul 24, 2011 at 10:24 AM, Alan Kay alan.n...@yahoo.com wrote: The main idea here is that a windowing 2.5 D UI can compose views from many sources into a page. The sources can be opaque because they can even do their own rendering if needed. Since the sources can run in protected

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Bert Freudenberg
On 25.07.2011, at 19:13, Jakob Praher wrote: Dear Alan, Dear List, the following very recent announcement might be of interest to this discussion: http://groups.google.com/group/mozilla.dev.platform/browse_thread/thread/7668a9d46a43e482 To quote Andreas et al.: Mozilla believes

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Thiago Silva
On Monday 25 July 2011 11:03:57 Igor Stasenko wrote: But i think this is a general problem of software evolution. No matter how hard you try, you cannot foresee all kinds of interactions, features and use cases for your system, when you designing it from the beginning. Because 20 years ago,

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Jakob Praher
On 07/25/2011 09:35 PM, Bert Freudenberg wrote: I did ask in that thread about exposing the CPU, a la NativeClient. (It's a usenet group so you can post without subscribing, nice) Short answer is that they don't see a need for it. I somehow have mixed feelings about NaCL. I think that safe

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread BGB
On 7/25/2011 12:59 PM, David Barbour wrote: On Mon, Jul 25, 2011 at 9:25 AM, Igor Stasenko siguc...@gmail.com mailto:siguc...@gmail.com wrote: how different our systems would be, if guys who started it 20 years back would think a bit about future? The guys who spend their time

Growth, Popularity and Languages - was Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Julian Leviston
On 26/07/2011, at 1:33 AM, Igor Stasenko wrote: On 25 July 2011 16:16, Julian Leviston jul...@leviston.net wrote: On 26/07/2011, at 12:03 AM, Igor Stasenko wrote: Interestingly that many today's trendy and popular things (which we know today as web) were invented as a temporary solution

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread David Barbour
On Mon, Jul 25, 2011 at 3:20 PM, BGB cr88...@gmail.com wrote: too bad there is no standardized bytecode or anything though, but then I guess it would at this point be more like browser-integrated Flash or something, as well as be potentially more subject to awkward versioning issues, or the

Intention Implementation - was Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Julian Leviston
On 26/07/2011, at 1:43 AM, Igor Stasenko wrote: (quotes are broken) On 25 July 2011 16:26, Julian Leviston jul...@leviston.net wrote: On 26/07/2011, at 12:03 AM, Igor Stasenko wrote: In contrast, as you mentioned, TCP/IP protocol which is backbone of today's internet having much

Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Alan Kay
I agree there are better ways to do things than NaCl, but Yoshiki was able to get Squeak running in it, and that was a milestone benchmark that points the way for better systems than Squeak. Cheers, Alan From: Jakob Praher j...@hapra.at To: fonc@vpri.org

Re: Growth, Popularity and Languages - was Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Julian Leviston
On 26/07/2011, at 12:20 PM, Igor Stasenko wrote: You lost me here. My attitude to Ruby is same as to Perl: lets take bit from here, bit from there, mix well everything and voila! , we having new programming language. It may be good for cooking recipe, but definitely not very good for

Re: Growth, Popularity and Languages - was Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Julian Leviston
On 26/07/2011, at 12:20 PM, Igor Stasenko wrote: But for programming its a bit different: you giving to people a tool which they will use to craft their own products. And depending on how good/bad this tool are, the end product's quality will vary. And also, it would be too good to be

Re: Growth, Popularity and Languages - was Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Julian Leviston
On 26/07/2011, at 12:20 PM, Igor Stasenko wrote: Say, for example, like making a telephone that is vastly more easy to use than all other telephones on the planet. Now, for tech geeks, it's not really *that* much easier to use... For example, when the iPhone came out, I got one, and the

Re: Intention Implementation - was Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread David Barbour
On Mon, Jul 25, 2011 at 4:40 PM, Julian Leviston jul...@leviston.netwrote: I guess my question is... what's stopping an alternative, replacement, backwardly-compatible protocol from taking over where http and https leave off? HTTP and HTTPS are not very good protocols if your goals relate to

Re: Growth, Popularity and Languages - was Re: [fonc] Alan Kay talk at HPI in Potsdam

2011-07-25 Thread Alan Kay
The argument about mass popularity is good if all you want to do is triumph in the consumer products business (c.f. many previous raps I've done about the anthropological human universals and how and why technological amplifiers for them have been and will be very popular). This is because