Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-14 Thread Vincent Hennebert
Thanks for all your feedbacks. Hearing no objections, I’ll then commit the change in the next days. Vincent Vincent Hennebert wrote: > Hi, > > The title may be a little cryptic for those who aren’t familiar with the > table layout code :-\ But basically it corresponds to the following: > > Wh

Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-09 Thread Max Berger
Vincent, > > both of them I'd prefer to see split onto two pages. So imo a high > > penalty is better > That will still be possible with the infinite penalty (assuming your > "1.5 pages" contain enough break possibilities in between). The rule > here is only to make sure that every column contribu

Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-09 Thread Jeremias Maerki
On 09.01.2008 16:19:33 Max Berger wrote: > Vincent, > > please consider the case where a table cell is long, or even longer than > a page. In this case it should break it anyways. Also, consider these > cases: > > ++ > | 0.25 pages | > ++ > | 1.5 pages | > ++

Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-09 Thread Jeremias Maerki
+1 I guess it makes sense. On 09.01.2008 15:27:29 Vincent Hennebert wrote: > Hi, > > The title may be a little cryptic for those who aren’t familiar with the > table layout code :-\ But basically it corresponds to the following: > > When a row starts at the bottom of a page, there may not be en

Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-09 Thread Andreas L Delmelle
On Jan 9, 2008, at 18:59, Jay Bryant wrote: Hi Jay, My opinion doesn't count, but I'm for it. Just wondering: What do you mean by "doesn't count"? You are a committer, so your opinion most definitely counts here... :-) Cheers Andreas

Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-09 Thread Andreas L Delmelle
On Jan 9, 2008, at 15:27, Vincent Hennebert wrote: Hi Vincent, Currently, a 900 penalty is assigned to such a break possibility, to avoid as much as possible this situation from occurring. However, it doesn’t completely prevent it, as we have seen recently on fop-users. My proposal is to for

Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-09 Thread Jay Bryant
My opinion doesn't count, but I'm for it. For me and my customers, a cell that begins on one page and ends on another is never desirable. Jay Bryant Bryant Communication Services http://www.bryantcs.com/

Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-09 Thread Vincent Hennebert
Hi Max, Max Berger wrote: > Vincent, > > please consider the case where a table cell is long, or even longer than > a page. In this case it should break it anyways. Also, consider these > cases: Well this is a different issue. The fact that at least the beginning of each cell should be present

Re: Disable 900 penalty when not all cells have contributed in tables?

2008-01-09 Thread Max Berger
Vincent, please consider the case where a table cell is long, or even longer than a page. In this case it should break it anyways. Also, consider these cases: ++ | 0.25 pages | ++ | 1.5 pages | ++ | 0.25 pages | ++ +---+ | 0.5 pages | +