Re: [Freetel-codec2] Activity Day feedback

2024-05-07 Thread Mooneer Salem
Hi Bruce, I'm not fully sure re: Field Day but based on the rules and how FreeDV has traditionally been classified in the past, I'd suspect it's treated the same as regular SSB voice for scoring purposes. As for net control, given that band conditions on any particular day can make it so that a c

Re: [Freetel-codec2] Activity Day feedback

2024-05-07 Thread Bruce MacKinnon
Hi Mooneer: All of the nets that I participate in regularly are weekly, so that does seem like a good cadence. Having someone to talk to helps a lot when trying to generate knowledge/interest. You probably need that to build community and momentum around any new mode. But I also know that p

Re: [Freetel-codec2] Activity Day feedback

2024-05-07 Thread Mooneer Salem
Hi Bruce, Speaking of W1AW, do you think that something even more frequent than the existing Activity Day event would be useful? (For example, a weekly net or other meetup (e.g. on Zoom) that lasts an hour or two.) I know that the HF D-Star people do that every weekend and cycle through each of th

Re: [Freetel-codec2] Activity Day feedback

2024-05-07 Thread Bruce MacKinnon
Hi Mooneer: I find the activity days to be very helpful. I am working on my own implementation of the CODECs and modems. This work is made much easier (and more satisfying) when you have real activity impacted by real noise to test receivers/decoders. Having a time/place where there is a high