Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2013-01-11 Thread Jeff McKenna
> > There are different schools on the topic. I know Frank is not too keen on > mentionning versionning, although personnaly, I try to mention version > differences in the format page itself (http://www.gdal.org/ogr/drv_osm.html > mentions GDAL/OGR >= 1.10.0). But at the end, in drivers with a lo

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2013-01-11 Thread Even Rouault
Selon Jeff McKenna : > On 13-01-08 9:26 PM, Even Rouault wrote: > > Ah ok, so I must mention that the online documentation is always up-to-date > > with the latest trunk version (it is refreshed each night). So the fact > that > > something is documented is not a sign of stability by itself. It ca

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2013-01-11 Thread Jeff McKenna
On 13-01-08 9:26 PM, Even Rouault wrote: > Ah ok, so I must mention that the online documentation is always up-to-date > with the latest trunk version (it is refreshed each night). So the fact that > something is documented is not a sign of stability by itself. It can be a new > development comm

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2013-01-08 Thread Even Rouault
Le mercredi 09 janvier 2013 02:11:21, Stefan Keller a écrit : > Even, > > Thanks for the fast response! > > 2013/1/9 Even Rouault : > > (Just curious what in the doc makes you call it "stable", and what you > > consider as "stable") > > Just the fact that it's there and especially that is't also

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2013-01-08 Thread Stefan Keller
Even, Thanks for the fast response! 2013/1/9 Even Rouault : > (Just curious what in the doc makes you call it "stable", and what you > consider as "stable") Just the fact that it's there and especially that is't also in the overview table alongside with all other (stable) drivers http://www.gdal

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2013-01-08 Thread Even Rouault
Le mercredi 09 janvier 2013 01:02:22, Stefan Keller a écrit : > Hi Even > > Documentation of OpenStreetMap driver suggest its stable (Just curious what in the doc makes you call it "stable", and what you consider as "stable") > - but when I > recently installed the newest OGR version on a linux

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2013-01-08 Thread Stefan Keller
Hi Even Documentation of OpenStreetMap driver suggest its stable - but when I recently installed the newest OGR version on a linux it was'nt there. Is it not yet stable enough? If not, what do you recommend? Should I include the tagged version (currently 1.9.2) and add the trunk version (subdirect

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-10-24 Thread Even Rouault
Le mercredi 24 octobre 2012 09:57:58, Frank Broniewski a écrit : > Hi, > > I had this up my schedule for this week, but I see I need GDAL >= 2.0. > Where might I get this? From svn (https://svn.osgeo.org/gdal/trunk/gdal)? Yes, svn trunk = GDAL 2.0dev.

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-10-24 Thread Frank Broniewski
Hi, I had this up my schedule for this week, but I see I need GDAL >= 2.0. Where might I get this? From svn (https://svn.osgeo.org/gdal/trunk/gdal)? Thanks, Frank Am 2012-10-17 11:54, schrieb Even Rouault: Selon Frank Broniewski : Hi Even, I need to reinstall my OSM database due to the l

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-10-17 Thread Even Rouault
Selon Frank Broniewski : > Hi Even, > > I need to reinstall my OSM database due to the license change to ODBL. > Usually I use osm2pgsql for that, but I am willing to sacrifice a little > downtime of my DB in order to test the GDAL implementation. Before > storming ahead I wanted to know how far y

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-10-17 Thread Frank Broniewski
Hi Even, I need to reinstall my OSM database due to the license change to ODBL. Usually I use osm2pgsql for that, but I am willing to sacrifice a little downtime of my DB in order to test the GDAL implementation. Before storming ahead I wanted to know how far you are with the driver implement

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-23 Thread Rahkonen Jukka
Even Rouault wrote: 23. heinäkuuta 2012 13:27 > Le lundi 23 juillet 2012 00:09:05, Jukka Rahkonen a écrit : >> Even Rouault mines-paris.org> writes: >> > > > However, select with SQL feels sub-optimal. >> > > >> > > Yes, when you use ogr2ogr with explicit layer names, there are >> > > optimizatio

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-23 Thread Even Rouault
Le lundi 23 juillet 2012 00:09:05, Jukka Rahkonen a écrit : > Even Rouault mines-paris.org> writes: > > > > However, select with SQL feels sub-optimal. > > > > > > Yes, when you use ogr2ogr with explicit layer names, there are > > > optimizations. For example, when you only specify the layer 'poi

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-22 Thread Jukka Rahkonen
Even Rouault mines-paris.org> writes: > > > > > > However, select with SQL feels sub-optimal. > > > > Yes, when you use ogr2ogr with explicit layer names, there are > > optimizations. For example, when you only specify the layer 'points', the > > OSM driver will not even try to index the node

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-20 Thread Even Rouault
> > However, select with SQL feels sub-optimal. > > Yes, when you use ogr2ogr with explicit layer names, there are > optimizations. For example, when you only specify the layer 'points', the > OSM driver will not even try to index the nodes into the temporary > database because it is not needed.

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-20 Thread Jukka Rahkonen
Rahkonen Jukka mmmtike.fi> writes: > > > Even Rouault wrote: > > > Do you have comparisons of the performance with osm2pgsql on the same PC and > > with the same data ? I'd be curious if that slow down effect is found with every > > tool, or if it is something specific to the way sqlite is

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-19 Thread Rahkonen Jukka
Even Rouault wrote: >> Windows 7, 64-bit, SATA disk and 2x3 GHz is converting Finland.osm.pbf in >> about >> 8 minutes for me. But execution time does not increase at all linearly. >> Germany.osm.pbf is about 10 times larger in filesize but ogr2ogr had to work >> about 8 hours with it, thus rough

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-19 Thread Rahkonen Jukka
Even Rouault wrote: >> Amenity is included in my osmconf.ini and it can be used inside -sql. >> However, your example gives me this >> >> ERROR 1: 'amenity' not recognised as an available field. >> FAILURE: SetAttributeFilter(amenity='toilets') failed. > Hum, I think I know what's wrong. I see th

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-19 Thread Even Rouault
> > Windows 7, 64-bit, SATA disk and 2x3 GHz is converting Finland.osm.pbf in > about > 8 minutes for me. But execution time does not increase at all linearly. > Germany.osm.pbf is about 10 times larger in filesize but ogr2ogr had to work > about 8 hours with it, thus roughly 70 times longer. Obvio

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-19 Thread Even Rouault
> Amenity is included in my osmconf.ini and it can be used inside -sql. > However, your example gives me this > > ERROR 1: 'amenity' not recognised as an available field. > FAILURE: SetAttributeFilter(amenity='toilets') failed. Hum, I think I know what's wrong. I see that, even if a subset of lay

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-19 Thread Jukka Rahkonen
Even Rouault mines-paris.org> writes: > > Selon Jukka Rahkonen mmmtike.fi>: ... > > > It is > > much faster to convert all the points than select only a part of those. The > > error message suggest that ogr2ogr is inspecting the input file more closely > > than necessary for this use case:

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-18 Thread Jukka Rahkonen
Even Rouault mines-paris.org> writes: > > Hi, > > Following the recent brainstorming with Jukka, I've pushed into trunk a > driver > to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files . . > > Testing with larger areas, like whole France or Europe, shows sluggish > performance when ways are

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-18 Thread Jeff McKenna
> Even Rouault mines-paris.org> writes: >> Following the recent brainstorming with Jukka, I've pushed into trunk a >> driver >> to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files . > Fascinating. Actually I think once someone imports the points, lines, polys into a DB, then (cool!) someone could then

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-18 Thread Even Rouault
Selon Jukka Rahkonen : > Even Rouault mines-paris.org> writes: > > > > > Hi, > > > > Following the recent brainstorming with Jukka, I've pushed into trunk a > driver > > to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files . > > Driver seems to do what it promises. It is super fast in converting POI data > be

Re: [gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-18 Thread Jukka Rahkonen
Even Rouault mines-paris.org> writes: > > Hi, > > Following the recent brainstorming with Jukka, I've pushed into trunk a > driver > to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files . Driver seems to do what it promises. It is super fast in converting POI data because it is possible to skip the slowe

[gdal-dev] New OGR driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files

2012-07-10 Thread Even Rouault
Hi, Following the recent brainstorming with Jukka, I've pushed into trunk a driver to read OpenStreetMap .osm / .pbf files . No particularly exotic dependencies : SQLite (and Expat for OSM XML files) See http://www.gdal.org/ogr/drv_osm.html for the details (will be available in a few hours).