Re: Queuing solution for merging patches

2022-07-06 Thread Jarek Potiuk
Sorry wrong link: [2] - the discussion was moved to LEGAL and I asked it in the legal one: [2] https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/LEGAL-599 On Wed, Jul 6, 2022 at 7:19 PM Jarek Potiuk wrote: > I added my comment to [1]. I think there are good reasons why the decision > about rejecting the

Re: Queuing solution for merging patches

2022-07-06 Thread Jarek Potiuk
I added my comment to [1]. I think there are good reasons why the decision about rejecting the "Merge Queue'' feature from GitHub should be revised (and I asked for it). IMHO it was partially based on misunderstanding how "merge queue" works and partially because we did not have the precedent.

Re: Queuing solution for merging patches

2022-06-30 Thread tison
Hi Sheng, I think you're right that I can remove 'required_status_checks.strict' in .asf.yaml to disable up-to-date requirements and then find other way to resolve logic conflict issue. At least the committers should be aware of which case should merge main branch. Hi Martinjn, Good to know

Re: Queuing solution for merging patches

2022-06-29 Thread Martijn Visser
Hi Tison, I asked a couple of months ago [1] if Infra could enable Github's Merge Queue Functionality [2]. That was rejected unfortunately. I'm also curious if others think of a solution that would be compliant with the ASF rules. Best regards, Martijn [1]

Re: Queuing solution for merging patches

2022-06-29 Thread Sheng Wu
Hi I think the key is you set up to date for main branch, which makes CI has to rerun. tison 于2022年6月29日 周三19:39写道: > Hi Sheng, > > Yes. I do _not_ ask INFRA to support it, but to see if there is existing > practice. > > Best, > tison. > > > Sheng Wu 于2022年6月29日周三 19:33写道: > > > Hi Tison > > >

Re: Queuing solution for merging patches

2022-06-29 Thread tison
Hi Sheng, Yes. I do _not_ ask INFRA to support it, but to see if there is existing practice. Best, tison. Sheng Wu 于2022年6月29日周三 19:33写道: > Hi Tison > > I think there is no hard requirement from infra or Apache perspective. The > PMC could decide what they like, and ask Infra team to set

Re: Queuing solution for merging patches

2022-06-29 Thread Sheng Wu
Hi Tison I think there is no hard requirement from infra or Apache perspective. The PMC could decide what they like, and ask Infra team to set them up. tison 于2022年6月29日 周三19:25写道: > Hi, > > There're several solutions around GitHub ecosystem to queuing patches > passed reviews and waiting for