Re: [VOTE] Remove POI svn restrictions.

2006-12-16 Thread Rainer Klute
Martin van den Bemt schrieb: [+1] Open up POI svn commit access. [-1] Don't open POI svn commit access, because... [0] I don't care. Best regards Rainer Klute Rainer Klute IT-Consulting GmbH Dipl.-Inform. Rainer Klute E-Mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [VOTE] Remove POI svn restrictions.

2006-12-16 Thread Niall Pemberton
Is it necessary to resort to sarcasm and personalise this? Henri Yandell's a good guy in my book and this only reflects badly on you. Niall On 12/16/06, Andrew C. Oliver [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hey I have an idea! If it doesn't pass this time we can call another vote right before the next

Re: [VOTE] Remove POI svn restrictions.

2006-12-16 Thread Henri Yandell
On 12/15/06, Andrew C. Oliver [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hey I have an idea! If it doesn't pass this time we can call another vote right before the next holiday and hope that none of the POI PMC members are around... Then 3 months later do it again. Reasoning being that Martin has done the

Re: [VOTE] Remove POI svn restrictions.

2006-12-16 Thread Roland Weber
Henri Yandell wrote: Reasoning being that Martin has done the same thing I did - asked legal vp and secretary if they know anything about the need for POI to be legally special and they don't. Then either the ASF legal team wasn't involved in the discussion Andy mentioned, or the current

Re: [VOTE] Remove POI svn restrictions.

2006-12-16 Thread Martin van den Bemt
-1 from me. Harmony doesn't let anyone commit on their project unless they they sign a statement saying they haven't looked at Sun's source code[1]. AFAIK this is a similar issue and the POI policy [2] is designed to protect POI, which as a user of POI is a good thing IMO. Even if this

Re: [VOTE] Remove POI svn restrictions.

2006-12-16 Thread Martin van den Bemt
Every legal document has to be on file and known to the secretary and he has no knowledge of such documents, so from an ASF point of view, this is non existing. If there is something on file I would love to hear where. Mvgr, Martin Roland Weber wrote: Henri Yandell wrote: Reasoning being

Re: [VOTE] Remove POI svn restrictions.

2006-12-16 Thread Martin van den Bemt
Will Glass-Husain wrote: Andy-- No one was going to railroad this through without input from POI. See my previous email where I insisted that we have POI participation. (and I would have -1'd this automatically if it had been lacking). The discussion was civil up until recently. I am

Re: [VOTE] Remove POI svn restrictions.

2006-12-16 Thread Martin van den Bemt
Andrew C. Oliver wrote: Hey I have an idea! If it doesn't pass this time we can call another vote right before the next holiday and hope that none of the POI PMC members are around... Then 3 months later do it again. This is a different vote. This one is specific about POI. The previous