Re: [IP CLEARANCE] Arrow Flight SQL JDBC Driver

2022-07-16 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, What were the original headers on the files and/or where did the original code come from? The code pointed to has ASF headers which make determining the origin a little difficult. Kind Regards,. Justin - To unsubscribe,

[IP CLEARANCE] Arrow Flight SQL JDBC Driver

2022-07-16 Thread David Li
Hello, Apache Arrow is receiving a donation of a JDBC driver [1], currently in a pull request, to be merged into a branch on the main Arrow repository. This is the formal request to check the clearance. The software grant has been filed, ICLAs have been submitted, and the Arrow PMC vote has

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] Arrow Flight SQL JDBC Driver

2022-07-16 Thread Daniel Widdis
To elaborate and be more specific, the proposal identifies this fork [5] as the "source". [6] is an exhaustive list of the 1491 commits involved, constituting the donated IP. A spot check of commits with "license header" in the description shows ASF headers were used and there does not appear

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] Arrow Flight SQL JDBC Driver

2022-07-16 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Do we have an ICLA on file for "Abner Eduardo Ferreira”? I can see we do for the other people mentioned in the grant. Kind Regards, Justin - To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] Arrow Flight SQL JDBC Driver

2022-07-16 Thread Daniel Widdis
Isn't developing on a fork of the project and submitting a PR considered "developed inside the project"? When I contribute to Apache projects, I fork the project, write code using the project's headers, and submit a PR from my fork. I never claim copyright as my own or use my own header.

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] Arrow Flight SQL JDBC Driver

2022-07-16 Thread Daniel Widdis
Based on this blog post [1] it appears that the entire development was done in a sequence of draft PRs on the Arrow site (and on a fork), with the intention of donating it, and using ASF headers. Proposal: [2] Initial POC work: [3] Experimental version: [4] [1] -

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] Arrow Flight SQL JDBC Driver

2022-07-16 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Which is an issue as the header has "Licensed to the Apache Software Foundation (ASF) under one or more contributor license agreements”. That is not really the case yet. Normally wth a software grant you replace the headers and move the original copyright line to the NOTICE file. I'm

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] Arrow Flight SQL JDBC Driver

2022-07-16 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > Isn't developing on a fork of the project and submitting a PR considered > "developed inside the project”? Sure, but then you usually don’t need a software grant. > I never claim copyright as my own or use my own header. This is exactly what > happened here. Why you may not claim it