Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-14 Thread Samuli Suominen
On 14/02/13 09:26, Michael Weber wrote: non-multilib/x86 installs to /lib, multilib is linked to /lib. So please, stop using dramatizing this and use it as alibi for your otherwise justified plans. There is no guarantee multilib is linked to /lib whatsoever. Where did you get that idea?

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Chí-Thanh Christopher Nguyễn
Christopher Head schrieb: Most external firmware is not needed to boot. If you need it to boot, you will have to stow it in the initramfs. For those of us who prefer monolithic kernels, virtually all firmware is needed to boot. Even if a network interface doesn't need to be operational for

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Chí-Thanh Christopher Nguyễn
Sergei Trofimovich schrieb: The source of confusion was non-working device by default. Maybe 'IUSE=+firmware; RDEPEND=firmware? ( sys-kernel/linux-firmware )' for virtual/linux-sources would help user experience a bit. +1 https://bugs.gentoo.org/457082 Instead of USE defaults, this could be

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Diego Elio Pettenò
On 13/02/2013 14:38, Chí-Thanh Christopher Nguyễn wrote: https://bugs.gentoo.org/457082 Instead of USE defaults, this could be turned on in the desktop profile as wifi, radeon cards etc. are less likely to be present on non-desktop systems. IIRC some server systems need ethernet cards'

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Chí-Thanh Christopher Nguyễn
Diego Elio Pettenò schrieb: On 13/02/2013 14:38, Chí-Thanh Christopher Nguyễn wrote: https://bugs.gentoo.org/457082 Instead of USE defaults, this could be turned on in the desktop profile as wifi, radeon cards etc. are less likely to be present on non-desktop systems. IIRC some server

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Diego Elio Pettenò
On 13/02/2013 15:50, Chí-Thanh Christopher Nguyễn wrote: Indeed. Firmware is also needed for some RAID controllers. I imagine that users of the default profile are more likely to not need hand-holding here and more likely to want a lean system by default. But I have no strong opinion either

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Peter Stuge
Diego Elio Pettenò wrote: People who don't need the firmware can deal with disabling it themselves. I don't like the binary distribution argument of include everything to cover as many possible use cases as possible in one go. I very much like the high resolution of Gentoo packages. I'd hate to

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Diego Elio Pettenò
On 13/02/2013 18:33, Peter Stuge wrote: I don't like the binary distribution argument of include everything to cover as many possible use cases as possible in one go. I very much like the high resolution of Gentoo packages. I'd hate to enter a slippery slope toward lower resolution. Are you

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Peter Stuge
Diego Elio Pettenò wrote: I don't like the binary distribution argument of include everything to cover as many possible use cases as possible in one go. I very much like the high resolution of Gentoo packages. I'd hate to enter a slippery slope toward lower resolution. Are you really

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Chí-Thanh Christopher Nguyễn
Peter Stuge schrieb: Kernel -sources USE is a handy way to install linux-firmware wholesale, but AIUI the standalone firmware packages would be removed too, effectively making the USE flag non-optional, and removing the possibility of having managed firmware packages. (People would have to

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Graham Murray
Peter Stuge pe...@stuge.se writes: Kernel -sources USE is a handy way to install linux-firmware wholesale, but AIUI the standalone firmware packages would be removed too, effectively making the USE flag non-optional, and removing the possibility of having managed firmware packages. (People

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-13 Thread Michael Weber
U folks are aware of the fact that installed sources is rather vaguely coupled with running kernel, right? No, I'm not running archkernel on gentoo, but it would be possible. It's also fine to poke around in linus' sources and cross compile w/o ever running the damn thing or needing firmware from

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-12 Thread Christopher Head
On Sun, 10 Feb 2013 20:43:02 +0100 Dirkjan Ochtman d...@gentoo.org wrote: On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 5:54 PM, Fabio Erculiani lx...@gentoo.org wrote: +1 from me; I've had a few machines break on kernel upgrades because I didn't have the proper firmware installed (I guess older kernel sources

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-12 Thread Christopher Head
On Sun, 10 Feb 2013 14:49:03 -0800 Alec Warner anta...@gentoo.org wrote: Most external firmware is not needed to boot. If you need it to boot, you will have to stow it in the initramfs. For those of us who prefer monolithic kernels, virtually all firmware is needed to boot. Even if a network

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-12 Thread Fabio Erculiani
I am starting to believe that this is yet another good reason for having official ebuilds building binaries off gentoo-sources through genkernel. Pretty much the same I do in Sabayon since 2007. -- Fabio Erculiani

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-12 Thread Pacho Ramos
El mar, 12-02-2013 a las 19:43 +, Fabio Erculiani escribió: I am starting to believe that this is yet another good reason for having official ebuilds building binaries off gentoo-sources through genkernel. Pretty much the same I do in Sabayon since 2007. I think shouldn't have any

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-12 Thread Fabio Erculiani
On Tue, Feb 12, 2013 at 7:47 PM, Pacho Ramos pa...@gentoo.org wrote: El mar, 12-02-2013 a las 19:43 +, Fabio Erculiani escribió: I am starting to believe that this is yet another good reason for having official ebuilds building binaries off gentoo-sources through genkernel. Pretty much the

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Pacho Ramos
El dom, 10-02-2013 a las 17:46 +0300, Sergei Trofimovich escribió: [...] The source of confusion was non-working device by default. Maybe 'IUSE=+firmware; RDEPEND=firmware? ( sys-kernel/linux-firmware )' for virtual/linux-sources would help user experience a bit. Sometimes firmware loader

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Maxim Kammerer
On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 5:05 PM, Pacho Ramos pa...@gentoo.org wrote: I agree as I have also needed to google and search in forums to get proper firmware installed in the past in some machines :/ for fw in $(strings -a -n 10 $(find /lib/modules -name '*.ko') | sed -n 's/^firmware=//p' | sort

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Dirkjan Ochtman
On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 4:05 PM, Pacho Ramos pa...@gentoo.org wrote: I agree as I have also needed to google and search in forums to get proper firmware installed in the past in some machines :/ +1 from me; I've had a few machines break on kernel upgrades because I didn't have the proper

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Maxim Kammerer
On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 6:49 PM, Dirkjan Ochtman d...@gentoo.org wrote: (I guess older kernel sources came with the firmware?) See e.g. https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=42689#c5 -- Maxim Kammerer Liberté Linux: http://dee.su/liberte

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Fabio Erculiani
On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 4:49 PM, Dirkjan Ochtman d...@gentoo.org wrote: On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 4:05 PM, Pacho Ramos pa...@gentoo.org wrote: I agree as I have also needed to google and search in forums to get proper firmware installed in the past in some machines :/ +1 from me; I've had a few

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Dirkjan Ochtman
On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 5:54 PM, Fabio Erculiani lx...@gentoo.org wrote: +1 from me; I've had a few machines break on kernel upgrades because I didn't have the proper firmware installed (I guess older kernel sources came with the firmware?). This is another problem, namely dependency level

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Rick Zero_Chaos Farina
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 02/10/2013 11:54 AM, Fabio Erculiani wrote: On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 4:49 PM, Dirkjan Ochtman d...@gentoo.org wrote: On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 4:05 PM, Pacho Ramos pa...@gentoo.org wrote: I agree as I have also needed to google and search in forums

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Bruno
On Sun, 10 February 2013 Maxim Kammerer m...@dee.su wrote: On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 5:05 PM, Pacho Ramos pa...@gentoo.org wrote: I agree as I have also needed to google and search in forums to get proper firmware installed in the past in some machines :/ for fw in $(strings -a -n 10 $(find

Re: RFC: install linux-firmware with kernel sources (was Re: [gentoo-dev] Lastrite: Firmware cleanup, part #1)

2013-02-10 Thread Alec Warner
On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 1:06 PM, Bruno bonbon...@internet.lu wrote: On Sun, 10 February 2013 Maxim Kammerer m...@dee.su wrote: On Sun, Feb 10, 2013 at 5:05 PM, Pacho Ramos pa...@gentoo.org wrote: I agree as I have also needed to google and search in forums to get proper firmware installed in