Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-13 Thread Timothy
On Tuesday, December 13, 2016 6:17 PM, "Vangelis forthnet" wrote: > GiP 2.96 (used by OP prior to updating to 2.97) > does not pass -stats to FFmpeg 0.8.18, > so - as you point - remuxing works. > Ah. I did not listen all that closely to the first line of both logs.

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-13 Thread Vangelis forthnet
On Tue Dec 13 22:33:13 GMT 2016, Timothy wrote: Actually, it can, if you don't have the -stats option there (snip) It was just the -stats option that was the issue Hi Timothy I think it's apparent in the portion of my post you quoted that I was refering to the combination of GiP 2.97 +

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-13 Thread Timothy
On Tuesday, December 13, 2016 3:49 PM, "Vangelis forthnet" wrote: > The original log on GiP 2.97 with obsolete FFmpeg 0.8.18 is pretty > clear; http://sprunge.us/XYbJ > FFmpeg can't remux (repackage) downloaded FLV files into .M4A ones. > (ffmpeg version

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-13 Thread Charles Johnson
On 13/12/16 09:19, Jim web wrote: Maybe the building omitted some codecs because they don't meet some open/free requirements or similar and the process wasn't told to include them anyway. That's a good thought. But the reality seems (i haven't combed it thoroughly) to be that the Debian build

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-13 Thread Jim web
In article <42FB9FA5AB734668B7B82B794E7EB888@vasonote>, Vangelis forthnet wrote: > Now, this is a second issue, unrelated to GiP itself, in that your > FFmpeg 3.2.2 build (on Debian Jessie) appears unable to transcode a > HE-AACv1 m4a file (produced by GiP) to MP3.

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-12 Thread Vangelis forthnet
On Sun Dec 11 20:41:39 GMT 2016, Charles Johnson wrote: that's done separately in a script and is just ffmpeg -i "${f}" $(basename "${f}").mp3 So, to recap, your original issue (failure to remux FLV audio files into MP4 container, after upgrading to GiP 2.97) was caused by the inability of

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-12 Thread Vangelis forthnet
On Sun Dec 11 20:55:57 GMT 2016, Charles Johnson wrote: ... Have you tried the --ffmpeg-obsolete switch I suggested with your 0.8.18 version, prior to updating to 3.2.2? No i didn't do that ...Pity; had you tried and it worked, it would have been valuable info for a subset of GiP 2.97

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-12 Thread Charles Johnson
On 11/12/16 20:33, Vangelis forthnet wrote: It's during the transcoding from HE-AACv1 => MP3 that your copy of FFmpeg barfs... Perhaps a regression introduced in 3.2.2? I think that must be it. I backed up ffmpeg 3.2.2, symlinked the latest build from here

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Charles Johnson
On 11/12/16 20:33, Vangelis forthnet wrote: ... Have you tried the --ffmpeg-obsolete switch I suggested with your 0.8.18 version, prior to updating to 3.2.2? No i didn't do that, since i thought it a good idea to get the latest ffmpeg anyway ___

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Charles Johnson
On 11/12/16 20:33, Vangelis forthnet wrote: So please, you need to provide the transcoding ffmpeg command used; Actually that's done separately in a script and is just ffmpeg -i "${f}" $(basename "${f}").mp3 ___ get_iplayer mailing list

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Vangelis forthnet
On Sun Dec 11 19:16:18 GMT 2016, Charles Johnson wrote: This one is errorful. It uses the latest version (3.2.2) of ffmpeg ... Have you tried the --ffmpeg-obsolete switch I suggested with your 0.8.18 version, prior to updating to 3.2.2? As Alan advised, please provide full GiP command

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Charles Johnson
On 11/12/16 14:30, Timothy wrote: You are definitely using an outdated FFMpeg - version 0.8.18. I'm not sure why there's an issue, except that on one log the "-stats" switch was given, which your FFMpeg choked on by saying that there was no input file given. On the log without the "-stats"

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Vangelis forthnet
On Sun Dec 11 17:29 GMT 2016, Charles Johnson cehjohn...@googlemail.com wrote: Actually the log files (afaicr) mentioned avconv. I do have libav installed AND ffmpeg. tbh i've got thoroughly confused over the ffmpeg/avconv dichotomy but perhaps i should try to get the latest libav for my

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Vangelis forthnet
On Sun Dec 11 17:21:58 GMT 2016, I wrote: Your very old ffmpeg version has been probably affected by the following GiP commit: https://github.com/get-iplayer/get_iplayer/commit/9183610030e9e85ff8d2711108feb1c9d6333f97 It appears the combination of "-loglevel -stats" is what broke your 0.8.18

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Vangelis forthnet
On Sun Dec 11 09:03:24 GMT 2016, Alan Milewczyk wrote: it's nearly 24 hours since you posted your query and no replies ... Anyone remembers my last month's post? http://lists.infradead.org/pipermail/get_iplayer/2016-November/009922.html > my knowledge of get_iplayer is incomplete :-( ;

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Timothy
You are definitely using an outdated FFMpeg - version 0.8.18. I'm not sure why there's an issue, except that on one log the "-stats" switch was given, which your FFMpeg choked on by saying that there was no input file given. On the log without the "-stats" switch, everything went swimmingly. I

Re: 2.97 failing to produce files

2016-12-11 Thread Alan Milewczyk
Hmm, it's nearly 24 hours since you posted your query and no replies, so I'll bite. I'm sorry, I couldn't make head nor tail of the attachments, but my immediate question is (assuming you used the command line) "what was the exact command issued to get_iplayer? Regards Alan On