Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread David Neary
Hi, If this is an almost-concensus (only myself, Alan Horkan and Raphael seem to like the change), it seems reasonable to revert the redo shortcut to Ctrl-R. Cheers, Dave. Tom Mraz wrote: FYI (multiple keybindings per menu action in GTK+). As I see it will be implemented in GTK+ 2.4 I vote

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread Raphaël Quinet
On Thu, 2 Oct 2003 08:34:25 +0200, David Neary [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If this is an almost-concensus (only myself, Alan Horkan and Raphael seem to like the change), it seems reasonable to revert the redo shortcut to Ctrl-R. Please don't. If you replace the current Ctrl-Shift-Z by something

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread Simon Budig
Raphaël Quinet ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: On Thu, 2 Oct 2003 08:34:25 +0200, David Neary [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If this is an almost-concensus (only myself, Alan Horkan and Raphael seem to like the change), it seems reasonable to revert the redo shortcut to Ctrl-R. Please don't. If

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread Tino Schwarze
On Thu, Oct 02, 2003 at 11:03:02AM +0200, Simon Budig wrote: If this is an almost-concensus (only myself, Alan Horkan and Raphael seem to like the change), it seems reasonable to revert the redo shortcut to Ctrl-R. Please don't. If you replace the current Ctrl-Shift-Z by something

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread Sven Neumann
Hi, Raphal Quinet [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On Thu, 2 Oct 2003 08:34:25 +0200, David Neary [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If this is an almost-concensus (only myself, Alan Horkan and Raphael seem to like the change), it seems reasonable to revert the redo shortcut to Ctrl-R. Please don't.

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread Sven Neumann
Hi, [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Tino Schwarze) writes: I would not change the shortcut if it will be changed with GTK 2.4 anyway. Just stick with CTRL-R. This way, we can later provide an alternative more sane extra shortcut using GTK 2.4. I don't think we ever want a second shortcut for anything. We

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread David Neary
Hi, Sven Neumann wrote: Raphaël Quinet [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: try to replace it by something that is used by some other applications, such as Ctrl-Y. Do not bring back the old Ctrl-R. Unless Ctrl-Y collides with another suggested shortcut in the HIG, it seems like a reasonable choice

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread Joao S. O. Bueno
Will you excuse me...but ..what CTRL-Y has to with REDO alltogether? CTRL + R - R is the first letter in REDO. SHIFT + CTRl + Z - Shift acts as amodifier to the CTRL + Z UNDO. CTRl + X - Stays next to Z and allows for fat toggling as has been argued. But... CTRL-Y? Why not just stick with

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread Raphaël Quinet
On Thu, 02 Oct 2003 09:19:11 -0300, Joao S. O. Bueno [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Will you excuse me...but ..what CTRL-Y has to with REDO alltogether? For better or worse, Ctrl-Y is the most frequently used shortcut for Redo. CTRL-Y? Why not just stick with CTRL+R? Maybe to pick the worst of both

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-02 Thread Sven Neumann
Hi, Raphal Quinet [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Ctrl-Y is the shortcut used by most Windows applications (except for Photoshop and Paint Shop Pro, using Ctrl-Shift-Z and Ctrl-Alt-Z) As far as I understood, Photoshop uses Ctrl-Z for redo. Actually a redo in PS is just an undo of the previous undo

[Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-01 Thread Tom Mraz
FYI (multiple keybindings per menu action in GTK+). As I see it will be implemented in GTK+ 2.4 I vote for leaving the current redo keybinding as is and wait for GTK+ 2.4 with the change. Tom Mraz Original Message Subject: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional

Re: [Gimp-developer] [Fwd: [Bug 123647] Changed - Allow attaching additional (hidden) keybindings (accelerators) to menu entries]

2003-10-01 Thread Sven Neumann
Hi, Tom Mraz [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: FYI (multiple keybindings per menu action in GTK+). As I see it will be implemented in GTK+ 2.4 I vote for leaving the current redo keybinding as is and wait for GTK+ 2.4 with the change. The new menu API in GTK+-2.4 will solve quite a few of our