Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread David Rysdam
On Thu, 07 Apr 2011 21:26:43 -0400, Bruce Labitt bruce.lab...@myfairpoint.net wrote: Had an interesting conversation this evening. A snipped version basically was: op: You like to use a lot of Open Source Software don't you? Don't you know it is not 'standard' here? me: Hmm. What

[FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Ric Werme
Had an interesting conversation this evening. A snipped version basically was: op: You like to use a lot of Open Source Software don't you? Don't you know it is not 'standard' here? me: Hmm. What part of free, efficient and fast don't you care for? op: (no answer) I appreciate the

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
But really, nobody got fired for buying the standard, i.e. what everyone else is buying. People get fired because the project does not work...it makes little difference if the failed solution is standard or not. md ___ gnhlug-discuss mailing list

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Bruce Labitt
Makes me be more productive *is* the point. Why would anyone want to be less productive ? Oh, and anyone could read, reproduce, test or execute the work. Sounds like a positive proposition to me. On Apr 8, 2011 8:18 AM, Ric Werme ewe...@comcast.net wrote: Had an interesting conversation this

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread David Rysdam
On Fri, 08 Apr 2011 08:33:29 -0400, Jon 'maddog' Hall mad...@li.org wrote: But really, nobody got fired for buying the standard, i.e. what everyone else is buying. People get fired because the project does not work...it makes little difference if the failed solution is standard or not. I

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
Why do many large organizations tend to resist FOSS? Discuss. FUD...utilizing the true definitionof the unknown. Even today there are lots of people in IT management who started after the beginning of Microsoft and Appleand other systems companies who utilized closed source. Buying a

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
This whole conversation reminds me of the contention that existed between Cobol and Fortran programmers. Put one or more of either into a team with the others, and you're got a recipe for instant gray haired managers - especially when reviewing each other's code! I worked with a man who wrote a

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Thomas Charron
On Fri, Apr 8, 2011 at 9:02 AM, Jon 'maddog' Hall mad...@li.org wrote: Why do many large organizations tend to resist FOSS?  Discuss. FUD...utilizing the true definitionof the unknown. Even today there are lots of people in IT management who started after the beginning of Microsoft and

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Joseph Smith
On 04/08/2011 09:02 AM, Jon 'maddog' Hall wrote: Why do many large organizations tend to resist FOSS? Discuss. FUD...utilizing the true definitionof the unknown. Even today there are lots of people in IT management who started after the beginning of Microsoft and Appleand other

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Mark Komarinski
I'll be a bit of a Devil's Advocate here. On 04/08/2011 09:02 AM, Jon 'maddog' Hall wrote: Why do many large organizations tend to resist FOSS? Discuss. FUD...utilizing the true definitionof the unknown. Even today there are lots of people in IT management who started after the

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
'Buying a solution' is how we always approach things. We don't build our own cars or houses from kits anymore - we buy them pre-built. Sometimes buying a solution is one way of solving a problem, particularly if the solution fits the problem. However if the solution does not fit the problem,

Re: Fun 404 page.

2011-04-08 Thread Ted Roche
On Mon, Apr 4, 2011 at 10:40 AM, Ken D'Ambrosio k...@jots.org wrote: I clicked on a link in a c. '99 Linux article, and wound up here: http://www.ibiblio.org/LDP Another 404 page that pleases the inner geek: https://github.com/flyingmachine/clean-up-your-mess (roll your mouse over the

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Lloyd Kvam
On Fri, 2011-04-08 at 10:54 -0400, Mark Komarinski wrote: Along the same lines, if you already have a staff of .NET developers, why make them learn PHP and Drupal when they can just do something in SharePoint? Sometimes an organization needs to step back and review what they're doing and

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Ken D'Ambrosio
On Fri, April 8, 2011 10:54 am, Mark Komarinski wrote: Be honest here, how many of you built your home desktop from scratch? How about your parents? Why do you think there's a discrepancy in those numbers? I have, many times -- including the desktop sitting at my left this very moment. So

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
How does one innovate if one has to do *everything* in a standard fashion? Exactly! And now you have touched on another sore spot I have with today's managementthey do not see IT as a strategic resource. Some managers treat IT today as if it is a commodity, something that has to happen

Re: ssh reverse tunnel issue

2011-04-08 Thread Michael ODonnell
Huh? You saw sessions freeze for as long as a *full minute* and after disabling compression you're no longer seeing that problem? Hrmmm Compression can certainly slow things down sometimes but I can't think how even unnecessary triple redundant compression could all by itself block traffic

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Thomas Charron
On Fri, Apr 8, 2011 at 12:59 PM, Jon 'maddog' Hall mad...@li.org wrote: If everyone uses the same software in exactly the same way, then it is a commodity...but how to you get ahead of your competitor that way? But if someone innovates *ANY TIME THEY CAN* it does from innovation, to being an

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Thomas Charron
On Fri, Apr 8, 2011 at 1:10 PM, Thomas Charron twaf...@gmail.com wrote:  But if someone innovates *ANY TIME THEY CAN* it does from innovation, to being an oddity.  And not all companies who USE does = goes. :-D -- -- Thomas ___ gnhlug-discuss

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
Thomas, But to the original posters comments, the right solution isn't, by default, 'FOSS'. I do not know what question you are trying to answer, perhaps How do list members respond to this line of questioning? But the question I am trying to answer, also from the original poster was: Why do

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Mark Komarinski
On 04/08/2011 11:15 AM, Jon 'maddog' Hall wrote: Not the same issuethis is apples and oranges. I am not asking the managers to write the solution themselves. I am advocating that they hire experts to create it for them. Hiring someone (for non-core business purposes) is probably more

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
Do you honestly give a snot if the machine testing you for Cancer is taking twice as long as it could if I'd implemented an innovating data analysys algorithm? Interesting you should ask that particular question. The first Beowulf system I ever physically saw was at the University of Sao Paulo,

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Thomas Charron
On Fri, Apr 8, 2011 at 1:50 PM, Jon 'maddog' Hall mad...@li.org wrote: So, do you think I give a snot?  Sorry, I do. The answer doesn't scale. That same 'problem' using a cluster years ago can now be processed in *minutes* on a Xeon quad processor. I'm actually leading a product right now

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
The answer doesn't scale. Sorry, it scaled with the information you gave me. That same 'problem' using a cluster years ago can now be processed in *minutes* on a Xeon quad processor. ...and the capabilities of the ENIAC can be done on my wristwatch today. o First of all, I am talking about

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Thomas Charron
On Fri, Apr 8, 2011 at 1:44 PM, Jon 'maddog' Hall mad...@li.org wrote: Thomas, But to the original posters comments, the right solution isn't, by default, 'FOSS'. I do not know what question you are trying to answer, perhaps op: You like to use a lot of Open Source Software don't you? Don't

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Thomas Charron
On Fri, Apr 8, 2011 at 2:08 PM, Jon 'maddog' Hall mad...@li.org wrote: The answer doesn't scale. Sorry, it scaled with the information you gave me. John, *you* provided the information that everyone should always be trying to inovate. If I misunderstood your point, my bad. My point is, when

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
John, *you* provided the information that everyone should always be trying to inovate. Pardon me, I said that a lot of IT managers are now looking at IT as a non-strategic resource, and therefore do not look at it as something where they should innovate. I do not believe I *ever* said *everyone*

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
The assumption of the original question, as stated, was that there was some resistance, when the conversation he quoted, depending on tone, could very well have been used to enlighten, instead of a condesending, 'If your not in the IN crowd, your obviously an idiot'. I read this part, read your

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Bruce Labitt
Thanks, one and all, for your insights. I hadn't intended this thread to quite play out the way it did, but it was at the very least entertaining in some way. I don't develop software for a living. I do use programming languages to model systems, to create product(s) with new capabilities,

Re: [FOSS] How does one respond to this line of questioning?

2011-04-08 Thread Seth Cohn
A few comments: md wrote: As a Free Software Evangelist I have often advised people that if they have a system that is working perfectly fine, paid up licenses, on hardware that is cost effective, then they are typically foolish to try and move that to FOSS, for that will be the all pain and

Re: ssh reverse tunnel issue

2011-04-08 Thread Eric Stein
If ssh compression works anything like telnet message chunk sending, it could be waiting for something that looks like a newline in the stream... 2 wrapped compressed streams could break that state machine. Eric - Original message - Huh?  You saw sessions freeze for as long as a