[Goanet]Church built on temple site ?

2004-03-28 Thread Vivian D'Souza
Oral history has it that Our Lady of Perpetual Succour church, in Socorro, Bardez, was built in the general vicinity of where a Hindu temple once existed in a ward called Zoswado (probably a corruption of the original Joshivaddo). The temple was not razed to construct the church on the exact

[Goanet]Church built on Temple?

2004-03-25 Thread Miguel Braganza
I do not know about other churches which are actually converted temples, but the church at Mapusa is definitely one of them. Alfred de Tavares calls it the Igreja da Nossa Senhora dos Milagres, Mapuça . So do most people, even Mapsekars, although the church is actually dedicated to St. Jerome [not

[Goanet]Church built on Temple?

2004-03-24 Thread Sachin Phadte
Tim de Mello says: If you ask most Catholics in Goa if their church was built on the site of a Hindu temple, they will reply by saying they do not know for sure but - yes, probably. This is accepted by both Catholics and Hindus and there is no indication that any party (religious or political)

RE: [Goanet]Church built on Temple?

2004-03-23 Thread Tim de Mello
If you ask most Catholics in Goa if their church was built on the site of a Hindu temple, they will reply by saying they do not know for sure but - yes, probably. This is accepted by both Catholics and Hindus and there is no indication that any party (religious or political) wants to reverse

Re: [Goanet]Church built on Temple?

2004-03-22 Thread Tariq Siddiqui
--- Sachin Phadte [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I had raised this issue not in this context, but because of a statement posted on this list that the BJP in Goa is asking for the return of the destroyed sites. I had not heard of such statements, and I wanted to have a confirmation.

[Goanet]Church built on Temple?

2004-03-22 Thread Sachin Phadte
appreciate if he could clarify. Sachin Phadte From: Gilbert Lawrence [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Fri, 19 Mar 2004 20:47:16 -0500 Subject: [Goanet]Church built on Temple? Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sachin's question still stands on whether Catholic churches were built over

[Goanet]Church built on Temple?

2004-03-20 Thread Gilbert Lawrence
Church built on Temple? Santosh Helekar: This is a thread wherein I support Gilbert's quest to find out the truth - to ask the Goan journalists, GoaNetters and other such amateur historians to prove the claims made by professional historians, and then revise Goan history if these folks are unable

RE: [Goanet]Church built on Temple?

2004-03-20 Thread Alfred de Tavares
. dos Milagres, in Vanxem, is a converted temple. Mario Cabral e Sa, among others, will have many more examples. Alfred de Tavares From: Gilbert Lawrence [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [Goanet]Church built on Temple? Date: Fri, 19 Mar 2004 20:47:16

[Goanet]Church built on Temple?

2004-03-20 Thread Gilbert Lawrence
Sachin's question still stands on whether Catholic churches were built over Hindu Temples in Goa. It is very unfortunate that individuals who made the original statement and those who repeated it cannot (once again) back up their statements with specific examples or numbers. Most religious