Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-04-22 Thread Stavros Konstantaras
is quite useful to do that as well. Kind Regards Stavros From: Martin Pels Date: Friday, 19 April 2024 at 15:12 To: Stavros Konstantaras , Jeff Haas Cc: grow@ietf.org grow@ietf.org , moy...@linx.net Subject: Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-04-19 Thread Martin Pels
Hi Stavros, On 18/04/2024 11:32, Stavros Konstantaras wrote: Hi Martin, Jeff and colleagues. After some internal discussion, we have submitted the -02 version of the draft, you can find it available here: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-04-18 Thread Stavros Konstantaras
: Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024 Hi Stavros, I support this work. The Extended Communities for RS signaling were always a kludge, so I'd like to see them go away. On 15/03/2024 10:28, Stavros Konstantaras wrote: > Hi Jeff, > >

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-30 Thread Martin Pels
Hi Stavros, I support this work. The Extended Communities for RS signaling were always a kludge, so I'd like to see them go away. On 15/03/2024 10:28, Stavros Konstantaras wrote: Hi Jeff, Thank you very much for your comment. As Job said, the draft is targeting the Route Server

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-16 Thread Jeffrey Haas
On Sun, Mar 17, 2024 at 12:24:27AM +, Job Snijders wrote: > On Sat, Mar 16, 2024 at 08:19:42PM -0400, Jeffrey Haas wrote: > > > Moreover, we know at least another IXP that dropped support for > > Extended Communities 2 years ago with big success, thus adopting > > such a practice from other

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-16 Thread Job Snijders
On Sat, Mar 16, 2024 at 08:19:42PM -0400, Jeffrey Haas wrote: > > Moreover, we know at least another IXP that dropped support for > Extended Communities 2 years ago with big success, thus adopting > such a practice from other fellow IXPs shouldn’t be of > an issue as long as support for Large

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-16 Thread Jeffrey Haas
Stavros, On Fri, Mar 15, 2024 at 09:28:19AM +, Stavros Konstantaras wrote: > Thank you very much for your comment. As Job said, the draft is targeting the > Route Server infrastructure of Internet Exchange Points, but do you believe > that this is something that needs further clarification

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-15 Thread Stavros Konstantaras
-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024 Hi Jeff, On Thu, Mar 14, 2024 at 10:54:54PM -0400, Jeff Haas wrote: > I’m at least 90%, “Meh, whatever “ for the > proposal as long as it doesn’t become a recommendation to filter > the extended communities by default. For purposes of the

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-15 Thread Job Snijders
Hi Jeff, On Thu, Mar 14, 2024 at 10:54:54PM -0400, Jeff Haas wrote: > I’m at least 90%, “Meh, whatever “ for the > proposal as long as it doesn’t become a recommendation to filter > the extended communities by default. For purposes of the adoption poll, > consider this a conditional

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-14 Thread Jeff Haas
I’m at least 90%, “Meh, whatever “ for the proposal as long as it doesn’t become a recommendation to filter the extended communities by default. For purposes of the adoption poll, consider this a conditional abstention. The last 10% of my opinion is formed by the fact that extended

[GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-11 Thread Christopher Morrow
Howdy WG folks! The authors of: draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms (https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms/) are interested in seeking WG Adoption for their new missive. The abstract is included here-in: "This document outlines a recommendation to the Internet