Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-03 Thread Robert Krawitz
On Wed, 2 Nov 2011 22:57:08 -0700 (PDT), JohnPW wrote: If I don't misunderstand your post . . . Yes, one wants a level horizon, but the horizon is an imaginary line and is only evident in certain perfect situations without obstructions (flat desert, seascape, etc.) In most natural situations

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-03 Thread JohnPW
Well that's one of those easy situations. When you can see the horizon clearly like that, horizontal CPs distributed about the pano on the horizon should give you great results. Contrary to how one might casually think, placing them far apart (with very wide angle images) produces diminishing

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-03 Thread JohnPW
BTW my sig would have to be more like Unix doesn't dictate how I work, it dictates how I don't work (but only when I consciously try to use it.) ;-) I love that it's there, but I like having that Aqua interface softening the ride! -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-03 Thread Robert Krawitz
On Thu, 3 Nov 2011 07:06:01 -0700 (PDT), JohnPW wrote: Well that's one of those easy situations. When you can see the horizon clearly like that, horizontal CPs distributed about the pano on the horizon should give you great results. Contrary to how one might casually think, placing them far

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-03 Thread JohnPW
Ah the Pilgrim monument. I haven't been there. Very nice panoramas. They all look very well done to me. You clearly have very high production standards. When I was working for the NPS I did a similar style panorama from the top of the Cape Lookout Light (not even remotely as nice as yours

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-03 Thread Robert Krawitz
On Thu, 3 Nov 2011 09:35:04 -0700 (PDT), JohnPW wrote: Ah the Pilgrim monument. I haven't been there. Very nice panoramas. They all look very well done to me. You clearly have very high production standards. Thanks! When I was working for the NPS I did a similar style panorama from the top

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-03 Thread JohnPW
So how do folks do their hand adjustments? . . . [I guess I should start a new topic for this.] On Nov 3, 12:47 pm, Robert Krawitz r...@alum.mit.edu wrote: I had the same problem on the Pilgrim monument.  There are only four spots, at the center of each side, where there's a clear view without

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-02 Thread Emad ud din Bhatt
can we use vertical line detector by Setting equirect pitch to 90 degree and than call vertical line detector. Than set pano pitch to -90 and call vertical line detector again? On Fri, Oct 28, 2011 at 7:09 PM, Battle battlebr...@gmail.com wrote: I'll reiterate Thomas' comments. I do a lot

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-02 Thread Bruno Postle
On Wed 02-Nov-2011 at 11:47 +0500, Emad ud din Bhatt wrote: can we use vertical line detector by Setting equirect pitch to 90 degree and than call vertical line detector. Than set pano pitch to -90 and call vertical line detector again? Yes (or roll), but you would have to manually change all

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-02 Thread Ian Adam
Greetings all, I'm new here. This is all very interesting to me. My project at the moment is to photograph the school where I work, parts of which can be seen here: http://www.i-magz.com/thomas-more.html In front of the school is a strip of grass, then a narrow road, then a thick row of trees.

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-11-02 Thread JohnPW
If I don't misunderstand your post . . . Yes, one wants a level horizon, but the horizon is an imaginary line and is only evident in certain perfect situations without obstructions (flat desert, seascape, etc.) In most natural situations like landscapes, the viewer's senses are not greatly

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-10-28 Thread Battle
I'll reiterate Thomas' comments. I do a lot of buildings. I would like horizontal and vertical line detectors. Seems like it ought to be a simple programming loop that would reuse existing vertical line feature search on a 90 degree rotated basis calling them horizontal instead of vertical. I

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-10-27 Thread Jeffrey Martin
I'm bringing this thread up again... Does anyone find the possibility of a horizon detector interesting, for cases where there are not vertical lines, but there is a horizon? This would help to automatically level more panos Jeffrey -- You received this message because you are

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-30 Thread Jeffrey Martin
Still, there is certainly use for a *horizon* detector. in many panos there is water - the ocean - and no vertical lines. here, the only way to level the pano is to set this horizon line. this is not an edge case - this is a really big case :) if you check some panos on 360cities you'll see

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-18 Thread Harry van der Wolf
Hi Thomas, 2011/9/17 T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de It's an edge detector. The same as in calibrate_lens_gui. If it would consider only parallel lines, it would not handles perspective distortion (stürzende Linien in German) correctly. (A view from a non-programming user): Isn't it possible

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-18 Thread T. Modes
Hi (A view from a non-programming user): Isn't it possible to make linefind a two-step edge detector. First search for vertical lines, then rotate the algorithm itself and search for horizontal lines. I see that you have vertical lines functions and structures inside findlines.cpp. Could it

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-18 Thread kfj
On 18 Sep., 10:51, T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de wrote: Hi (A view from a non-programming user): Isn't it possible to make linefind a two-step edge detector. First search for vertical lines, then rotate the algorithm itself and search for horizontal lines. I see that you have vertical

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-18 Thread kfj
On 18 Sep., 11:16, kfj _...@yahoo.com wrote: and in equirect all horizontal lines come out horizontal (to be more precise, I'm talking about lines which in a perfect equirect or rectilinear or cylindrical projection would appear horizontal, not merely lines which are horizontal in the scene

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-18 Thread Harry van der Wolf
2011/9/18 T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de Hi (A view from a non-programming user): Isn't it possible to make linefind a two-step edge detector. First search for vertical lines, then rotate the algorithm itself and search for horizontal lines. I see that you have vertical lines functions

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-17 Thread T. Modes
Hi Kay, Sorry to keep pestering you about it, but if no images are selected in the images tab and you click to use linefind, it looks at no images - rather than at all images, which is the default behaviour with all other CPGs if no images are selectd. So maybe you can modify your hack yet

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-17 Thread Gnome Nomad
T. Modes wrote: Hi Kay, Sorry to keep pestering you about it, but if no images are selected in the images tab and you click to use linefind, it looks at no images - rather than at all images, which is the default behaviour with all other CPGs if no images are selectd. So maybe you can modify

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-17 Thread kfj
On 17 Sep., 19:10, Gnome Nomad gnomeno...@gmail.com wrote: It reports only vertical lines. But there is a workaround: Run linefind to find vertical lines. Then change the roll value of all images to 90 (or -90) and run linefind again. This will find the horizontal lines. Then wouldn't

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-15 Thread Harry van der Wolf
Hi Thomas, I have observed now that vertical linefind is an integral part of cpfind. I don't like that very much as it actually disturbs some panorama's. I think it should be an option, be it a default option.But is should be possible to do without, something like --noverticallinefind (or a

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-15 Thread T. Modes
Hi Harry, I have observed now that vertical linefind is an integral part of cpfind. That's wrong. Linefind is an own program and not integrated into cpfind. I don't like that very much as it actually disturbs some panorama's. I think it should be an option, be it a default option.But is

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-15 Thread Harry van der Wolf
2011/9/15 Harry van der Wolf hvdw...@gmail.com 2011/9/15 T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de Hi Harry, I have observed now that vertical linefind is an integral part of cpfind. That's wrong. Linefind is an own program and not integrated into cpfind. So I thought but it seemed not from the

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-15 Thread Harry van der Wolf
2011/9/15 T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de Hi Harry, I have observed now that vertical linefind is an integral part of cpfind. That's wrong. Linefind is an own program and not integrated into cpfind. So I thought but it seemed not from the output. I don't like that very much as it

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-15 Thread Harry van der Wolf
2011/9/15 Harry van der Wolf hvdw...@gmail.com 2011/9/15 Harry van der Wolf hvdw...@gmail.com 2011/9/15 T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de Hi Harry, I have observed now that vertical linefind is an integral part of cpfind. That's wrong. Linefind is an own program and not integrated into

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-14 Thread Ian Tindale
Can I have a copy of your built OS X one too, if you can put it up online somewhere? Thanks. On 13 September 2011 20:06, Harry van der Wolf hvdw...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Thomas, Just built the 5551. Did 2 panos and linefind works fine on OSX as well. Will do some more tests. Harry --

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-14 Thread Harry van der Wolf
2011/9/14 Ian Tindale ian.tind...@gmail.com Can I have a copy of your built OS X one too, if you can put it up online somewhere? Thanks. Tonight I will put it on my website as usual. Harry -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups Hugin and other free

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-13 Thread kfj
On 11 Sep., 19:41, T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de wrote: Hi group, the default branch contains now a vertical line detector. It tries to generate vertical control points for levelling of the pano. I have another slight issue with linefind. When I use it from hugin, sometimes I want it to look

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-13 Thread T. Modes
Hi Kay, So my issue is with hugins's interaction with this specific CPG rather than with the CPG itself. I wonder if this wouldn't be easy to fix for someone who's inside the code? added special handling for linefind to work with single image. (It's more like a hack, it works only for cpg

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-13 Thread kfj
On 13 Sep., 19:43, T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de wrote: Hi Kay, So my issue is with hugins's interaction with this specific CPG rather than with the CPG itself. I wonder if this wouldn't be easy to fix for someone who's inside the code? added special handling for linefind to work with

Re: [hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-13 Thread Harry van der Wolf
Hi Thomas, Just built the 5551. Did 2 panos and linefind works fine on OSX as well. Will do some more tests. Harry -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups Hugin and other free panoramic software group. A list of frequently asked questions is available at:

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-12 Thread kfj
On 11 Sep., 19:41, T. Modes thomas.mo...@gmx.de wrote: Hi group, the default branch contains now a vertical line detector. It tries to generate vertical control points for levelling of the pano. ... Compiles, integrates and runs here: Betriebssystem: Linux 2.6.38-11-generic-tuxonice i686

[hugin-ptx] Re: Vertical line detector

2011-09-12 Thread T. Modes
@Kay but in the resulting pto file, result.pto, all three vertical CPs are assigned to image number zero: # control points c n0 N0 x2847.22729509834 y2096.36641460524 X2851.72865032147 Y2405.76855173728 t1 c n0 N0 x-2.47460425806207 y2128.94518372973 X-3.35545983791303 Y2407.96021470891