z/OSMF

2023-05-30 Thread VER Z038
Why so much hate for z/OSMF? We sound like a bunch of grumpy old boomers resistant to change.  I always found ServerPac clunky and unnecessarily complicated. Longing for that is not a hill I would choose to die on.  I have been supporting a 4 LPAR organisation since 2018 using z/OSMF

Re: [EXTERNAL] zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Matt Hogstrom
I believe what you stated below is the major problem. z/OS systems have years of process, embedded meta information in PROCs, file names, HLQs, etc. Its not a “fresh disk install” its about existing processes and procedures, time to migrate, the risk involved in making the alignment happen

Re: SSHD terminates immediately with permission(?) problem

2023-05-30 Thread Michael Babcock
I think ours is set for port 22 with SSHD* but I’d have to check to be sure. On Tue, May 30, 2023 at 5:55 PM Wendell Lovewell < 01e9c0ee0673-dmarc-requ...@listserv.ua.edu> wrote: > A big "Thank you" to all of you listers who chimed in on my "EDC5111I > Permission denied.

Re: SSHD terminates immediately with permission(?) problem

2023-05-30 Thread Wendell Lovewell
A big "Thank you" to all of you listers who chimed in on my "EDC5111I Permission denied. (errno2=0x744C7246)." message. Almost everyone was on the right track. Changing to port showed that it was just port 22. Commenting out the RESTRICTLOWPORTS and the PORT reservation for "22 SSHD"

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Jeremy Nicoll
On Tue, 30 May 2023, at 21:41, Seymour J Metz wrote: > SMP/E uses VSAM I've no idea if that is or was correct > and doesn't have the wonky member names of SMP through SMP4. You keep saying this ... and you're still wrong. I don't know why you're so sure. Maybe it's changed since then

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Pommier, Rex
Very true - and that isn't just Windows. MS Office anyone? It seems like every new release they tape the user interface icons and menu items to scrabble pieces, then give them a good shake in a hat, pulling them out randomly to build the next user interface. OK, it isn't that bad but they do

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Pommier, Rex
Really? I just looked at my z/OS SCDS (2.4). Definitely a PDS structure and here's what it looks like: Name .G.3 .GXc'... ../. .Z7X>... _{.. _... nGXc=... Rex -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Seymour J Metz Sent:

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Seymour J Metz
I haven't installed windows since 3.1, but I always do as fresh install of ArcalOS and Linux on a spare logical drive, using a RYO script to deploy my customization. That includes a lot of desktop customization for ArcaOS. For z/OS, you should be able to keep your local mods in a PDS, rework if

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Phil Smith III
FWIW (perhaps nothing), IBM solved the upgrade problem ~30 years ago for VM by separating the operating system nucleus (kernel) from the filesystem. That is, you can have multiple copies of the VM nucleus on various CMS (the end-user environment) minidisks, which CP (the hypervisor) knows how

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Tom Brennan
And not just with every new release! These days Windows (at least how I run it) decides to put on changes whenever it feels like it. But if you're talking about the default Windows Start Menu, I haven't used it since Windows 7. With a new Windows install that's probably the first thing I

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Seymour J Metz
ObQohelet1:9 I vaguely recall reading a diatribe against the degeneracy of the younger generation, written in ancient Greece. There have always been people who didn't want to learn. -- Shmuel (Seymour J.) Metz http://mason.gmu.edu/~smetz3 From: IBM

SSRB/SSRX and LOCAL locks question

2023-05-30 Thread David Cole
Does any know if suspended SRB control blocks (SSRB/SSRX) are stabilized by holding the LOCAL lock? (I'm considering logic in support of setting up TRAP2 debugging for SRBs.) Thanks, Dave Cole -- For IBM-MAIN subscribe /

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Seymour J Metz
SMP/E uses VSAM and doesn't have the wonky member names of SMP through SMP4. -- Shmuel (Seymour J.) Metz http://mason.gmu.edu/~smetz3 From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List [IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU] on behalf of Jay Maynard [jaymayn...@gmail.com] Sent:

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Tom Brennan
Funny! Yes, that sounds like the same conversation I had with XXX company and the product, not necessarily that number of X's but could be :) You're right, I should have mentioned that when I install a new version of Windows or Linux, I always start with a full install file and a

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Seymour J Metz
I don't see an FMID issue with SMP/E. I see an issue with being able to install and remove service selectively, but can you have a reliable system if they take that away? The classical "reboot" and "reinstall" solutions to windows issues are not acceptable on a 24x365 enterprise server. --

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Seymour J Metz
How about the last time that the menu structure changed? I keep reading user complaints about each new release of windows that boil down to not being able to find things because they aren't where they used to be. -- Shmuel (Seymour J.) Metz http://mason.gmu.edu/~smetz3

Re: SSHD terminates immediately with permission(?) problem

2023-05-30 Thread Matthew Stitt
I'm surprised no one has mentioned about checking to see if the low ports (< 1024) are restricted. Matthew On Tue, 30 May 2023 13:23:23 +, Allan Staller wrote: >Classification: Confidential > >Things to check. >TCP Policy Agent >Other users of the poirt (as previously suggested). >OMVS

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Sri h Kolusu
>> Turned on both of the empty member options and it still does not allow input >> under Prompt. Charles, I misunderstood your request. The prompt option is not available as it is already provided in the EDIT menu itself. However, the panel ISREDM01 is NOT updated with the prompt options

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Charles Mills
Turned on both of the empty member options and it still does not allow input under Prompt. This is with Edit -- ISPF 2. Works with DSLIST -- ISPF 3.4. Charles On Tue, 30 May 2023 17:00:50 +, Sri h Kolusu wrote: >>> Interesting. The Edit member selection panel (ISPF 2 with a blank member

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Pommier, Rex
Tom, I have gotten the privilege of reinstalling 2 Windows machines in the past year that were so messed up from failed installs/updates that it was easier to just low level the hard drive and start over. Could I have fixed 1 or both of them? I don't really know, because Microsoft has hidden

Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Kurt J. Quackenbush
> > Is there anything easy we/IBM could do to move in the right direction? > > Examine the current system, > create a script to set the equivalent values for z/OSMF? Oh, so just like the Model function in z/OSMF Software Management? When you install software, like z/OS, using z/OSMF, during the

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Tom Brennan
"I've known people for whom using Excel is a struggle." Ha ha! Add me to that list. It could be the original PC's and Unix/Linux were also more like a tailored suit, but then things like plug-and-play and better install programs were created to hide and standardize. Like you say, that was

Help for the Less Fortunate - How do I maintain z/VM Users and Disks without DIRMAINT

2023-05-30 Thread Tom Longfellow
Our history with z/VM could best be defined as 'Hobbyist' level to test the concept of multiple virtual Linux servers running on an IFL. As it not being a formally funded project, licensed $$$ software features like DIRMAINT would NOT be purchased or licensed. Over a dozen years ago I set this

Re: Searching for a process to clean my VTS

2023-05-30 Thread Tom Longfellow
Yes I have the list -- I know them by naming standard and I can do a Virtual Volume Search to the Cluster and get a downloadable list of volume names and their current category status.I already have a REXX roughed out that generates the command I think I need. But I really need to find

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread John McKown
Windows, MacOS, Android and so on are built on the premise of "mass marketing". Which means they need are set up in "the one true way". Lack of choice is required to make things easy enough for someone who is not interested in technology, just using something. I've known people for whom using

Re: [EXTERNAL] zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Tom Brennan
I agree with that. On 5/30/2023 10:27 AM, Matt Hogstrom wrote: I can’t speak for IBM but I believe that z/OSMF is part of the strategy to help guide folks onto a consistent approach. The challenge is that policies, procedures and configuration options have existed for years across thousands

Re: [EXTERNAL] zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Matt Hogstrom
I can’t speak for IBM but I believe that z/OSMF is part of the strategy to help guide folks onto a consistent approach. The challenge is that policies, procedures and configuration options have existed for years across thousands of customers. The cloud refers to servers as cattle because

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Tom Brennan
I can't remember the last time a Windows/Linux install failed. I do remember the last time an ISV z/OS install failed, and when I called for help the support person said, "Don't worry about it, *everybody* calls when installing this particular product." :) ISRFIND/ISRDDN is still hunting.

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Sri h Kolusu
>> Interesting. The Edit member selection panel (ISPF 2 with a blank member >> name) shows a Prompt heading but the fields are protected. Charles, You probably don’t have the option to edit empty members. Using option 0 (settings) from ISPF main menu and look at Member list options at the

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Charles Mills
@Sri and @Steve, thank you. Got it. From ISPF 3.4. Interesting. The Edit member selection panel (ISPF 2 with a blank member name) shows a Prompt heading but the fields are protected. Charles On Tue, 30 May 2023 16:39:53 +, Sri h Kolusu wrote: 1. Is there any support in JCL or in ISPF

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Sri h Kolusu
>>>1. Is there any support in JCL or in ISPF for reading member generations? Charles, There is no JCL support for member generations, but ISPF does provide the support. Here is how you do it. 1. Allocate PDSE version 2 with maxgens defined at 20. Note your allocation will fail if your

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Shaffer, Terri
Kids can install, because basically one FMID, and if it doesn’t work, good luck. How many FMID components make up core z/OS? Maybe if IBM made it one FMID you could install like android. I can use ISRFIND or ISRDDN, to find many things out in Seconds, no more hunting thru libraries. z/OS is

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Steve Smith
>From an "Extended" member list display (with the 8-char command field), you can place a '/' in the Prompt field: EDIT SAS00.MAIN.CNTLMember DEFDDIR1 saved Command ===> Scroll ===> CSR Name Prompt

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Doug
Maybe actually teach the new sysprog's how MVS works? Like real knowledge? Ah, why do THAT when there are s many better shortcuts to give them to screw it all up. Glad my time in this gets shorter every day. Doug Fuerst -- Original Message -- From: "Colin Paice" To:

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Lionel B. Dyck
Perhaps we've put the cart before the horse. Define and then transition to a standard environment and then provide the tooling to manage it. Trying to do it the other way around has taken years and too much stress. The transition won't be easy but if there is a benefit it will happen -

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Lennie Dymoke-Bradshaw
Charles, Try this Share presentation. (Rather long URL. If problem just try searching for "PDSE member generations").

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Tom Brennan
So how come my kids can install apps and updates to their Windows and Mac machines, and I can work with Linux with no formal training? For example, I don't need to hunt down SYS3.MY2013.PARMLIB(PROG46), I look in /etc and parms are in standard directories. Even my Android (while annoying)

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Lionel B. Dyck
Your reasons are some of those that prompted the creation of PDSEGEN. Lionel B. Dyck <>< Website: https://www.lbdsoftware.com Github: https://github.com/lbdyck “Worry more about your character than your reputation. Character is what you are, reputation merely what others think you are.” - -

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Schmitt, Michael
Lack of better member generation support is the reason that my team is still using PDS instead of PDS/E. We *like* the ability to easily retrieve previous and deleted versions of members from the PDS "gas". (This is helped because we have a home-written ISPF panel that lets you display,

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Lionel B. Dyck
True enough - and one more thing is that while IBM supports member generations, they DO NOT support them via JCL, dynamic allocation, or the majority of their utilities/tools. And don't even try to find them in zExplorer, ZOWE, or ZOAU (or is it ZAOU?). Lionel B. Dyck <>< Website:

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Jay Maynard
SMP used to do this, and ISTR SMP/E does as well. On Tue, May 30, 2023 at 9:34 AM Schmitt, Michael wrote: > And IMS. MFS Formats have non-display and lower-case letters in the member > names. > > Such as: > > ."wACOV0 > 07ACCDEF > 2F613650 > > > > -Original Message- > From: IBM

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Schmitt, Michael
And IMS. MFS Formats have non-display and lower-case letters in the member names. Such as: ."wACOV0 07ACCDEF 2F613650 -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Steve Thompson Sent: Tuesday, May 30, 2023 8:19 AM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: Re: Two

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Paul Gilmartin
On Tue, 30 May 2023 09:18:48 -0400, Steve Thompson wrote: >I may not have edited these posts correctly for this, but, I >thought I should point out that an IBM product does create >"illegal" (per JCL) member names. And that would be Netview. > Also Binder with the CASE(MIXED) option. >So yes,

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Shaffer, Terri
I have to disagree. First lets talk about the migration guide and how many products an average customer runs for a z/OS upgrade? Then how many of the hundreds of actions does any one customer need to actually perform? Then, I know many customers, who may apply one RSU once per year and just add

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Mike Schwab
On Tue, May 30, 2023 at 9:04 AM Colin Paice wrote: > > People feel that z/OSMF is not meeting their needs. Looking at the positive > sideIf we wanted to get future z/OS newbies up to speed very quickly (1 > month) What should IBM and us users be doing? > >1. Making better use of existing

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Colin Paice
People feel that z/OSMF is not meeting their needs. Looking at the positive sideIf we wanted to get future z/OS newbies up to speed very quickly (1 month) What should IBM and us users be doing? 1. Making better use of existing tools? Eclipse ? 2. Simplify the installation process

Re: SSHD terminates immediately with permission(?) problem

2023-05-30 Thread Allan Staller
Classification: Confidential Things to check. TCP Policy Agent Other users of the poirt (as previously suggested). OMVS segment for the affected user. Public/Private keypair definitions and Permissions. SSH is (*VERY PICKY*) about file permissions. I suggest the following reading (thank you

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Steve Thompson
I may not have edited these posts correctly for this, but, I thought I should point out that an IBM product does create "illegal" (per JCL) member names. And that would be Netview. In years gone by I had seen member names that were really "odd" and found out that it was Netview that was

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF

2023-05-30 Thread Allan Staller
Classification: Confidential Agreed! -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Shaffer, Terri Sent: Friday, May 26, 2023 12:34 PM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: zOSMF [CAUTION: This Email is from outside the Organization. Unless you

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Seymour J Metz
To clarify, you must use the absolute dsn if you need to specify a member name *in the JCL* but you can use a relative generation to allocate a PDS[E] to a step that opens the GDS with DSORG=PO and processes individual members via, e.g., FIND, OPENJ. -- Shmuel (Seymour J.) Metz

Re: Two related member generation questions

2023-05-30 Thread Lionel B. Dyck
As others have said - PDSE member generations are *not* generation data sets. A PDS or PDSE can be a GDS but the members are not. PDSE member generations provide similar functionality to a GDG in that the current generation has both a relative, and absolute, generation of 0. The prior

Re: Searching for a process to clean my VTS

2023-05-30 Thread kekronbekron
Hi Tom, Do you already know the names of the volumes that are now in no man's land? Isn't that required for Brian's suggestion to work? I suggest digging through https://public.dhe.ibm.com/storage/tapetool/ to see if anything in there will help. You may not find anything to find the volumes,