Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-25 Thread David White
The Cisco SG series is decent for semi-managed switches. I have installed a number of the SG-200 series for various clients. They support QoS, VLANs, etc... If you want Layer 3 capability, though, I am pretty sure you need to get a 300 or better. I know the 200s don't support it. On Sep 24,

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-25 Thread David White
PS... I have never used the Ubiquiti switches, but FWIW, I absolutely love their wireless APs. On Sep 25, 2014 6:35 AM, David White dwr...@gmail.com wrote: The Cisco SG series is decent for semi-managed switches. I have installed a number of the SG-200 series for various clients. They support

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-25 Thread Jim Thompson
All of pfSense (ESF Netgate, including the collocation sites) runs on a combination of Dell PowerEdge 5524P (PoE), 5548, and 8924F switches. -- Jim On Sep 23, 2014, at 12:56 PM, Chris Bagnall pfse...@lists.minotaur.cc wrote: On 23/9/14 6:46 pm, RB wrote: I'd suggest at least a managed

[pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Kenward Vaughan
Sorry about the topic, but when I had asked a question before about trying to tie into a wireless network through a pfSense box, your answers to what turned out to be another OT question actually led our IS group to give me full VPN access to the outside world. I will be putting a pfSense box

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Moshe Katz
On Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at 1:28 PM, Kenward Vaughan kay_...@earthlink.net wrote: Sorry about the topic, but when I had asked a question before about trying to tie into a wireless network through a pfSense box, your answers to what turned out to be another OT question actually led our IS group to

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread David Ross
On 9/23/14, 1:36 PM, Moshe Katz wrote: On Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at 1:28 PM, Kenward Vaughan kay_...@earthlink.net mailto:kay_...@earthlink.net wrote: Sorry about the topic, but when I had asked a question before about trying to tie into a wireless network through a pfSense box, your

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread RB
On Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at 11:36 AM, Moshe Katz mo...@ymkatz.net wrote: If you don't need to do any fancy routing or VLAN stuff, just go on Amazon or NewEgg and get the top-rated 16-port unmanaged gigabit switch. I would slightly disagree - note that it's a compute cluster and that the machines

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Chris Bagnall
On 23/9/14 6:46 pm, RB wrote: I'd suggest at least a managed switch that can do LACP. This. Given how small the price difference often is between unmanaged and semi-managed (aka 'smart') switches these days, it just doesn't make sense to buy unmanaged any more. You never know when things

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Josh Reynolds
The 1910's ARE rebranded 3com, but I found them to be very reliable. We are having good luck with the 2530's right now. Josh Reynolds, Chief Information Officer SPITwSPOTS, www.spitwspots.com http://www.spitwspots.com On 09/23/2014 09:56 AM, Chris Bagnall wrote: On 23/9/14 6:46 pm, RB wrote:

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Adam Thompson
+1 for HP ProCurve, except for the stuff they inherited from 3Com... I've also had reasonably good luck with Netgear and D-Link managed switches. The Cisco SMB stuff seems OK hardware-wise, but the software is questionable. Note that all three of these options come with lifetime, free, firmware

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Michael Bubb
I agree with the point that managed vs nonmanaged price difference is negligible so why not managed... Ubiquiti is worth a look for this application. The OS is nice to work with and has both CLI and GUI http://www.ubnt.com/edgemax/edgeswitch/ On Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at 2:04 PM, Adam Thompson

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Josh Reynolds
Interesting that I would see Ubiquiti pop up on this list. I am Josh_SPITwSPOTS on that forum... http://community.ubnt.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/108998 TheGUI and CLI are a mess. Thatsaid, they are stable, but if you don't need 24vpassive POE, and/or 802.3at/af, then the HP has

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Chris Bagnall
On 23/9/14 7:44 pm, Espen Johansen wrote: A netgear pro switch Be careful which model you get. Some of the newer/cheaper ones that have been sold as 'managed' recently don't have a web interface. They have some horrible management application that uses Adobe Air, only works on Windows, only

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Stefan Baur
Am 23.09.2014 um 20:56 schrieb Chris Bagnall: Be careful which model you get. Some of the newer/cheaper ones that have been sold as 'managed' recently don't have a web interface. They have some horrible management application that uses Adobe Air, only works on Windows, only communicates with

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Kurt Buff
HP Procurves are a good line of switches, and often come with a full lifetime warranty. I also like Juniper, but those tend to be more expensive, although often more capable than the HPs. It's my policy (as a networking professional) to *always* buy managed switches. Doing this can give you a

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread J. Echter
Am 23.09.2014 19:56, schrieb Chris Bagnall: On 23/9/14 6:46 pm, RB wrote: I'd suggest at least a managed switch that can do LACP. This. Given how small the price difference often is between unmanaged and semi-managed (aka 'smart') switches these days, it just doesn't make sense to buy

Re: [pfSense] OT: Good network switch for 10 machines?

2014-09-23 Thread Kurt Buff
BTW - forgot to make some specific recommendations - I like this switch a lot: http://www.provantage.com/hewlett-packard-hp-j9803a-aba~7HEWN2JW.htm Oh - don't forget to get the firmware current on anything you get... Kurt On Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at 10:28 AM, Kenward Vaughan kay_...@earthlink.net